Monthly Archives: September 2013

The Pros and Cons of Exchange Life

There are many assumptions people make about exchange students and the lives they lead, and these conjectures are made by those who have never been on a long-term exchange, those who have never met an exchange student, or those who have met an exchange student but thought they were snotty and conceited. Maybe they were snotty and conceited, or maybe they were just extremely homesick and/or had no idea what you just said. Here is a list of pros and cons to being an exchange student that I hope will a) inspire you to become an exchange student and b) gain a better understanding to the difficulties of exchange life.

PROS:

-You get to travel. A lot!

-You get to learn a new language

-You get a long break from your “old life” and learn a “new life”

-You get to stay with amazing host families that bring you everywhere and feed you with vast amounts of delicious things

Escargots fit under that category of "delicious things" believe it or not

Escargots fit under that category of “delicious things” believe it or not

-Maybe the Rotary (or another organization) has sent you to a country you never even considered going to, and would never have the chance to go otherwise (a few examples: Indonesia, South Africa, Russia…)

-It’s relatively inexpensive for an entire year abroad — free room and board, free food

-Everyone thinks you’re super cool and foreign. Yes, even the French thought it was cool that I was American. Either that or they would make back-handed (and sometimes blunt) insults about my country, but hey, you gotta roll with it.

-If you’re taking a gap year, you don’t have to do well (or anything at all) in school. If you’re doing an exchange during one of your years in high school,  good luck passing your classes in a different language!

-You become super tight with other exchange students near or around your town and meet people from all over the world

-You get some pretty good stories to tell all your friends and family (until they get sick and tired of all your cool stories)

-You gain huge amounts of confidence as well as worldly knowledge

-You get to be rather independent (if you’re paired with a chill host family)

-Last but not least– parties? Only all of the time.

 

CONS:

This is the outsider's perspective, and yes, complaining about our choices can get old. But from an exchanger's perspective, we know what's up.

This is the outsider’s perspective, and yes, complaining about our choices can get old. But from an exchanger’s perspective, we know what’s up.

-You have to leave everything you know and completely immerse yourself in a different culture for a year (harder than it sounds!)

-You have to leave all your family and friends behind for a year

-You might have to learn a new language from scratch (some of my exchange friends got to France knowing only how to say ‘thank you’, ‘hello’ and ‘goodbye’ in French)

-You don’t know anyone going into your country, and have to make friends and get along with your host family in a different language

-If you have some sort of issue, you have to formulate it in a foreign language.

-Ever heard of the Exchange Student 25? It’s like the Freshman 15, but with better food.

-Your town or country might be unsafe, so the Rotary and/or your host parents don’t let you travel alone or stay in town after dark

-Sometimes host families and their exchange student don’t get along. Horror stories to come in later posts (none are mine thankfully!)

-You have to deal with the religion and social barriers of your country. For example, my French host sister went to Indonesia (a predominantly Muslim country) the same time I was in France, and she had to go to a religion course in which the teacher taught the students that women were lesser beings than men.

-You will get homesick, you will miss your friends and family, and you will miss American conveniences such as free public toilets and Spotify (no, it’s not available in Europe!)

-If you’re taking a gap year, you have to go to high school for a 5th year (worse than it sounds)

-The 4 main rules of Rotary are the 4 D’s: No drinking, no driving, no drugs, and no dating. They’re pretty relaxed on the no dating rule however (I think they just want to avoid the creation of international offspring). If you can do any or all of these in your home country, you can’t in your foreign one.

-Learning a foreign language and having it be spoken to you 24/7 is the most exhausting thing until you reach fluency. You have to be paying attention all the time or else you’ll miss something

So you see? You know that Brazilian student who seemed to be glaring at you in class? She was probably just missing her dog back at home. You should never make assumptions about how difficult something is until you experience it, and the first two months of my exchange year make up probably one of the most challenging parts of my life. But luckily, the pros always outweighed the cons for me.

I think I'll let this meme sum up my entire blog for me.

I think I’ll let this meme sum up my entire blog for me.

Ideas for Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Since I’m a Fine Arts major, I thought I’d take the opportunity to base this essay on a work of art. Here are a few ideas of pieces I might like to analyze:

Who’s Afraid of Aunt Jemima by Faith Ringgold

This quilt was created during a tumultuous time for African Americans as well as the artist’s own life, thus it contains elements of pathos and a strong historical background. Its content as well as the medium used in the piece would make it an interesting work of art to analyze.

