I often search for people in my past for various reasons. Last month, I was looking through old newspaper clippings from when I was a reporter at The Morning Sun (working parttime at Off Broadway for
Tari Lynn Barrera and a full time student at CMU). I did a feature story on fashion back in 1986 — I also appeared in some of the photos. (The perks.)
I remember the shoot well because I had met this young guy (younger than me) named Keith Johnson. He was a townie who had a Tyson Beckford-ish vibe before Tyson was even on the scene. I think I just saw him at a store. Tari Lynn and I convinced the shy kid to do the photo shoot — and that he was a natural.
Fast forward December 2021 when I am looking at the yellowed, worn newspaper clipping I dug up from the bottom of my box containing my portfolio.
I think I actually posted the photo on Twitter that night.
Then I Googled his name and Mt. Pleasant, Michigan. It was a long shot because it was so many years ago.
An obituary finally came up.
I read it, but refusing to believe it was him because there wasn’t a photo. Then, I saw the words “freelance model.”
I still didn’t believe I had the correct person. I think I spent 5 hours that night searching, Googling, reading every name, every detail of that obituary. Looking at archives of MPHS yearbooks.
Ancestry.com (my new fav search engine)
I read all of the comments on Legacy dating back to December 2004.
I was deep down an emotional rabbit hole.
I could not find ONE photo of this “Keith Johnson” in the obituary which also included words like “your senseless, untimely death.” More clues.
I started another search: news articles about accidents with his name, Chicago.
And there it was: “Chicago man killed in a Florida park
By From news services
Chicago Tribune
•
December 07, 2004
A Chicago mortgage broker and part-time model from Chicago was found stabbed to death last week in a Florida state park.
Keith Johnson, 37, was found the morning of Nov. 30 by a boater at Lovers Key State Park in Ft. Myers Beach. The Lee County Sheriff’s Office said it is investigating the slaying, but would not release many details about the crime.
The News-Press of Ft. Myers reported that Johnson, who was visiting Florida for business, died of stab wounds to the back and chest. A working cell phone and wallet with ID were found with his body.
He is survived by his wife, and 3-year-old daughter.”
Still… there are no photos.
I can’t confirm it. I refuse to believe it.
I search Facebook for any member of his family— these folks are like ghosts, I think out loud. I find a woman with the same name in the obituary who is a model. She is stunning. I message her but she understandably doesn’t respond; she was only three at the time. But the model thing connects. It makes sense because Keith and his wife ( there were photos of her and the daughter on the obituary comments) are insanely gorgeous.
But I am not convinced likely because I am still so emotional about losing my dad, that I am not even ready to believe that an acquaintance from College has died.
I even message the Lee County Sheriff Cold Case. They said they would update me.
I just need a photo.
Why aren’t there any photos?
I just need confirmation.
But it hounds me that this trained journalist can’t confirm this story. I don’t want to believe it. Those of you who went to Journalism School know the rule: “Your mother says she loves you, confirm that shit.”
Anyway, last night I take a much needed emotional break from watching Women of the Movement: the story of Emmett Till’s mom’s battle to get justice.
It’s way past 11 p.m. EST
This time I go through the friends of people I think maybe related to see if any of the same names appear in the obituary and the Friends list. (Yes, I am invested.)
I see three names connected in a guy I think may be Keith’s brother. (Their Facebook pages are not public so I cannot see photos). One guy was James Griffith. I put Keith’s name in HIS profile, and hit the search function.
My heart was beating fast with anticipation. It seemed to take forever, but it was only one second.
There it is: “My cousin Keith Allen Johnson, RIP” with a photo of that trademark intense glare, perfect jawline.
I don’t know if it was the emotions from being reminded of the brutal killing of Emmett Till, or the confirmation that 18 years ago another Black man was murdered and there has been no justice…but
I am shaking…Heartbroken.
I just stare at those eyes.
I get up, drink some wine.
I stare at the photo on Facebook, drag it to my crowded Desktop…compare it to my clipping — then message the cousin because even though I see the two photos, I need to hear the words.
Surprisingly, the cousin responds a few hours later.
He confirms it. “Yes, he was murdered.”
He wrote that Keith was murdered “by two white men,” stabbed in the heart and tossed in the gutter. He said police know who the men— who fled to Canada— are yet would not extradite.
I only knew Keith for a short time. I just remember him being young. I remember that smile. I remember him being shy. Funny. Humble about his good looks. The kind of guy that you would label “a sweetheart,” maybe even a “mamma’s boy.”
I reread his obituary and the comments from his friends, wife and daughter— dating back to 2004 — it all confirms that at age 37, Keith Johnson had indeed grown to be even more amazing. (read below, link in comment)
He was a husband, father, real estate wiz, caretaker of an elderly mentor, retired US Navy Vet, and a parttime model.
“I will love you forever.”
His cousin called me. We talked. He told me how amazing Keith was in his short life. How there has been no charges.
I expressed my condolences, and thanked him for the confirmation — the confirmation I didn’t know I needed 18 years ago.