Writing the Body, Writing Yourself

Through collecting a representative variety of women’s and men’s magazines and finding ads for both “feminine hygiene products” and “masculine hygiene products,” I am able to uncover many messages regarding gender. Just looking at these two sets of ads, it is obvious that they differ in terms of the body image presented. Women in feminine hygiene ads tend to appear reserved, and sometimes even insecure or embarrassed. The women’s ad that I found most representative of “feminine hygiene products” is an ad for U by Kotex pads that is promoting their 3D Capture Core to protect women from leaks. There is a woman with her back to us, who can only been seen from her shoulders to her butt. This closed off body language in addition to the fact that we do not see her face reveals a sense of insecurity surrounding her that we can assume results from her period. She is wearing underwear with the words “save the undies” on them. There is also a caption that says, “Your period is between you and your pad. Not you and your panties.” What this caption is really saying is that your period is for you and you only to know about. It is not only obviously uncomfortable to experience a leak, but more importantly, it is embarrassing to have a leak that someone else notices, especially a male. The woman in this ad represents the notion of “body shame” that females experience from menstruation. Despite the fact that half of the world population consists of females, all of whom most likely have, do, or will menstruate for a decent portion of their lives, “body shaming” in regard to menstruation is still a typical thing for females to experience. Of course no female wants to have an embarrassing leak, but we can at least expect a leak to be less embarrassing if it is noticed by another female rather than a male. Therefore, such “body shaming” in regard to menstruation is logically a result of male judgment toward it. This ad overall is playing on women’s insecurities surrounding menstruation and the “body shaming” that men impose regarding it. It emphasizes the main body image message that females receive from hygienic ads, which says that they should be hygienic and beautiful yet discreet and even secretive about how they stay that way. On the other hand, the masculine hygiene ads that we see present a much different body image. The men in these ads appear to be cool and confident, often flaunting their hygiene. The men’s ad that I found most representative of “masculine hygiene products” is an ad for American Crew shampoos, conditioners, and styling products. There is a man in focus who is driving a convertible with a smile on his face. He is calm, cool, and collected. Based on his composed body language we can tell that he is quite confident. There is also a woman in the background staring at him with an admiring gaze. Clearly she is attracted to such confidence. The slogan of this ad is “Groom to Win.” It is accompanied by a caption that says, “Wherever your victories take you American Crew offers a complete range of shampoos, conditioners and hair styling products that allow men to look their best. Because your victory doesn’t stop on the inside.” It can be inferred that the man in this ad is “winning” and “victorious” due to the fact that he uses American Crew products. Even in ads for products that may seem to be more on the “embarrassing” side for males to buy, such as hair loss products and male thongs, the men are presented as confident and completely secure with themselves. They do not experience any “body shaming.” Other men who buy these same products are not likely to impose “body shaming” on them, and unlike the “body shaming” that men impose on women in regard to menstruation, women do not impose such “body shaming” on men. This allows them to be confident on the inside as well as the outside, unlike women who are insecure in both regards involving menstruation. These differences in feminine and masculine hygiene ads imply that “gender ranking” exists in our culture, which “ranks” or values the male/masculine sex/gender over the female/feminine sex/gender. As mentioned, these ads exhibit female “body shaming” imposed by males, yet not male “body shaming” imposed by females, but rather admiration toward males instead. I believe that because males have a higher gender “rank” or value over females in our culture, women allow men to control how they feel about themselves. Men, knowing that they are of a higher gender “rank,” do not submit themselves to “body shaming” by females as they feel that their “superiority” dismisses any “body shaming” that may be imposed upon them. Instead, the females in these ads who are seen as looking up to the males in admiration seem to portray the idea that women yearn for the confidence that men possess, which results from their higher gender “rank” and frees them from the burden of “body shaming.”

5 thoughts on “Writing the Body, Writing Yourself

  1. kow5198

    I really like the images you selected – though I too was confused when you said the women in the feminine product ads looked reserved but it really got me thinking about how submissive women are portrayed in media and how this sometimes is catered toward a male audience in order to show domination or such. Even so, women are still being treated as property or objects of men and it’s wrong and sends the wrong message to young and impressionable girls and boys who will grow up thinking that these ads represent “reality” and “expectation.” In order for society to change its thought and standards for men and women, the media has to change theirs.

  2. Carly Jane Keefer

    I thought it was interesting that you said for the feminine hygiene products you thought the women looked reserved and insecure/embarrassed. While I was looking at ads I found quite the opposite of this. I saw a lot of women athletes competing in their sports and looking strong, although I do not think that is an accurate representation of what a woman looks like on her period. I also found it very interesting how you brought up the way men will body shame women, but women do not usually body shame men. I agree with that statement. It is very interesting to see the different ways men/females are represented in the ad industry.

  3. rnk5048

    I liked how you discussed the shame women feel based on what men might think of them. You then also highlighted that the reverse rarely happens. Men are built up to feel more confident in all of these areas, while women are told to hide. I think it is interesting that you attributed this to gender ranking. I think these issues also have to do with men and women’s roles in society. Women are told to be more submissive while men are supposed to be dominate. I feel this is another area that promotes the confidence discussed in the ads.

  4. Catherine Rose Roerden

    I like your view on the images you selected. These are good representations of both the female and made hygiene ad. The fact that we can not see the woman face definitely shows the fact that she is embarrassed which is shaming women for normal bodily functions which you clearly stated. I also think you pointed out the main difference between these two particular articles well. That main difference is the insecurity of women and the security of men. Males are almost idolized in comparison to females in these types of ads. As a whole this puts men in a more confident position while women are made to feel less confident without certain things or because of certain natural things such as having a period. Overall nice choice of ads and good job with showing the problem with ads body shaming women.

  5. tlb5496

    I really like the images you selected. What I got from reading your post is that these ads are putting women to shame and men to great heights. Women experience a natural menstrual cycle and these hygiene ads are trying to tell us that we need to do something about it because it is not a good thing. On the other hand, these hygiene ads for men are trying to enhance these “perfect” features they already have. Once they use that lotion, shower gel, or cologne, women will be all over them. They will get what they want, including sex. There is a mixed message concerning these hygiene ads for men and women. Women are being used as objects and are being told that these products are to help us cover up our imperfections. These companies needs to change the way they choose to advertise their products because it is not fair to women who are receiving negative messages about themselves.

Leave a Reply