Les Demoiselles d’Avignon by Pablo Picasso

This well-known cubist piece would be interesting to analyze due to its comment on women during the early 20th century. It shocked the art world during the time of its creation, so its historical context would be interesting to talk about too.

Guernica by Pablo Picasso

Yes, another Picasso piece, but I do need 4 pages of analysis and his works are rich in symbolism which makes for a perfect rhetorical analysis paper. Another good thing about Picasso is that he takes a stance on issues, and my thesis has to explain how this work of art argues a point. Again, the historical context of the Spanish Civil War would be important to talk about because it is the basis of this piece.

Headstone Portrait of Claudia Glass by Jerome Witkin

Contemporary artist Jerome Witkin often utilizes broken-down scenery to create meaning in his pieces. In this case he makes a statement about the broken-down party girl after a night out with death’s skull looming in the corner. The title also gives me something to analyze, but I’m not sure I’d have enough to talk about for 4 pages.

 

 

 

 

Day One of Exchange

Bye Bye State College!

Bye Bye State College! (Notice I’m wearing an odd jacket with buttons on it– I’ll get to that later.)

This is the last picture taken before I left on my 11-month excursion to France. It was taken on August 28th, 2012 in the little old State College airport at about 6 o’clock in the morning. Looking back, it was a pretty emotional day for me. (Notice my blotchy face and watery eyes? Yep, those are tears, people.) Every time I would even think about the fact that I wouldn’t see my parents, nor my friends, sister, or dog for almost an entire year, tears would quickly form in my eyes. I even got sentimental about leaving State College, along with my American culture. Would I ever see you again, oh delicious peanut butter? Wait for me, Lion Shrine, okay? I’ll be back before you know it.

I’ll skip to the getting to France part.

I arrive in Paris along with several other exchange students who will be in the same Rotary district as me (loosely based on the government department regions in France). I’m exhausted from traveling and waiting in airports for about 17 hours, and I just want to meet my host family. So I hop in the car with one of the other exchange student’s host parents, and drive 2 hours directly South of Paris to a town called Bourges. My host family, the Brouards (pronounced “Brhoo-arhd”, as if you have marbles in your mouth), live about 15 minutes outside of Bourges in a suburb called St Doulchard.

Meeting my host mom, Sylvie, for the first time, meant performing the dreaded “bise” that I knew I would have to do. The bise is what the French call their cutesy 2-kisses-on-the-cheek routine. In my head I could picture myself swerving right as she swerved left, thereby getting caught in a swerving head battle, being extremely cautious not to accidentally touch lips, God forbid. But all went well, and we formally sealed our bond as host mother and temporary daughter.

That night I met my 2 host brothers, ages 12 and 18 (my first time living with brothers!), along with my host dad, Laurent, with whom I was also very nervous of totally screwing up the bise, but, phew, all went well. We had a delicious summer-time meal full of fruits and veggies, finishing with the typical baguette and cheese combo along with a delicious dessert. By the end, I was stuffed and exhausted. Although I had taken 5 years of middle and high school French classes, I found that listening and speaking French was still rather challenging. I stumbled my way through what I thought were intelligible, albeit broken, phrases, but mostly I just answered “oui” to whatever I thought was a question, and if it wasn’t, oh well!

My first impressions of my family were that they were extremely welcoming and excited about hosting their first exchange student. I would be staying with them for about 3 1/2 months, and then I would switch to a second host family (in a different suburb, but I would be attending the same school). The Rotary sets this up so that students can get various perspectives on their host country’s way of life, and also I think so that the family won’t get too sick of their student!

Here are some pics from my first day in France:

It's a super new house in a super new development

It’s a super new house in a super new development (there are no deserts in France, come on people).

My room!

My room!

Oh, yeah! Did I mention I also have adopted a very adorable host dog named Virgule? (His name means "comma".)

Oh, yeah! Did I mention I also have adopted a very adorable host dog named Virgule? (His name means “comma”.)

My host fam (picture taken on my 4th day in France during a little canoeing excursion). Aren't we fab?

My host fam (picture taken on my 4th day in France during a little canoeing excursion). Aren’t we fab?

