1. After looking at the three sample papers, which introduction paragraph do you think identified the ad’s context and commonplaces the best? Explain why in a few sentences.
Olympic Moms really drew me in just from the opening paragraph. The introduction was strong and gave a strong idea about what the ad was about and where they were going to take the reader through their paper. It was very well written and made me want to continue reading about the commercial. I also appreciated their thesis statement. It was clear, concise, and summed up the whole introduction nicely.
2. Which paper’s organization did you like the best? What strategy did the writer use to develop different topics for the paragraphs? Explain in a few sentences.
I liked the organization of the Eminem and Chrysler paper. The author organized it a little differently than the other papers and followed their own path. The paper developed really nicely and got all of the points across clearly even with the different organization. The other papers seemed to list the topics they were going to discuss and then discussed them in that strict order.
3. Which paper captured your interest the most? Why do you think that is? Explain in few sentences.
The Olympic Moms paper captured my interest the most. I definitely think this was because of the introduction. The opening paragraph makes or breaks a paper for me and this author did really well. They had a nice voice and experimented with structure and punctuation while getting their points across clearly. It was easy to follow and well written. It also felt fairly relatable at some points which made it hold my interest more.
4. Now, turn to your own paper draft. Write a sentence or two about the context(s) and commonplace ideas you are going to identify in the opening paragraph.
The commonplace my ad focuses on is the desire to help the less fortunate. I plan to make this a very strong point in the opening so that I can really elaborate on the commonplace and pathos later in the paper.
5. Now, let’s craft a few thesis statements. Try this formula for your own paper topic:
“By/Through [using these specific tactics], [this ad] [analytical verb that answers does what?] [in order to do what?].”
Attempt 1: By the use of commonplaces, rhetorical devices, and a strong pathos argument, the TOMS advertisement entices the general public into buying their shoes in order to benefit those in need.