Since the beginning of entertainment media, representation of various aspects of diversity have changed much over time, even just in the past ten years. In the United States, film and broadcasting companies have made huge progress in representing different ethnic groups, races, sexualities, and people with all kinds of differences. However, today, I still find some issues with representation in media that is consumed today.
One issue I find in popular shows has to do with preformative representation. Although this happens less with media created recently, in shows from the 2010’s that are still popularly consumed/rewatched, It’s often obvious that media companies include diverse characters just to appear inclusive. For example, in shows I watched growing up, diverse characters always take on the “sidekick” role, and are often flamboyant and caricatured. One example can be seen in the show Good Luck Charlie, with the main family characters, love interests, and recurring characters are white, with really only one person of color featured-Ivy. Ivy is the protagonist’s best friend, and she is only used for small comedic moments, with no storyline that follows her. She is only there as a small side character. This unfortunately is seen in a lot of media my generation grew up consuming on Disney Channel and Nickelodeon. ALthough this media was popular some time ago, it is still detrimental because these shows are so popular that they are rewatched by younger generations.
Another issue I see with representation is that characters with different ethnicities or sexualities are often exaggerated, and used for comedic purposes. The “gay best friend” trope is very common unfortunately. Gay characters are often only sidekicks or small recurring characters that play into the stereotype that all gay men are flamboyant and only ever speak about their sexuality. This is truly harmful, as this gives close minded people an idea that gay people all act a certain way-which is extremely untrue. My best friend is a gay man, and he very much dislikes the way gay men are portrayed in many shows, as it almost feels offensive to him-like the shows are discreetly making fun of a gay stereotype. One day, when we were scrolling on Netflix, we came across a movie titled “GBF,” standing for “Gay Best Friend.” Even just the title plays into people not seeing the depth that a gay character on screen could have. Nowadays, there are many gay characters represented well on screen thankfully, but it will be difficult to undo the harm that past shallow representation has done.
Similarly, with characters of different ethnicities, they often play into stereotypes and “do up’ their accents for comedic purposes. In one of my favorite shows, Gossip Girl (also with an all white main cast and only two recurring characters of color who are literally classified as minions of a main character), Blair’s (the main character) maid is from Poland. In real life, the actress is Polish, but has a slight accent. In the show, she plays up a huge fake accent, which is supposed to add into the comedy of her character. Again, in shows we watched growing up, like Jesse, this was a common trope. Ravi, a character from the show, highly exaggerates his Indian accent. My dad has a Serbian accent, and he has expressed how it frustrates him that people make fun of his accent or think it is funny. I believe that the media we consumed growing up has played a huge role in the normalization of that. We watched “funny” or “sidekick” characters use their diversity for humor. Again, although this has changed in recent years and improved, there is so much media that is so adored out there that does this that it will be difficult to undo.
Although i have much more to say on this topic, the research I have done so far and my opinions have lead me to these two deliberation prompts:
Has the media’s portrayal of diverse characters caused the public to see diverse people in a different manner?
Should diversity and differences be able to be used for humor in entertainment media?
Articles used:
https://researchguides.dartmouth.edu/filmstudies/representation
https://time.com/6305012/hollywood-diversity-report-asian-representation/