The great phone debate has waged on for ages: if you ask a group of people whether they prefer Samsung or Apple, chances are that they will disagree — many times strongly. With constant commercials and releases for new phones, bombarding us with gigapixels and high-tech processors, it is understandable. We are so invested in the companies’ unending competition that we forget what is important: fundamentally, both phones are the same. Not in the sense of their aluminum casings nor liquid crystal displays, and not in the sense that they perform similarly complex actions. It is what we can find deep down, before we step into the store to get a better look, and before executive meetings decide how to advertise. What truly matters is the production of these phones. Across the supply chains of technological companies, unethical practices abuse unprivileged workers.
At the beginning of the chain, workers, namely child-workers, carry rocks outside of rugged crevices only their nimble bodies can pass through; and under the blazing sun, they sift through the stones, searching for cobalt that will power lithium batteries used across the globe. The reality of the filthy, lung-corroding caves deeply contrasts the sleek stores in which tablets are sold, tablets which more fortunate children across the globe use to learn things that those mining never will.
The majority of this cobalt production originates in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where children work over 12 hours a day. Along with 10 cents an hour, these children are paid with life-long diseases that will further handicap them.
“I would spend 24 hours down in the tunnels. I arrived in the morning and would leave the following morning … I had to relieve myself down in the tunnels … My foster mother planned to send me to school, but my foster father was against it, he exploited me by making me work in the mine” (Amnesty International, 2016).
Unfortunately, not all workers in these mines leave. Many workers die, crushed under collapsed rocks, their bodies and stories buried under the debris of corporate greed and our own materialism.
As the supply chain proceeds, workers continued to face abuse in factories. In a Chinese Apple factory, reporters found workers in 80-decibel factories filled with chemicals, enclosed by doors with tiny openings. Their dormitories were no better, covered in debris, without showers to clean themselves. “Chinese recruiters play up the chance to build advanced consumer electronics to attract the millions of typically impoverished, uneducated laborers without whom the production of iPhones and other digital gadgets would be impossible” (Bloomberg, 2018).
In order to help the people abused by such a horrific system, we must keep companies accountable. But companies evade these questions: “Amnesty International contacted 16 multinationals who were listed as customers of the battery manufacturers listed as sourcing processed ore from Huayou Cobalt. One company admitted the connection, while four were unable to say for certain whether they were buying cobalt from the DRC or Huayou Cobalt. Six said they were investigating the claims. Five denied sourcing cobalt from via Huayou Cobalt, though they are listed as customers in the company documents of battery manufacturers. Two multinationals denied sourcing cobalt from DRC. Crucially, none provided enough details to independently verify where the cobalt in their products came from” (Amnesty International, 2016). These statements prove highly contradictory — how can multi-billion dollar companies manufacturing such innovative technologies be unable to investigate the state of their own material producers?
Maybe that isn’t the right question to ask. Maybe we should ask how the gleam of money outshines the lives of millions.