In 2011, 35% of African-Americans and 33% of Hispanics in the United States lived in poverty. Also, as Nate mentioned in one of his previous civic issues posts, “1 in 36 Hispanic men ages 18 or older is in prison, 1 in 15 black men ages 18 or older is incarcerated, 1 in 9 black men ages 20-34 is behind bars. Prison inhabitance is dominated by men, yet the same trend follows with women. Ages 35-39, 1 in 355 white women is in prison. In the same age group, 1 in 297 Hispanic women is incarcerated, while 1 in 100 black women is behind bars.“ With these statistics, it paints a pretty bleak picture for one fourth of America’s population that watch more television than Whites and Asians combined.
While researching for what to post for this week I came across an article written by Carlos Cortes which revolved around how “TV Stereotypes Ignore Dramas of Life.” And while it goes over stereotypes such as “criminals, crime fighters,” and “hustlers,” I want to focus on the article’s comments towards family sitcom stereotypes; it seems as though the author is describing these shows in a negative light. Although Cortes outwardly portrays Cosby Show and I Love Lucy in a positive light, his comment that it “[a]ccording to most fictional TV, minority poverty seems to be a thing of the past” becomes almost ironic. It implies that some sort of smack on the hand should be given to these shows for not showing how a large piece of minorities actually live. But my question is: should these sitcoms really be ashamed of not depicting this real lifestyle?
After all, television is used by many people as an escape from their daily lives and allows them to experience another. Do these people that live in poor conditions need a reminder of what they live every day? Would you want to watch a show with the family about a husband and wife struggling to raise their children, worrying about feeding them, and ending with uncertainty as to whether the family will survive? I think these sitcoms provide hope for these types of families that people have gotten out of worse conditions and made it into a better state than past generations. It gives the audience something to strive for whether they are knowingly thinking about the show’s effect on them or not.
Now I don’t think that television shouldn’t show what poverty looks like. After all, how can others help with this issue if they do not have an idea of what poverty looks like. I’m just not sure if family sitcoms should be that medium.
http://www.statehealthfacts.org/comparebar.jsp?ind=14&cat=1
http://www.medialit.org/reading-room/minorities-tv-stereotypes-ignore-dramas-life
http://www.nielsen.com/us/en/newswire/2011/american-video-habits-by-age-gender-and-ethnicity.html
http://www.nij.gov/journals/270/criminal-records-figure2.htm