Category Archives: Artifacts

Creators and the Fight for LGBTQ+ Representation in Their Programs

https://ew.com/tv/2018/08/22/steven-universe-voltron-kids-cartoons-lgbtq-characters/?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=social-share-article

An image depicting Ruby of Steven Universe, Luna of The Loud House, and Shiro of Voltron: Legendary Defender, and an article posted August 22, 2018 by Entertainment Weekly.

Representation Of LGBTQ+ people in animation doesn’t just happen. Its a process and often a fight as well to have these characters included in animated shows and films. It is the creators of these that are typically at the forefront, fighting to get the characters and themes they want in their programs to be allowed by the company that produces them. This article offers insight into that behind the scenes fight. With interviews from some of the prominent creators in this filed, such as Rebecca Sugar (Steven Universe), Alex Hirsch (Gravity Falls), Joaquim Dos Santos and Lauren Montgomery (Voltron: Legendary Defender), Daron Nefcy (Star vs. the Forces of Evil), and Michael Rubiner (The Loud House), the article looks into the struggles, discussions, frustrations, losses, victories, and everything else that has had to go into allowing the LGBTQ+ representation we see today, and is continuing for what they, and we, hope to see in the future.

Cartoon Controversy: Arthur’s Same-Sex Wedding

https://onemillionmoms.com/current-campaigns/pbs-kids-airs-gay-marriage-on-arthur/

An ABC News clip posted May 22, 2019 and an article from One Million Moms posted May, 15, 2019 discussing the recent same-sex marriage shown in an episode or the children’s cartoon Arthur.

The news surrounding the recent same-sex marriage episode of Arthur is an example of the controversy and arguments that follow the LGBTQ+ representation being depicted in animation. The video is an ABC News clip discussing how the episode in question was banned from being aired in Alabama. The article is from One Million Moms, a division of the American Family Association. The article offers the opinion of One Million Moms, who is against LGBTQ+ representation in the media, especially in children’s shows and cartoons. As great as the increase in LGBTQ+ representation in animation is, there are unfortunately those who strongly oppose it and actively fight to have it censored. More unfortunate is that some are succeeding, as was the case in Alabama. The fight for representation is not all victories.

Stevonnie and the Binary: An Update

A video from Cartoon Network and Dove’s Self-Esteem Project campaign delivered by the Steven Universe character Stevonnie, published June 24, 2019.

In a recent Archive Post it was discussed how the character Stevonnie from the cartoon Steven Universe is making headway because of their use of they/them pronouns and their depiction as a non-binary character. Recently, Steven Universe has taken this representation a step further by revealing in the above video that Stevonnie is also intersex (seen in their social media profile description). With this reveal, Steven Universe has become even more inclusive than before. This is their, and children’s cartoons’ in general, first intersex character, and yet another LGBTQ+ identity to add to their growing list. Intersex is one of the rarest identities portrayed in animation, if before now it was portrayed at all.

Rebecca Sugar On LGBTQ+ Visibility In Animation

https://ew.com/tv/2018/08/13/steven-universe-rebecca-sugar-lgbtq-cartoons/

An image of Steven Universe creator Rebecca Sugar and an article by Nick Romano interviewing Sugar about LGBTQ visibility, published August 13, 2018.

In this article by EW, Rebecca Sugar discusses LGBTQ+ visibility in her show Steven Universe and recounts some of the issues and resistance she has faced in bringing this inclusion to life. The overt representation of LGBTQ+ charcaters that is now seen on Steven Universe, often more than many other similar shows, is still a relatively new concept. Creators, like Sugar, have had to fight to get to this point and to be allowed to include queer themes and characters on their programs, and that fight is not yet done. Examples of LGBTQ+ representation in animation is limited but growing, and much of this growth is thanks to creators like Sugar.

Sailor Moon – The Erasure of LGBTQ Characters

https://www.teenvogue.com/story/sailor-moons-erasure-lgbtq-characters

https://www.pride.com/geek/2018/12/26/9-ways-sailor-moon-was-way-gayer-you-remember#media-gallery-media-0

An image depicting two characters from Sailor Moon, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune, as well as two articles written by Gabe Bergado and Terra Necessary respectively. The first article was written for Teen Vogue June 30, 2017 and the second for the site Pride.com.

