Last semester I took PLSC 3: Comparative Politics and one of the topics we discussed was data and reach done to see if there are some cultural determinants of democracy. Montesquieu states the most optimal type of government for a country was one that “leads men by following their propensities and inclinations” and “best agrees with the humor and disposition of the people in whose favor it is established”. In other words, people should be governed based on what they are like. With this in mind, I would like to analyze the current United States of America under some of these cultural factor lenses to help better understand why the country became one of the most staggering proponents of democracy.
One of the most prevalent theories in this subject is cultural modernization, which claims that as a country develops economically, cultural changes will inevitably occur, that cause a shift toward democracy. Some argue that industrial growth is a direct cause of a rise in democracy, but those in favor of the cultural modernization theory believe the is an extra shift concerning culture in the process. If this theory holds true it would be safe to assume that the most prolific economy would have the most economic culture. This does seem to be the case with the United States, whose president is heralded as the “leader of the free world”, also boasts the largest GDP and has been for quite some time. While cultural modernization theory helps explain how largely agrarian economies adopt more democratic values as they expand, America’s economy had the cocoon of democracy to nurtures itself into the massive industrial butterfly it has become. All based around the capitalistic mindset citizens have cultivated for decades. The American Dream, a commonplace synonymous with the identity of the nation, is grounded in the fact everyone believes they have the freedom to succeed in the U.S.
A change that cultural modernization theory cites as being one of the most important for the suitability of country for democracy is a civivc culture. Civic culture is defined by 4 major factors, the first of which being how much individuals feel they can influence a political decision. During this past election, this aspect of America was very prevalent. The left especially, collectively used their rights in order to set in motion the change they desire and end an administration they believed to be diminishing the same democratic values they made full use of. With the election being fairly tight, even greater emphasis and responsibility was placed on those voting in states where the decision could be finalized such as Georgia and Pennsylvania. Social Media and technology has inflated the averages persons belief on how much their voice and opinion can influence policy, to the point where some feel leaving a hateful comment will bring the legislation they desire to light. The second factor is a positive feeling toward the political system. Although some may have their qualms with things such as the electoral college and government aid, this past year made many in the states realize this government is the only system that will effect them and the have to abide by, so even though tensions are high between both parties, most still have faith the country can achieve the state they personally desire if who they prefer are in charge. Through both mask requirements and stimulus checks, Americans recognize the influence the government can have on their daily lives and this translates to faith in its effectiveness. Interpersonal trust is the third factor for civic culture and even with the nation so divided a form of this can still be observed. Party alignment plays a huge role in politics here in America, and that is true more than ever. The left and right both feel their values are threatened by the other, but on the other hand many are placing large amounts of faith in the representatives they support. Trump became a megaphone for many who felt overlooked and disregarded, echoing their sense of unease towards topics like immigration and liberal policy. Biden is being regarded by some as a savior, here to right all the wrongs of the Trump administration. The line in the sand has never been so defined, but each side takes great solace in banding together with those like minded. Finally, the fourth factor is preferences for gradual societal change. Change can not come any quicker for either side, with the “make America great again” slogan becoming a conservative rallying cry and liberals pushing for leaps in social justice and acceptance. However the want for change is still there, meaning citizens are not content with things the way they are.
Historically, America has been an outstanding example for democratic values, with studies showing it has been the most stable democracy of all. The country has developed underneath a constitution written hundreds of years ago and still proving to be effective and with the state of current social issues, there will be no other optimal form of government in the future.
sources: https://us.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upm-assets/81275_book_item_81275.pdf
https://eml.berkeley.edu/~ygorodni/gorrolpolculture.pdf