TED Talk Reflection & Controversy Ideas

After completing my TED Talk, I am very satisfied with my finished product. Of course, it wasn’t perfect, but it did have some features that I am personally very proud of. Firstly, I thought I did a great job using my visuals to develop my words, and I think my enthusiasm really made my Talk more interesting than it could have been if I seemed monotone. I had a great tone that resembled that of a TED Talk’s, and I am personally very satisfied with the vocal aspect of my speech. There were a few stumbles and a few examples of diction that I would have liked to fix, but overall, I did well verbally. In addition, I liked my slides very much, and thought they were organized in a nice fashion. My group also found my visuals very appealing, and they made the talk much more engaging and easy to follow. However, they pointed out my occasional verbal stumbles, but they recognized that my recoveries were very fast, which helped make my word fumbling less distracting.

For our history of a public controversy project, I had a few ideas in mind, with the first idea being what I mentioned in class, the electoral college. I know there have been a lot of challenges to the current voting system in the United States, and this would be an interesting topic to explore, especially being in an election year. Personally, I don’t have a set hatred on the electoral college, I just disagree with the fact that a candidate can win 51% of California and get every single vote in the electoral college. I think it should be partitioned based on actual votes in each state, and the electoral college should be proportioned to the actual votes to maximize representation of the American public.

My second idea has to do with ‘cancel culture’ and the rise of political correctness. Many things have been destroyed because they were deemed offensive, such as the Washington ‘Football Team,’ and it would be interesting to explore why this rise in sensitivity came to be. This topic, unlike the electoral college, may be harder to research, and specific reasons for shifts might be hard to identify. Finally, I thought of the idea of capital punishment. This topic is a widely debated controversy, and is interesting to consider past punishments and how it was viewed in the past. Personally, after reading Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood, I have a strong grasp on this topic and would be able to support our claims with examples from Capote’s text. Capote, being sympathetic to victims of capital punishment, would provide a strong counterargument against the morality of capital punishment.

S. rubra, the Sweet Pitcher Plant

d

S. rubra sketch [1]

Congratulations on reaching my last blog entry on the final species of Sarracenia! We have now discussed seven species in detail, and we have arrived on the eighth species: the sweet pitcher plant. This is one of my least favorite Sarracenia, but it is by no means a boring plant. I personally just find the uniqueness of the other species to be more exciting than this plant, which is somewhat similar in appearance to three other Sarracenia. Any who, this plant is found in the southeastern United States, in the Florida panhandle, southern Alabama and Mississippi, and parts of Georgia and the Carolinas.

d

S. rubra range distribution [2]

As I previously discussed, this plant isn’t too unique, and is similar in appearance to S. flava, alata, and oreophila. The plant is known as the ‘sweet’ pitcher plant due to the fruity fragrance of its bright red flowers. The plant features fairly short, erect tubes that look like the stereotypical Sarracenia form. They are much smaller than S. flava, but resemble their basic structure. Unfortunately there isn’t much else to talk about with this plant, so instead I am going to discuss its mess of nomenclature and taxonomy.

e

S. rubra ssp. rubra [3]

If you thought last weeks discussion of the confusion taxonomy of S. purpurea was bad, then you’re in for a real treat with S. rubra. This species consists of many subspecies and varieties, some of which are considered by some to be their own species. For this blog, I will present the nomenclature decided upon by Stewart McPherson and Donald Schnell. Introducing, the confusing, subject to change taxonomy of S. rubra.

S. rubra ssp. rubra –  this is the most common variety in the species, and is olive green colored. It does not get very tall, at only around a foot, and has a rather long lid. In addition, this plant also has nice pinstripe venation. It is found only in the Carolinas and Georgia.

s

S. rubra ssp. rubra; note the small stature and long lid [4]

S. rubra ssp. alabamensis – often considered its own species, this subspecies is found in Alabama (obviously) and is very rare. It is short, and often mostly green. This plant is so rare that on the few sites where it grows in the wild, it is federally protected. It is incredibly hard to get in cultivation. I have one, but it is a seedling and may not survive long in the NJ winter.

ss

S. rubra ssp. alabamensis; note the green color [4]

S. rubra ssp. gulfensis – this subspecies has particularly large pitchers, with a bulgy upper neck. It typically has strong red veins, and can be seen in the Florida gulf coast.

d

S. rubra ssp. gulfensis; note the wide pitcher neck [4]

S. rubra ssp. jonesii – the mountain pitcher plant, also sometimes considered its own species, this plant is critically endangered in the wild due to changing water tables and urbanization. It is about twice the size of most S. rubra, and is often found growing on granite slabs in the middle of a stream.