 

Civic Engagement Speeches – pros and cons

I found that the speeches people gave today were very good! Here are some pros and cons of the speeches given today:

PROS:

  • Everyone explained how their artifact or the person they interviewed tied into civic engagement really clearly
  • Everyone’s artifact was very unique — I especially liked the retro protest artifact that was found in the library
  • I think most people explained how their artifact used pathos, ethos, and/or logos to make their argument
  • I liked it when people tried to make their speech interesting and engage the students, no one just delivered a speech that was written out

CONS:

  • Some people spoke too fast
  • There were some long pauses at some points
  • Some labored over their point for too long; I think some of those speeches were a lot longer than 4 minutes
  • I thought one or two strayed off topic for a little while; for example, I didn’t think the assignment was about trying to encourage people to engage in that specific type of civic engagement, and I think a couple people added that to their speech

The Rotary, and, On How To Plunge Headfirst Into Life

This post will partly explain to my dear readers why I chose to take part in a year-long exchange and also expose them to how passionate I am about taking a year off and doing some cool stuff since this post is like nearly 700 words long (not including the impossibly witty captions). Sorry.
BUT FIRST.

What’s the Rotary?

This is Rotary International

This is the Rotary.

I think I mentioned previously that my I took my exchange year through an organization called Rotary International. The Rotary is an organization of a collection of older-aged people (usually retired) whose motto, always proudly proclaimed and eerily in unison at the beginning of all meetings, is “Service Above Self”. One of their biggest service projects is eradicating Polio around the world, and they are almost successful in their goal—only 3 countries are not completely immunized to Polio.

Look at all these diverse Rotarians!

Look at all these culturally diverse Rotarians!

The other large part of Rotary is their international exchange program. Students ages 15-18 can embark on a year abroad excursion during which they learn a new language, experience a new culture, and meet lots of cool people from all corners of the world.

That’s the Rotary in a nutshell.

I guess you might wonder why I chose to “give up” a year of my life, to put college on hold, to say goodbye to a lifestyle that I knew all too well. My very first inspiration was my mother. As an 18-year-older fresh out of high school in 1980, my mom took a gap year to be a Rotary exchange student on the east coast of Argentina, a country that she knew nothing of. In fact, she had taken German in high school and had chosen Germany as her top choice; but no, there were no available spots in Germany, so, naturally, without any prior knowledge of the Spanish language, the Rotary sent her to Argentina.

Throughout my childhood, my mom occasionally relayed some of her best stories of her year abroad to me, for example, of the time she won a rambunctious, squealing-with-literal-life pig from a fair, and was expected to make that into her evening meal. “My exchange year was so difficult and so lonely at times,” she would tell me, “but it’s one of my most memorable years.”

That, combined with viewing a brief presentation of the exchange program during my senior year of high school, sealed the deal. I wanted in on this awesome thing. It wasn’t even a very difficult decision for me; I don’t remember ever laying awake at night and wondering if I really wanted to put my life on hold so I could travel for a year. To me, this was life. I always knew I would get to college eventually, and there was no rush in my mind; college could wait a year.First, I wanted to put myself through this year, of what my mom described to be lonely and terrifying and heart breaking and exciting and fun and frustrating and unbelievable all at the same time.

Plunging headfirst into life means redefining what your present life is. If your present life is waking up and going to school and studying and maybe seeing a friend or two and then going to bed and doing that EVERYDAY, taking the chance and completely changing what your life is is pretty scary, but it’s worth it. And taking the chance to do that for a year—not a two-week program, not a summer thing– a year in which you have the time to submerge yourself in that new way of living is so important because that way you’re not a constantly observing tourist, you’re someone that lives in that country. “Life begins at the end of you comfort zone”—I learned pretty quickly while on exchange that that’s extremely true and even liberating.

An inspirational quote. You're welcome.

Another inspirational quote. You’re welcome.

So I signed up, and I went through a simple interviewing process in which Rotarians asked me simple questions such as “How would you deal with homesickness?” and “What will you do if your host family feeds you something you don’t like”, to which you can reply really any answer at all and they’ll let you in I think. And then I filled out lots of forms and signed lots of dotted lines, and before I knew it, I was finding out my country assignment, FRANCE (my first choice!), making lists, packing suitcases, and saying goodbye, see you in a year, to lots of people.

My preconceived notions of France.

My preconceived notions of what France was.

