I was not planning on writing this post on this particular topic until I was standing at THON during the final four. I was standing with my arms around the people beside me swaying from side-to-side as we watched the video of all of the Four Diamonds children who were taken too soon. I noticed that all of the girls around me, myself included, had tears streaming down their faces with no regard for who noticed. On the other hand, all of the boys were choking back their tears and trying to not let their emotions get the best of them. Therefore, I want to look at gender inequality on the basis of emotional expression.
Why is that men feel the need to hide their emotions? Not just their tears, but at times their happiness as well. If emotion were on a scale of 1-10, society makes it seem that men should only ever range from a 4-8. Men should never hit the low of sadness or the high of happiness.
On the other hand, women are expected to be emotional. Society expects that women will range from a 1 through a 10 on the perceived scale of emotion.
It is discriminatory for society to assume that men should be strong, tough, and un-emotional. Yet, it is also discriminatory for society to assume the women are too emotional, sensitive, and fragile. The gender inequality flows both ways in this situation.
There is biological evidence to support this notion of emotional inequality. Studies have shown that women, in comparison to men, experience stronger and more frequent negative emotions. Women are more prone to negative stimuli and will elicit a stronger response to negative stimuli. Contrastingly, men are more susceptible to stimuli that are perceived to be threatening or erotic. Although there are a large number of studies that confirm gender differences in emotional experience, the differences are smaller than expected. This insinuates that much of the difference then comes from societal pressures and expectations.
At a young age, boys and girls are equal on the scale of emotional expressivity. They both hold onto to their parent’s hands in crowded places, sleep with stuffed animals, and give their friends hugs. Around second grade, all of this starts to change. Boys are taught not to be “sissies”, to “take it like a man”, and that “real men don’t cry.” Once this change occurs, there are several emotions that take on a different meaning for men and women.
Image Courtesy of Youtube
Anger
Anger is seen as a manly emotion and obviously women do feel anger too, but it is taboo for them to express this. Women often mask their anger with sadness. For example, if a woman is upset with her boyfriend for not returning her calls she may say that she is sad about the situation when in actuality she is angry with him. She feels the need to not express such a harsh emotion for fear of judgement.
Aggression
Aggression is another emotion that is viewed as appropriate for a man but not a woman. If men are angry about something and need a way to let out their emotion and they punch a wall or kick something it is not viewed as harshly or negatively as a woman in the same situation.
Fearful
Fear factor is something that a woman can have, but not a man. During a scary movie, it is normal and almost expected for a woman to grab onto a friend or boyfriend’s hand at certain points. Meanwhile, if a man were to do this he would likely be called “gay” or “weak” by one of his friends.
These are just a few examples of how specific emotions are meant to be expressed by one gender exclusively. As I have been writing this post, I have come to the realization that it is amazing how much influence societal pressures have on the way that we act and react. This seems like an obvious statement, but I think it is something that we are so accustomed to that we fail to realize it at times. It reminds me of the Margaret Mead Gender Study.
Image Courtesy of Common Direction
In the study, there were three groups where gender roles were very diverse. The Tchambuli had a genuine reversal of Western culture roles, with the woman being the dominant, managing partner. The Arapesh had equality for males and females with the ideal that they are both cooperative, unaggressive, and responsive to the needs and demands of others. The Mundugumor ideal was undisciplined, very violent males and females. All of these are very different from Western society.
It is amazing to see how different gender roles can be based on how society expects them to be. Can you image what it would be like if the US adopted a Arapesh view?