d

S. rubra ssp. jonesii; note the deep red venation on the tall lid [4]

S. rubra ssp. viatorum – this is a true mystery plant! Often called an ‘undiagnosed taxon’ or an ‘ancestral’ plant, this is a plant that not much is known about. It is smaller than gulfensis, and has a steep pitcher shape.

d

S. rubra ssp. ancestral; note the steep pitcher tube [4]

S. rubra ssp. wherryi – often considered a variety of alabamensis, this plant is found in Alabama, Mississippi, and Florida. Some varieties of this plant are large for S. rubra, and are prized in cultivation.

e

S. rubra ssp. wherryi; note the vertical tube [4]

As you can see, the nomenclature of this species is… disgusting. There is so much controversy over this plant, but more importantly, some of its varieties are near extinction in the wild. This is unfortunate, and like S. oreophila, if nothing is done, these beautiful plants will be gone forever.

Thank you for reading my blogs! I hope you can take something away from these posts, and hey, maybe you can try growing some of these plants yourself! S. x Judith Hindle is my recommendation. They are easy to grow, just keep them wet all the time, and let them die off and go dormant in the winter. They are perennials! To close my blog series, I will post some of my favorite photos of my collection that I hope to expand in the future.

d

S. x Adrian Slack, a S. moorei hybrid and one of the most sought after pitcher plants of all time.

S. x mitchelliana hybrid

s

S. purpurea ssp. purpurea and 3 sundew all native to the NJ Pine Barrens (D. intermedia, D. rotundifolia, and D. filiformis)

de

S. x Green Monster

e

S. purpurea clump

e

Gorgeous S. leucophylla HCW Clone F

d

S. psittacina var. okefenokeensis

d

A trio of S. leucophylla

d

My collection in early spring

  1. https://sites.psu.edu/countravioliwhw/wp-admin/post-new.php
  2. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c8/Sarracenia_rubra_range.png/220px-Sarracenia_rubra_range.png
  3. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/LjzaM-cpNas_NKJRKLv_0WKRGs98fu5in9RWCQCBfg576PyokOpgQhfuQwb6GkpnFOQ5Bg=s114
  4. http://www.sarracenia.com/faq.html

S. purpurea, the Purple Pitcher Plant

d

S. purpurea sketch [1]

We have come to the second to last species of Sarracenia! This species hits particularly close to home for me, as it is the only pitcher plant I can find where I live. In fact, just 20 minutes away from my house is Webb’s Mill Bog, an isolated boardwalk through a bog in the middle of nowhere in the New Jersey Pine Barrens. This small state park is home to the purple pitcher plant, as well as some other carnivorous sundews (D. intermediaD. rotundifolia, and D. filiformis).

s

The ‘hidden’ boardwalk at Webb’s Mill Bog, NJ [2]

Of all the species of Sarracenia, this species has by far the largest range. It is the only pitcher plant found in Canada, and the only one that can survive harsh winters. Clearly, the purple pitcher plant is very hardy, which makes it very easy to grow. This was actually the first pitcher plant I ever owned, and my S. purpurea collection has grown extensive since then.

z

S. purpurea range distribution [3]

The pitchers on this plant are short and fat low lying cups that can grow to a foot in length, but rarely get that large. The plant has a lid, like all pitcher plants, but the lid does not cover the pitcher opening. This lid, often frilly and veiny, is lined by particularly dense downward pointing hairs, and does not prevent rainwater from filling the pitcher tube. Often, these little ‘cups’ are completely filled by water. This plant looks nothing like any other species in this genus, so it will rarely be confused with other species. The plant produces a purple/red flower and often has purple pitchers (though colors can vary), hence the name “Purple” pitcher plant. The pitchers, although most frequently purple, can range from greens, oranges, and pinks. In fact, pitchers that are exposed to a lot of sun tend to become a deep purple, whereas shaded pitchers tend to stay green.

d

S. purpurea; note the distinct short pitchers [4]

Interestingly, this plant produces digestive enzymes in large quantities only when the plant is young. As the plant matures, it relies less on these enzymes, and instead relies on commensal organisms, including bacteria and the pitcher mosquito (W. smithii) that lays its eggs in pitcher fluid. As the larvae hatch, they feed on decaying insects in the pitcher tubes.

d

An exceptionally red S. purpurea [5]

The complications begin once the varieties of this species are discussed. Some argue that this species has a few subspecies, whereas others believe these subspecies are completely different species. For this blog, we are going to classify these ‘separate species’ as subspecies (ssp.). This may be confusing, so don’t worry too much about the Latin names, just appreciate the huge variety of this species. Actually, scratch that. The varieties/subspecies are so highly debated and aren’t agreed upon, so I cannot provide information on these. Instead, I will list one interpretation of the taxonomy of this species, and will provide their range as well as distinct features. The differences between these varieties are so minute that I won’t spend much time on the minutia. Instead, I will denote them by their most important characteristics.

