Makoto Shinkai – Beauty Creates Emotion

Note: major spoilers for 5 cm/s, Minor spoilers for The Garden of Words and Your Name.

Shinkai’s Rise

LISTEN

Makoto Shinkai is a name you might have heard mentioned here or there, and for good reason. His most recent film, Your Name, has taken the film community by storm, most notably for its amazing visuals and beautiful music. Your Name follows a trend of just pure beauty that Shinkai has put out throughout the years. Here’s an example of how Shinkai elevates fiction over reality, from his 2013 film, The Garden of Words.

Yeah. When I first saw this album of pictures posted by zixyon on imgur, I could barely differentiate the anime world and the real world.

Shinkai’s films all contain or are focused around romance, and it’s fitting that he uses such breathtaking visuals to accompany a romantic theme. His goal in every movie is to explore the emotional connections that humans build with each other and scenarios that can change how we feel. He also heavily uses the idea of distance between people, whether physical or emotional. As I said with Satoshi Kon’s movies, one really just needs to watch one of his movies to get the full experience. Where Kon uses bombastic imagery and surreal plots, Shinkai uses subtle characterization and quiet human interaction. Scenes are often without dialogue, just body language and beautiful backgrounds.

More than anything however, Shinkai’s art creates awe. His long-panning shots over pastoral landscapes and shots of rainy cities are orgasms to the eyes.

Here are some examples:

https://vimeo.com/228661227

There’s a reason why Shinkai’s 2011 film 5 Centimeters per Second has been widely considered as 5 Wallpapers per Second instead. The sad song is even more powerful if you consider that the real life singer wrote it for his dead girlfriend.

https://youtu.be/c_fmGgA5ShY?t=10m2s

(skip to 10:00 for the scene if timestamp doesn’t work)

This montage scene from The Garden of Words is absolutely breathtaking and it tells so much about the characters with so few words.

Emotion of Color

LISTEN

Color in any form of media greatly changes how we perceive the emotions of the story. Here, we can see a shot that Shinkai essentially reused, except with a completely different color palette that corresponds with the themes of the anime.

Train in The Garden of Words

Train in Your Name

The tone of The Garden of Words is far more down to earth and subtle, with the focus on a schoolboy and a woman that skip school and work on rainy mornings together, both of whom have no idea of direction for their lives. It revolves about how they struggle to find themselves and thus the colors are more muted and earthy.

By contrast, the plot of Your Name is far more surreal, with a boy and a girl swapping bodies in their dreams, lends itself to a far more dreamy color palette. Shinkai portrays the magical realism setting perfectly with a blurred vignette and brightened colors.

In general, Shinkai’s color usage is visceral in evoking the emotion of the characters and the mood of the movie.

Shot Composition:

LISTEN

Every director uses shot composition in order to help the movie flow better for the viewers, and Shinkai also uses his shot composition to add on to the themes of his story. In 5 cm/s, the main character, Takaki, is stuck in life, forever in love with a girl that he was in a relationship in that moved away. He’s constantly thinking about her – every day, every night- which leads to the deterioration of his relationships (He shrugs off a girl, Kanae’s affection because he’s always thinking about Akari, the girl who moved) and eventually his spiral into depression at the end of the movie. It’s a movie with a lot more substance than I can just describe with one short analysis, but I wanted to impress you with how much thought Shinkai puts into his direction. From /u/nap682 on Reddit,

