Two Ethical Lessons
I’ve learned many ethical lessons throughout the course from the lectures and case studies that will stay with me during my life and career. One lesson was the Five Ethical Principles since they can aid you in making moral decisions in not only journalism, but many other areas. These Five Ethical Principles are Aristotle’s Golden Mean, Kant’s Categorical Imperative, Mill’s Principle of Utility, Rawls’ Veil of Ignorance, and Judeo-Christian Persons as Ends. It’s interesting how each one goes more in depth and branches off into different sub-categories. Each one has different strengths and weaknesses and is applicable to real-life situations. One other lesson that I learned was the use of the Potter Box by Ralph B. Potter, a professor at the Harvard Divinity School. I learned that the box helps to guide decision making and that it has four steps, or boxes, that can be done in any order or multiple times. The boxes are Empirical Definition, Identifying Values, Identifying Principles, and Choosing Loyalties. I thought it was interesting that two different people who are analyzing the same problem could reach different conclusions and that the same person could analyzing the same issue could reach different conclusions if they use the box at different times. A third lesson that was reinforced in this course was making smart decisions and good choices in everything you do, from school to life to work. We saw multiple times from examples in this course that one bad decision can have a huge impact on your career and life. Everything from plagiarism, to fabrication, to conflicts of interest, and many others can be detrimental if not taken seriously. Not engaging in any of these wrongful acts will only help you in the long run and will only positively impact everything you do.
One Case Study that Impressed Me
One case study that impressed me the most was one of the first we discussed in the course, the case of Stephen Glass. I thought it was extremely interesting the extent in which he went to try and cover his tracks and truly how far he was able to go without being caught. The fact that 27 of his 41 stories contained some bit of fabrication while he worked at The New Republic magazine was detrimental and hurt his career and relationships. His addiction of lying was especially interesting because it almost seemed like a drug to him. Glass couldn’t stop doing it and continued to do so. Besides the fabrication, his continuous lying to his coworkers and friends about his made-up stories didn’t help his case. It seemed so odd that someone who seemed so dedicated and into his job could have done something like this. One part of his case that still amazes me is how we able to sort-of recover from what he did. Obviously, he can’t go back to the status where he was, but he somehow managed to somewhat get his career back on track. There is no solution to what Glass did, and this case especially goes to show that lying in your career will ultimately hurt you in the end and that even if works out for a little bit, it will ultimately catch up to you. This case is definitely one that will stay in my mind forever due to how impactful it was and the lessons learned.
Impact of the Course on my Future Career and Life
Since ethics is such an important topic in the journalism world, this course will have a great impact on my future career and life. In some of my other courses we’ve briefly discussed topics such as plagiarism, fabrication, and others, but never went as in depth and into them as we did in this course. The lessons over the course of the semester and case studies especially helped to really put certain topics into perspective and see real world examples of them. It shows how to act and not to act as a journalist. For example, fabrication, with the case of Stephen Glass, never works out for you in the end and only ends up ruining your reputation, career, and life. I thought I knew a decent amount about ethics before this course, but this course really expanded my current knowledge and taught me new things that I didn’t know before. After senior year, I plan to attend graduate school to earn a master’s degree and I think this course helped to sort of set the tone and standard for whatever I choose to do in the future. I think even if someone doesn’t choose to go into the field of journalism, a lot of the lessons can still be applied to other things and professions, which is definitely a big takeaway from this class.
Reflection on the Couse as a Whole
I overall really enjoyed COMM 409 and all the lessons that came from it. Ethics is an extremely important topic in the field of journalism and I’m glad that we went in depth into it throughout the course over the semester. As far as the course went logistic wise, it was straightforward, structured extremely well, and pretty easy to follow and know what was going on. The course schedule I thought was really helpful and helped to show what the course was about and the lessons we would learn. I would have to say that the case studies were my favorite part of the course since they helped to break the course up and split it between lessons and presentations, and because they helped to provide valuable life lessons and examples. When the class first started, I thought it would be just learning the rules of journalism and what not to do, but the fact that it was interactive and used a lot of real-life examples made the course interesting and enjoyable. Overall, this was a great class that really taught me a lot about the journalism and media field and has provided me with the tools to be successful in the future.