For this final civic issue blog post regarding the Catalan conflict, I would like to go over how I’ve lived the political and social struggle personally as a citizen of the region during the past 18 years and also review certain steps that have been made towards finding the peace between separatists and unionists. From my own experience, one of the greatest errors made by many Catalans in the past decade of turbulent politics and confrontation has been the refusal to dialogue and acknowledge the other side’s arguments. Nationalists have always stood firm on their beliefs of becoming an independent nation, regardless of some of the drawbacks their “success” might incur, and the Spanish government has refused on countless occasions to sit down with the Generalitat (Catalan government) in order to draft possible solutions to the conflict without having to regret the loss of one of its most precious autonomous communities. Crispation, hatred, and the lack of acknowledging other people’s viewpoints have pervaded the politics of the Catalan conflict and have stained the images of both sides, unable to come to a consensus on certain aspects such as economic management or social malpractices. Above all of this, digging into society more so than just politics, I’ve also seen first hand how many friendship, professional or even family relationships have been torn apart due to disagreements on such a sensitive topic like Catalan independence has been. I’ve also been witness of shameful episodes of people verbally and sometimes physically abusing themselves on public streets because one or the other have felt offended for the Catalan independence symbol or the Spanish flag. This is the sad reality of my community, people cannot hang a Spanish or a Catalan flag from their balcony without being victims of sabotage attacks or insults.
So, what can the Spanish and Catalan governments potentially do in order to bring the social conflict to a halt and restore the long-lost harmony we’re all looking for at the end of the day? One of the most popular and welcomed proposals in recent years has been a series of open dialogue sessions between the Spanish and Catalan governments where the latter would essentially be granted, in contrast to all other communities, the privilege of discussing or debating certain policies or reforms that the former might want to implement that would directly affect the northeastern region. Catalan separatist leaders, whom have held the throne of the region’s government for the entirety of the 2010s decade, were the ones to demand this innovative practice, and fearful of sparking even more tensions, the Spanish government accepted. This solution has allowed dialogue to prevail after the unfortunate events occuring at the end of 2017, and has made Catalans feel slightly more appreciated and recognized, which is in essence one of their greatest desires. However, this does violate the theoretical equity that should exist among all 17 autonomous communities in terms of power and say. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if now any other region feels that lack of recognition given the preferential treatment Catalonia has earned by basically being the naughty and rebellious child. To compensate this, the president along with his/her cabinet could think about establishing this “table of dialogue” (this is the literal translation from Spanish) with all other autonomous communities too.
Following the escalation of tensions during the end of 2017 and start of 2018, the Catalan conflict suffered another major turn of events when the Catalan president and primary ministers during the illegal referendum and declaration of independence were sentenced to prison stays ranging from 8 to 13 years. Naturally, this enfuriated many Catalans and created another spike in the number of natives that would favor the rupture with the western European nation. In order to restore some of the faded peace, the current government of President Pedro Sanchez decided to reprieve the sentence of these separatist leaders. Although controversial, the decision has been acknowledged to be a step forward in the search of restoring order with Catalonia. It’s absolutely true that according to the penal code, there were certain actions made by the condemnded Catalan leaders that were deserving of long jail sentences, but the tag of “political imprisonments” would’ve always hung over the cases and the current Spanish government wasn’t willing to accept it. Ultimately, a political conflict of this nature should ideally be tackled away from the courts. Politics are all about emotions and what people are able to transmit, and the straightforward nature of the judicial branch lacks the flexibility to properly adjust to a civic issue like the one being discussed.
With the dialogue sessions in place and the separatist leaders out of jail, the Catalan conflict has settled in the minds of many in the past couple of years. Tensions have deflated and this has been proven to have even helped Spain in its quest of preserving Catalonia. In recent surveys performed by La Vanguardia, Catalonia’s most important and refuted media organization, 53% of the about 7 and a half million Catalans prefer to continue being a part of Spain, with less than 45% actually positioning themselves in favor of independence. Dialogue with the now free separatist leaders have also allowed Spain to dodge any possible self-declaration attempt such as the one in October of 2017. Taking the Catalan conflict as an example, it can be deducted that for many, if not all civic issues, acknoweledgement, understanding, and dialogue between people must prevail in order to resolve these complex conflicts. At the end of the day, we all have our personal selfish desires and if we’re not able to control them as a society, issues such as the Catalan independence movement will not only cease to appear, but also strengthen with time.
Sources:
https://sciencenordic.com/denmark-forskerzonen-politics/is-there-a-solution-in-sight-for-catalonia/1458224
https://www.lavanguardia.com/politica/20211220/7937624/conflicto-catalan-solucion.html