“The quadrant system I talked about shows Balance on screen in Act 1, the characters usually are equally on the right side of the screen and the left, and they move left and right equally. However, as the film goes on, Takaki shows up more and more on the right side of the screen, looking left. Now think of the movie like a book. since it’s Japanese, the story moves right to left. Takaki frequently is on the right side of the screen, looking left but rarely actually moving in that direction. He’s always looking for Akari in his future but she simply isn’t going to be there. An aspect that he refuses to accept so he remain stagnant on the right side of the screen. As comparison, Kanae has a similar issue but after she has her talk with Takaki about “only doing what you can”, her next scene is her running off screen to the left, moving on into her future. It actually isn’t even until the last scene of the movie in which Takaki moves off screen to the left, the railroad crossing, and that scene is very interesting in and of itself. Akari may or may not actually be there, but the important part to recognize is that Takaki turns backwards to the right to try and see her. He’s looking into the past. It is almost like the final trial of if he will move on with his life or run back into his past to search for Akari once again. But he no longer chases after her. He shows a bittersweet smile of accepting that the past is the past and he must continue on into the future, turns, and walks off stage left. And thus the movie ends with a somber piano. Now the piece itself might seem just plain sad but it has a minor pick up in pace periodically that I mark as those moments where, even though life is sad, you hold onto a happy thought long enough to push you through to the next chapter of your life.

I hope that you have been incentivized to watch some scenery porn, and encourage you to look for these kinds of directional tools in other media forms. It’s pretty cool.

References/Learn More:

Garden of Words pictures: https://imgur.com/gallery/VoxHX

Analysis of Your Name OP: https://youtu.be/oikCyrqFLso

Quadrant System:  https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/33dqx9/wt_5_centimeters_per_second_a_story_of_longing/?st=j842eaoj&sh=6e634e37

Or just watch the damn movies.

Satoshi Kon’s Dreamworld

Note: contains major spoilers for Perfect Blue and Paprika, minor spoilers for Inception, Requiem for a Dream and Black Swan

Note #2: because I think music enhances the reading experience, I have taken some soundtracks from the relevant anime that could add to the mood or something like that. Also they give a better idea of what the film is like. I don’t know. Enjoy.

Note #3: This is by no means a comprehensive review of animation and cinematography. In order to get a full idea of what I’m talking about, just go and watch the anime. If you want to learn even more afterwards, then look at my links below – my objective is to introduce people to certain aspects of animation.

An Introduction

Music 

Satoshi Kon was an animator, film director, and screenwriter from Hokkaido, who died sadly in 2010 of pancreatic cancer at the age of 46, leaving behind five works of avant-garde audiovisual media.

While Satoshi Kon might not be very famous in the West, his cinematography and style has influenced some of the most famous contemporary western films.

In particular some scenes from his movies were straight lifted – Darren Aronofsky, maker of films such as Black Swan and A Requiem for a Dream purchased the rights from Kon’s Perfect Blue and used one of his scenes in Requiem for a Dream.

Aronofsky’s Black Swan also shares many plot similarities to Perfect Blue in transforming an actress’s life into a living psychological hell. A scene from Perfect Blue of the main character looking at her reflection in a train is also used in Black Swan.

Christopher Nolan’s Inception also includes a few scenes that seem to pay homage to Kon’s Paprika, which is also about a dream machine.

Is Inception a rip-off of Paprika?

Is Inception a rip-off of Paprika?

However, I’m not saying that Aronofsky and Nolan ripped of Kon, but Kon’s influence is undeniable across the world of film.

The Dreamworld

Music

Kon produced four movies and a 13 episode TV show, and all of them except one focused on the blurring between reality and dreams. This is where he takes full advantage of the animation medium, and where I believe he excels above all others. While Nolan’s Inception might be a mindfuck with all the changes in dreamworlds (note: I have not seen Inception, only clips and plot summary), I don’t think it can compare to what literally amounts to LSD trips.

The Youtube channel “Every Frame A Painting” has a great video on Kon (which I’ll link at the end, and probably tells this story better than I do), and he says “the opening four minutes of Paprika has five dream sequences, and every single one of them has a frame cut – by comparison the first fifteen minutes of Inception has four dream sequences, with only one match cut.”

Here is the opening in question (the only version I could find was subbed in spanish, sorry):

When I first saw this scene, I was stunned and confused. I had already watched a few of Kon’s earlier movies, so I knew what to expect, but I was not prepared for this. There are constant breaches in the barrier between dreams and reality, with people turning into cameras, dinosaurs, guitars, and dolls dancing in the streets. There are even more trippy scenes later – this parade scene is just a major WTF moment.

