For my last post of the year, I figured it’s time to be a bit introspective. Here’s the thing – we’re all the villains in someone’s story. That’s expected. But what happens when you look in the mirror one day and realize that maybe, just maybe, you’re the villain of your own? More of my story later, but obviously, today we’re going to be talking about Black Swan.
Natalie Portman’s devastatingly beautiful portrayal of prima ballerina Nina illustrates her descent into madness as she struggles to fully encapsulate the darkness of Odile in her company’s production of Swan Lake. She constantly compares herself to her eerily identical alternate, Lily, and begins to wake up with injuries after intense hallucinations. On opening night, Nina confronts Lily, and Nina stabs her, seemingly killing her. But by the final act, Nina realizes that she has actually stabbed herself, and collapses on stage after a flawless performance.
On the surface, the film asks viewers if whether pain is the common denominator to all meaningful art. However, beyond this, it raises questions on how far we can remove ourselves from the consequences of our psychosis. It’s a hard pill to swallow: we can blame insanity on the pressure to be perfect, or say it’s from past trauma, or even make the inept men around us shoulder the guilt. But if at the end of the day, we let the crazy consume us, if we let it control not just our reactions, but the conscious actions we take, who else can we blame but ourselves?
To look at the movie through an even narrower lens of the female gaze, Nina’s plight is a shared experience between all women: internalizing society’s standards and forcing yourself to adhere meticulously to them till you break. Jane Fonda’s character in another film, My Life So Far, has a quote that’s always stuck with me:
“This toxic striving for perfection is a female thing. How many men obsess about being perfect? For men, generally, good enough is good enough.”
The bar for men is so low even I can’t limbo under it. And I’m like five foot. So that should tell you something. But regardless, the drastic differences in the scrutiny men and women are held under is enough to make any woman go absolutely balls to the wall insane. This whole blog centers on that idea! But I guess the idea I’m trying to leave you all with is that yes, being a crazy girl is nothing to be ashamed about. Choose to be your most unhinged self everyday because God knows more people need the wake up call only a truly feral woman can provide. But don’t let the hurt make you bitter, or jaded, or cynical. I’ve been there… Boy, that was a bleak couple months. And there’s never a reason to be like Nina, and harm yourself over what has been done to you. There’s always hope for us crazy girls <3 (and if not, we can all just pivot into being old crazy cat ladies).
I love the quote you used for this blog, women in not only western society but more often than not are forced to be “perfect” but truthfully what does it mean to be perfect? We’re always forced into this box of being perfect that it quite literally drives us mad when men are not held to the same standard and are always the ones pushing the ideology that there must be a perfect woman. I love how your blog feels like I’m having a conversation with one of my friends because we definitely have had this conversation a great number of times and getting a different perspective and being able to compare it to media really broadened my mindset.
Is it bad to say that Black Swan is one of my comfort movies? I’m so glad you decided to pick this film as your last blog post because it encapsulates so much about the innate struggles of being understood as women. This blog as a whole I think really brings a new light to the idea of female rage and identity. Your writing draws readers in and is always so funny!
I really enjoyed this post as it was a great reminder that crazy is human too. I particularly liked your note about perfectionism in women and men. I know that perfectionism has been something I have struggled with my entire life. In my desire to be perfect, I feel eaten up inside and like I am worthless if something is not perfect. However, guys seem to care very little about being perfect because they do not have societal pressures placed upon them to be perfect like girls. My perfectionism is something I am working on, but I loved that your post validated that it is okay because this is a sign of humanity. This post was a great lesson and very entertaining to read, so great job!