 

Civic Engagement Speech Outline

I. Description of Artifact

  • simple graphic – blood bag used in blood drives
  • first thing you see: “Second Chance” and “First Time”
  • then read message at bottom
  • then see Red Cross logo

II. How is it civic?

  • event of giving blood is civic
  • gives people “second chance” for life
  • our duty as healthy humans to help those who are not

III. Commonplaces and Ideologies

  • commonplace: giving blood is good
  • the American Red Cross is a trustworthy organization (ethos)
  • ideology: your responsibility to help others when they can’t help themselves

IV. Rhetorical purpose

  • (purpose) to try to get you to give blood
  • techniques: simple, clear text; logos: can save 2 lives with 1 blood donation; pathos: can change lives — YOU’RE SAVING LIVES

V. Civic Engagement

  • if you can help people, you should
  • don’t just be self-centered, “look at it from both sides”
  • Successful? YES
  • My artifact

    My artifact

 

 

 

 

MLK Jr’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail – Rhetorical Analysis

Ethos:

1. I have the honor of serving as president of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference

2. My Dear Fellow Clergymen

3.  We have some eighty five affiliated organizations across the South, and one of them is the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights

Pathos:

1.But when you have seen vicious mobs lynch your mothers and fathers at will and drown your sisters and brothers at whim

2.  Isn’t this like condemning a robbed man because his possession of money precipitated the evil act of robbery? Isn’t this like condemning Socrates because his unswerving commitment to truth and his philosophical inquiries precipitated the act by the misguided populace in which they made him drink hemlock? Isn’t this like condemning Jesus because his unique God consciousness and never ceasing devotion to God’s will precipitated the evil act of crucifixion?

3. I have traveled the length and breadth of Alabama, Mississippi and all the other southern states. On sweltering summer days and crisp autumn mornings I have looked at the South’s beautiful churches with their lofty spires pointing heavenward. I have beheld the impressive outlines of her massive religious education buildings. Over and over I have found myself asking: “What kind of people worship here? Who is their God?

Logos:

1.  Thus it is that I can urge men to obey the 1954 decision of the Supreme Court, for it is morally right

2. For instance, I have been arrested on a charge of parading without a permit. Now, there is nothing wrong in having an ordinance which requires a permit for a parade.

3. In our own nation, the Boston Tea Party represented a massive act of civil disobedience.

 

Exchange Student? Huh?

 

What in the world is an exchange student?

The dictionary.com definition of “exchange” (v.) is

1. “to give up (something) for something else”

or

2. to give and receive reciprocally; interchange

And that’s a good start. Because everyone knows that exchange students go to live in different countries and study there, and have cool accents, and eat lots of food, and party a lot. Occasionally you might sit next to them in class as their head nods and they sleepily scribble doodles and scrawling words in a foreign language.

But the exchange student is much more than that. They “give”, yes, but they give so much more than a year set aside for exchange. The exchange student gives UP so much in the beginning — his family, his food, his customs, his schedule, his friends, his country, in short, everything he knows, in the hope that his reciprocate will be so much more.

This, of course, is a gamble. Before embarking on my exchange in 2012, my councilors would tell us over and over, “you’ll get as much out of your exchange as you put into it”. Easy to say, yes, but hard to do. To put 100% into your exchange, you have to say “yes” to everything. Even though you may be tired and homesick, craving a normal American hamburger and on the verge of tears, you have to say “yes” to that almost-friend in your school that asked you to go to lunch. Because if you don’t, you run the risk of missing out on an experience that is both nerve-wracking and amazing, and it could be something YOU’LL NEVER FORGET.

A dramatic start to the blog, I know, but that was how it all began for me August 28th, 2012, when I took my first steps on French soil. I spent my year in central France, two hours south of Paris, on the Rotary Youth Exchange Program. I had just graduated from high school and was looking forward to spending the next 11 months with three different host families in Bourges, France, a town of about 80,000 people. While I had some expectations, I had no idea what experiences I would gain, and more importantly, how I would change over the next year.

A map of France pointing out the town I stayed, Bourges

A map of France pointing out the town in which I stayed, Bourges.

This blog is a compilation of my experiences, other students’ experiences, the pros and cons of being an exchange student, the different programs available, and all that comes with traveling and studying a year abroad. (Hint: its bad stuff. Like, really difficult stuff. But mostly, the good stuff always outshines the bad.) And that’s just the beginning of what it means to be an Exchanger.