Varieties… or… subspecies(?):

S. purpurea ssp. purpurea – this is the northern subspecies of this genus, found anywhere north of Maryland/Virginia and west into Canada. This  subspecies is exceptionally temperature resistant, and can survive temperatures far below freezing. In fact, my specimen of this subspecies froze completely solid, and survived without trouble.

d

S. purpurea ssp. purpurea; note its basic characteristics [6]

S. purpurea ssp. venosa – nearly identical to the above subspecies, this plant is the southern subspecies, found on the east coast south of Maryland/Virginia. In the Chesapeake, where the purpurea and venosa ranges meet, it can be difficult to differentiate between the two subspecies. However, in general, this subspecies tends to be larger than the northern one. It is also less tolerable of extreme cold.

f

S. purpurea ssp. venosa; note its similarity to S. purpurea ssp. purpurea [7]

S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. burkii – yes, I know. Quite the name. This species is found on the southern most range of the species, and is identified by its unique pink flower and pink ‘pot bellied’ (fat) pitcher. It is sometimes referred to as its own species: S. rosea.

w

S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. burkii; note the pink color and pot belly [8]

d

S. ‘rosea’ flower [9]

S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. montana – found in the western Appalachian range in the mountains, this variety has a distinct ‘gnome hat’ shaped lid, where the ruffled edges meet at a single point.

S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. montana; note the triangular lid [9]

S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. montana; note the triangular lid [10]

As you can see, this is a very unique species of Sarracenia, and one of my favorites. It tends to form large, dense clumps of pitchers, and sometimes it can be hard to find the growth point with all the pitchers! As for my collection, I have three S. purpurea ssp. purpurea, one hybrid of purpurea and venosa, and two S. purpurea ssp. venosa var. burkii.w deThe first two images are of my huge S. purpurea ssp. venosa, which has over five growth points and has completely filled its pot. The third image is of my purpurea and venosa hybrid, which was lost in shipping for over a month and was cradled back into health by me this summer. Finally, the smaller S. purpurea ssp. purpurea is my first ever pitcher plant that I thought I killed, but it somehow survived. To conclude, I want to announce that I will be doing a blog on hybrids after my final blog on S. rubra. As a quick little sneak peak, I have many hybrids of S. purpurea, which are among my favorite because they feature the fat stature of this species, and thus have a lot of personality.

  1. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/8iJ3xIGa6WnlbU2MxyhT9Ub6c0vccD9JS6rez_ddJJ64c6nCewS-b0s2G85vVw5GGygZAVk=s85
  2. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/eMXrow6fANC7paxr3j5K86-vKBgbRvXX7tXuoXT2c2qOhEYcfb9taBOdblhbI8ZcFupE=s128
  3. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/IfhpEJx8eumRrFf4yONdqnKZjfTJDD5Lj6rsBvSA-GhT2CDC2URnnnnSqoUOvud8sXb2-A=s111
  4. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/yQXidaMqIMgnzZ95ZvmgXK4OOvA6TUQYbguYw1tQzXM9Er6mCFOBYK82-9chuSIUmKjeWg=s85
  5. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/DTD3DEF6U-Vx63iWljrXNQoRRYz3e7sjAIFkv_uitCElsIh6pGfdy_rx4y6Y-zbpjt9GN3o=s128
  6. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/NZ0X21fGG8kwP9OGz7zgRgRlmJJb02N26Krx58vyk2T4c4rwp2SaKT6olZQekNYZ9Rp3=s85
  7. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/G2DONEQAQ_j-2tnmQ8AbPMzNDPEyOVeSmaX4womjZNOnU4bKbsIMAWMHe4ivaEHMgt0b7Q=s128
  8. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/zQhMr9HKoPL7kpQALi3NcNn6WE9sROZczC3S-0st2DcbuvLwCPECH1h_eH-Gbi8HNqyEyy0=s85
  9. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/dNuxrAWw4t8Y2Ef9jN1bgmC3roNTGdD4SerE2FZl3XHubDaBU_sNoa3eCNHeqEcXg9nVIg=s85
  10. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/VgYF5o80EvwLc1S85kEcrUXBtvy5YCT93kg98BzNmtkIfaEBTTW9CHsOzsanCnGZo0GZ=s128