My dad grew up in Peters Township, near a small area in PA called Canonsburg. In Canonsburg, on a road called Hahn Drive, there was rumored to be a murder. Throughout his childhood, neighbors and classmates always chattered about the legend of Hatchet Jack. The story goes like this:
There once was a man who lived on Hahn Drive at a beautiful estate with his father and mother, who was sadly dying of cancer. In his mother’s last days, her sister moved in to help care for her. Upon her death, his aunt stayed there with his father. One day, as Hatchet Jack returned from a day of work, he asked his aunt for a glass of orange juice. She responded sharply and said he was way too old for her to wait on him, prompting his father to get involved. He told Hatchet Jack to pack up his things and be ready to move out in 30 days. Infuriated by his father’s words, he went upstairs to fetch his 20 gauge shotgun. Hatchet Jack came back downstairs, shot them both in the head, unloaded the rest on his father, and dragged their bodies to the basement. There, he used the chainsaw (ironically enough, not a Hatchet) to brutally cut their bodies into pieces. Hatchet Jack collected what was left of their dismembered bodies into twelve garbage bags, and buried them in the orchard.
My father works for the state Department of Environmental Protection, and has for quite some time. In his late 20’s, he was working in Philly when they hired a man named Sherman Richardson. They got to talking and discovered they had grown up in the same area and went to the same high school. Sherm, as my father came to call him, had grown up in Canonsburg on Hahn Drive. Because they lived within 15 minutes of each other, Sherm and my dad would occasionally share rides back to Pittsburgh.
Eventually, it came time for my father to move back to Pittsburgh and work there, after my parents wedding. In the last weeks before he made the move, he made a couple trips across Pennsylvania, one with Sherm. Weeks before, my father had mentioned to Sherman that he was looking for a place to live with my mom, aunt, and uncle, and he had suggested my father live in the old house on Hahn Drive that his sister now rents out. It was a beautiful property, and of course, my dad loved the idea. After corresponding with Sherm’s sister, he found that the address and house described fit perfectly the description of Hatchet Jack’s haunted house. This remained in the back of Dad’s mind, however, he figured he would rent it regardless. Hatchet Jack must have just been an old renter gone crazy. So on the car ride, he asked, “So Sherm, what ever happened back there at the house? Didn’t some kid go berserk and kill his relatives?” Having always been pretty quiet, Sherman didn’t say much in response; he kinda mumbled something and looked away. My dad continued, “Some crazy renters, huh?” Sherm agreed. “Well I sure hope that guy doesn’t turn up while I’m renting there. It’s a good thing I’ve got some guns of my own, not afraid to use them if I gotta. Don’t need some nutcase showing up at my door.”
They drove the rest of way to Pittsburgh, and Sherm showed him the property, driving up the long driveway and locking the gate behind him. They walked around the house and the orchard, and my dad told Sherm, he would definitely be in touch with his sister. Meanwhile, my dad had requested that my aunt ask around town and find out Hatchet Jack’s real name. Later that week they were together, and he asked, “Cindy, did you ever find out who committed those murders?” She responded, “Yeah, I think his name was, uh, Sherman Richardson.”
Everything my father had said and done with Sherm came flooding back to him. Everything from the many moments they spent alone, to the threats he had made in the car. Naturally, when my mom and aunt found out, they refused to rent the place. My father called Sherman’s sister and made a deal. He got the rent lowered, promised to do some work around the place, and asked for the number of Sherman’s parole officer. They rented the house for a couple months until Sherman wanted to move home. He even suggested that they simply become his roommates, rather than forcing them to move out, but my parents figured it was best to move out. My uncles hunt on Sherm’s property to this day.
When my father called the parole officer, he discovered that Sherm was a model prisoner, got out early on good behavior, and hasn’t had a problem since. Maybe he had a psychotic break, or just snapped under a lifetime of abuse, but he returned to a normal life after prison. He got work, married, and died years later of a heart attack while fishing.