Comment Writing Program

l

What?

Associate Editors will write a 30 to 60 page Comment

When?

The CWP takes place throughout editors’
second year of law school

Benefits?

Legal writing, legal analysis, editing, & Bluebooking skills

Questions?

Contact
Dickinson Law Review
Managing Editor

What is the Comment Writing Program?

A Comment is a piece of legal scholarship written by a student that identifies and critically analyzes a specific, unresolved legal problem and offers a solution. Comments are shorter than Articles—typically 30 to 60 pages in length—and much narrower in scope. To make the Comment-writing process manageable, the Dickinson Law Review organizes the research and writing process into assignment modules spread throughout editors’ second year, constituting the Comment Writing Program (CWP). See an example of a CWP assignment schedule here. The CWP provides tremendous potential for growth, as well as invaluable and transferable research and writing skills.

As an Associate Editor, you will spend a lot of time authoring a Comment. Your Comment may cover any pertinent legal topic of your choosing, provided it meets the standards detailed in each module. The Dickinson Law Review will publish a select amount of the Comments in its forthcoming volume. Once published, the journal will distribute the volume to electronic resources such as Westlaw and Lexis, as well as subscribers and law libraries in printed format. You can view previous student publications here

Is participation in the Comment Writing Program mandatory for membership?

Yes! Participation in the CWP is non-negotiable and should factor into your decision whether to accept an offer to join the Dickinson Law Review.

Is there any support offered to Associate Editors as they write their Comment?

Absolutely. Throughout the CWP, Associate Editors will have two editors assigned to them. Your Comments Editor will serve as your primary editor. The prior Editorial Board selected each Comments Editor based on their writing and editing skills as well as many other invaluable qualities. Additionally, each Comments Editor was trained by their predecessor. In other words, your Comments are in great hands. Your Comments Editor is the first set of eyes on your submissions, and you will meet with them regularly as you navigate the CWP to receive revisions, feedback, and support. Your secondary editor will be the Managing Editor or Executive Comments Editor who will further support your journey. 

How are Comments chosen for publication?

The Editorial Board selects Comments through an anonymous grading process near the end of the spring semester of the Associate Editors’ second year of law school. Selected editors will then prepare their Comments for publication during their third year of law school.