Welcome back, all! For those of you who are unaware, my Passion Blog follows the story of Downton Abbey. I discuss both the characters and plot of the show, but I put a new twist on the show by analyzing the historical context of the show. If you are interested, my past Passion Blogs can be found at: https://sites.psu.edu/rclsge/category/passion/. There is one post entitled “Downton: Explained,” which would be very helpful to read if you are not familiar with Downton’s characters.
We will pick up this semester in Season Two, Episode Three. England is in the middle of the first World War. At this point, we start to see the effects of the war on all, even those at Downton. The local hospital was in need of a place for the healing officers to convalesce, so Downton has become a convalescent home. As the same suggests, a convalescent home is simply a place for injured soldiers to rest and recover. During World War I, many large English estates were turned into convalescent homes because they offered the necessary space and staff for the recovering soldiers. Downton’s large estate with its many staff members is a perfect location. Below, you can see a picture of an English estate that was actually turned into a convalescent home during the war. You can see the soldiers relaxing on the lawn in front of the house.
As you can imagine, Downton’s transition from a private estate into a convalescence home caused many tensions. First of all, some people were upset that the home would only accept officers. The local hospital was only for officers, so it makes sense for the convalescence home to be reserved for officers. However, it does seem unfair that officers alone are able to enjoy Downton’s luxury. Sybil, one of the daughters, was especially adamant, insisting that different ranks can and should relax together. Additionally, there was the issue of separating the house into areas for the family and areas for the officers. Some of the family at Downton did not feel comfortable eating and relaxing with the officers. In fact, Violet comically announces that it is “like living in a second-rate hotel, where the guests keep arriving and no one seems to leave.” Finally, a huge problem developed concerning the chain of command. Mrs. Crawley, Matthew’s mother, takes control, creating tensions between her and Cora, Robert’s wife. These issues are similar to those that many estates turned into convalescent homes had to deal with during World War I.
We see another side of the war’s effects through Mr. Lang, Robert’s valet. Mr. Lang is tragically suffering from shell shock. Similar to post-traumatic stress disorder, shell shock is a psychological trauma that soldiers suffer after returning from war. In this episode, we see Mr. Lang’s heartbreaking display of many shell shock symptoms. Mr. Lang wakes up screaming, believing that he is back on the battlefield. Watching Matthew return to war after a break, Mr. Lang starts to shiver and shake, asking “The generals and all these officers…I don’t have to go back with them do I? Because I can’t.”
I will end this blog on a more positive note. In this episode, Edith cannot find her place among the bustle of the convalescent home. Sybil gives her the following advice: “You have a talent that none of the rest of us have. Find out what it is and use it.” Indeed, Edith does find her talent, which is dealing with the patients’ everyday needs and making them feel comfortable. Sybil’s advice is that which we should all follow; go out and find your talent.
First of all, I love your pun in the title 😉
I really liked watching Downton Abbey, and it’s so great to be able to be reminded of everything! It’s also cool how you bring out the real elements of history that are featured in the show.
It’s interesting how the show can explain history through the emotions of the characters. It really gives the watcher an opportunity to learn while being more invested in the story. I like how you ended with a motivational message.
This is really really interesting! As a history buff, it’s really cool to hear about a popular show (despite it being one I have not partaken in viewing) through the lens of history. World War I is strange. It is often glorified (alongside WWII) and many people forget the harsh realities that affected EVERYONE in Europe- Soldiers and Citizens alike.
This is a very interesting blog to read about, I am not one to like history or anything of the sorts but your blog was very engaging and at times relate able. I also like your twist on the show, I might have to consider looking into a bit more since I am very intrigued. I also look forward to reading more of your blogs!
I have actually never seen Downton Abbey, but now, I am intrigued to find out how much of the show is based on true historical events! It’s quite interesting to hear the mixed reactions people had to the convalescent home only accepting officers. As a regular soldier or the loved one of a soldier, I would find that frustrating, especially if I felt that the officers were receiving better treatment. The shell shock that soldiers must live through long after the effects of the war is something I hope I never have to experience. I cannot wait to hear more about the context of this show!