This week, I stumbled across an article that was published last month (April 14th) by BBC reporting on how the French brand Dior was facing backlash for posting a photo on Instagram that many said was discriminatory towards Asians. The post portrayed a woman pulling back her eye very close up. Critics of the ad claimed that the post showing a woman pulling her eye back to make it appear more narrow was racist against the Asian population and their appearance. There was also backlash of the backlash, where some commenters were quick to criticize the people claiming that Dior was racist, talking about how sensitive people can be and how there was clearly no ill intent in the post. You can see the photo that was posted below. The caption was “Channel your feline fierceness.”
When first reading this article, I had a few different feelings. On one hand, I am of the opinion that this post was 100% not intended to be racially insensitive, and it really meant to highlight and accentuate the makeup on the eye of the woman. On the other hand, I see where people take issue with this post and I can’t believe no one in Dior’s marketing room caught the problem.
As strategic communicators, we need to be cognizant and aware of all of the audiences we are trying to reach. The article states that China is one of Dior’s biggest markets. To me, it is imperative to cater to that population as a marketer, and how this post was not flagged as potentially problematic is beyond me. It reminds me of some of the examples from this week’s reading in the textbook and in the instructor commentary: The black child in the hoodie that said “Coolest Monkey in the Jungle,” the Mexican character who looked more like a knife-wielding bandit than a spokeman, and the list goes on. Unintentionally racist ads are the worst kind of ads, because not only does Dior look racist, they now look stupid for even posting this in the first place. It’s a great example of why we need to study multicultural marketing and the best practices to be successful in this endeavor. You can’t adopt a one-size-fits-all mentality anymore in today’s advertising culture. Knowing your different markets and making sure all groups can relate positively to your advertising is the most crucial aspect of successfully selling products or services today, and this article showed me a glaring example of why!
To read the article fully, here it is! https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-65229901
Thanks for reading this week’s post!!