The scenes in Paprika are just so incredibly surreal that it’s absolutely impossible to draw the line between dreams and reality – the entire time they’re joined eternally together. Paprika also makes statements about the internet and our consciousness as humanity, statements that seem much more relevant as our lives become increasingly interconnected to the web.

However, as we’ll see with Perfect Blue, Kon’s techniques are not just for detailing a scientist’s LSD trips – he can create a variety of emotions, including terrifying the fuck out of us.

Music for this section: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBxsRiG5eYU&feature=related

Perfect Blue is about Mima, an idol, and her descent into madness after she leaves the idol scene to become an TV actress and eventually gravure model. A stalker surfaces as pictures inside of her room are posted to the net and her every action is written in complete detail (such as how she gets off the train). She gets faxed paper filled with the word “Traitor”. Scenes become increasingly disorienting and insane as people around start getting injured – first, a man delivering fanmail gets severely injured from an explosive trap set up in the letter. Mima agrees to be fake raped in her TV show, but the scene is so graphic it’s hard to tell whether or not it’s real (and also gives Perfect Blue its R rating, it definitely deserves it) Eventually it’s impossible to tell the difference between dreams and reality again. At many points in the film an event might seem to occur in Mima’s life, only to be revealed instantly that it was part of her acting job. As people connected to her show “Double Bind” get killed off, and an imposter called Me-Mania that runs the stalker website claims that they are the real Mima and that the current Mima is a fake, Mima’s sense of reality becomes shattered. Loosely and confusing scenes are repeatedly shown as Mima’s life falls apart, and the audience begins to wonder what Mima’s brain is thinking. An alter ego Mima shows up in her idol dress

and begins to torment her endlessly during her production and in her daily life. It’s hard to show with clips just how disorienting this editing is – it takes a full watch to truly comprehend how disturbing it can get. (Also

Watch a clip of Mr Nerdista from YT explaining just how brilliant Kon’s editing is here. Only watch until 5:05 or just stop after he talks about Requiem for a Dream, because there are major spoilers in this video.

Why Anime?

People not accustomed to anime might ask why animation has any advantage over live action in this sense. Here I’ll quote Kon himself in an interview:

“I think editing for live action and animation share some similarities but are fundamentally different. If you show a photograph or a painting for five seconds, the volume of information is different. However you shoot a photograph or film, there’s a lot of visual texture, colour and extra information to take in. Whereas in animation, only what is intended to be communicated is there. If I had a chance to edit live action, it would be much too fast for audiences to follow. In animation, the audience understands this momentum.”

Because anime is essentially created from just the imagination of the directors and scriptwriters and artists, the options you have to display scenes are larger. Kon took advantage of this and cemented himself as one of the greatest anime directors ever.

Sources

Interview Source: http://www.midnighteye.com/interviews/satoshi-kon-2/

Paprika/Inception comparison: http://www.agonybooth.com/inception-ripoff-paprika-26479

Kon picture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Kon

Perfect Blue pic: http://blog.alltheanime.com/perfect-blue-horror/

Learn More – If you’re actually interested in anything I said

Kon in general: https://youtu.be/oz49vQwSoTE – pretty much this blog post, just better and in video form.

Perfect Blue is Scary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJmK5SOeQBc

Color Theory in Perfect Blue: https://youtu.be/2D9iZfedoiY

Perfect Blue Analysis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3u1J3BIfwG4

Animation in Perfect Blue, getting down to the nitty gritty of frame time and art techniques: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPbrjieNFtI

Interview with Satoshi Kon: http://www.midnighteye.com/interviews/satoshi-kon-2/

Making of Paprika Pt. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlHCdi6ASE0

Making of Paprika Pt. 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFGa4tpM-iM

Paprika Analysis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vwtSxbq8Hqo

Match Cuts: http://www.davidbordwell.net/blog/2011/05/25/graphic-content-ahead/