Give Me Liberty Or Give Me COVID-19?
It’s a very interesting yet true statement today in our democracy. I listened to this Democracy Works podcast as I am intrigued by the seemingly deepening schism between safety and liberty. I live in a very rural area of Pennsylvania that is largely conservative, but also contains Gettysburg College, a very liberal school. Living in a history rich area with such diverse political backgrounds it is always interesting to see the large diversity in opinions and the lack of civil discourse that arises over them. Recently, every time I log onto Facebook I can count at least three posts advocating for people to protect their freedom and not let the government boss them around; these posts are always matched by those advocating for people to obey the stay at home order and wait it out (luckily there is the occasional puppy post disrupting my doom and gloom feed or else Facebook would be quite depressing). While I personally support the stay at home order, I find myself struggling to fault those that are concerned about their personal liberties being violated. More often than not I find that these posts come from veterans who explicitly fought for these freedoms, so who am I to tell them they should not feel violated?
I felt like the most important point made in the podcast is that, “People’s experiences in different communities is quite different right now.” People are being disproportionately affected by the virus depending on where they are in the country, The point was made that some people know no-one that has been affected by the virus, but they do know that they have no income and their local businesses are struggling to keep their heads above water. This put the conversation in a different light for me. Being a person who’s aunt and uncle had the virus, who’s grandmother is immunocompromised from chemotherapy, who knows people who have passed from COVID-19; it is very easy for me to recognize the importance of the restrictions because I have witnessed the devastation first hand. But some people have witnessed the virus take a different toll; their families have been evicted, they have lost the family business, they don’t know where their next meal may come from. If that is someone’s personal experience with the virus who am I to judge their reaction to the stay at home order.
But liberty, where does this come into the conversation. Many people are claiming that their constitutional rights are being threatened by the stay at home order; that America’s foundational principals are being violated in response to the virus. I don’t know if I can agree with this statement. It is clear that the government takes extra powers during times of crisis, and a crisis this certainly is. I’ve witnessed a childhood friend post that they’ll, “Die before I let Tom Wolf tell me what to do.” All I am left thinking is that they probably won’t, but their grandma certainly may. I see these claims that liberty is being violated as incredibly selfish. The people we are staying home to protect are those who helped secure those freedoms by fighting in various wars, don’t we owe it to them to fight for them by staying indoors?