The articles here discuss the presence of LGBTQ+ themes within Sailor Moon and their subsequent erasure in the American release. As both articles show, there are both clear and subtle references to LGBTQ+ themes and identities. One of the biggest is the inclusion of the two characters Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune. These characters make up a lesbian couple, and are depicted as such in the original Japanese version of the show, but when it was adapted for American release these characters were rewritten and coded as cousins instead. While this is the biggest instance of erasure in the series, the articles discuss other instances as well. Erasure and censorship of LGBTQ+ characters and themes is not an uncommon issue faced in queer animation.

Steven Universe – Stevonnie and the Binary

https://www.glaad.org/amp/how-steven-universe-empowered-me-to-claim-my-pronouns

An image of a character from the cartoon Steven Universe called Stevonnie and an article by Athena Schwartz, published May 18, 2018, for GLAAD on what this character means to them and could mean to others who identify as nonbinary or gender nonconforming.

The character Stevonnie is a fusion between the characters Steven, a male, and Connie, a female. The physical attributes of the character are a blend of Steven and Connie’s own physical characteristics. As such, Stevonnie is neither male nor female presenting. Perhaps most importantly, Stevonnie uses they/them pronouns. The inclusion of a nonbinary character that uses they/them pronouns is a huge step in queer representation in animation. This inclusion is a meaningful one, as seen in the article. The show uses the character in a positive way, and through this can offer a sense of validity for nonbinary and gender nonconforming people, including children.

Dirty Paws

This is a short animated film Dirty Paws, posted in 2015 by the film’s creator Karina Farek. The film was originally a thesis and is written, directed, and animated by Farek.

The film follows two boyfriends, one of whom is a werewolf. What is depicted is a “normal” couple of days for the boyfriends as they prepare for and go through a full moon. Aside from the supernatural elements of the film, the relationship is just like every other. There is no real emphasis placed on the fact that they are a same-sex couple. Normalization is important in depicting LGBTQ+ relationships, so the fact that their sexuality is not the focus of the story being portrayed is key. All relationships, no matter sexuality, or if they are between human and werewolf, are normal and should be treated as such. This film does well at showing that.

Steven Universe “Reunited”

A clip from the children’s cartoon Steven Universe, episode 23 & 24 “Reunited” posted December 22, 2018.

While there are many scenes throughout Steven Universe that could apply to this archive, the clip stands out in its depiction of the first same-sex marriage to ever appear in a children’s animated show. According to the shows creator Rebecca Sugar, the gems (aliens from another world) are actually sexless but female presenting, and typically use she/her pronouns. This clip portrays the marriage of two gems, Ruby and Sapphire, who tighter fuse to become the gem Garnet. Having been together for thousands of years, Ruby and Sapphire decide to make their relationship officially their choice, by having a wedding. Done in a simple and open way, this wedding, again the first of its kind, offers positive representation never before seen in children’s animation.

Baby X

Baby X is a short animated film created by Brendan Bradley and based off of a children’s book titled X: A Fabulous Child’s Story by Lois Gould. This video was posted April 19, 2016 by Bradley.

Baby X is about a baby who is raised without gender. The film follows the baby from birth and introduction to its relatives, through school. The film takes an interesting look at what would happen if you raised a baby without gender from the start. It portrays the struggles that X and those who interact with X face, from what clothes and toys to buy, to pronouns, to how to describe the baby (for example, as “her” having cute dimples or “him” husky biceps). The film as a whole really takes a crack at traditional gender roles, as well as many of the roles that play into how, when, and where these roles are enforced. The film not only looks at X and the parents, but also relatives, teachers and administrators, students, store clerks, and so on. An important aspect of the film is that it doesn’t make this experience of X’s seem easy; in fact it explicitly states that it won’t be easy.

In a Heartbeat – Animated Short Film

In a Heartbeat is a short computer-animated film by Beth David and Esteban Bravo. It was produced at Ringling College of Art + Design in 2017. It tells the story of a boy who harbors a secret crush for another boy at his school.

In a Heartbeat won a GLAAD Media Award for Special Recognition and on YouTube has amassed over 2.2 million views. The tale of having a secret crush and trying to hide it is a familiar one, but one often told from a heterosexual perspective. This short animated film tells this familiar and relatable story from the perspective of a closeted boy afraid of being outed, in this case by his own heart. In this way the film has taken a normal human experience, but made the depiction of it accessible to a different group than previously portrayed. Representation is important in the media, especially for children. When you don’t see someone like you in the media, or in this case cartoons, then you are more likely to think that there is something wrong or not right about you. Representation makes you feel valid. Gay crushes being depicted as normal can make gay people, gay kids, feel valid.