Ethical Reflection:
Ethical Reflection Methodology
Grassroots Diplomacy:
Grassroots Diplomacy Methodology
Overview of Components of a Good Argument
- Make sure your conclusion (what you are trying to prove) and your premises (the reasons you offer in support of your conclusion) are clearly identified.
- Present your ideas in an understandable order
- Use clear language
- Don’t use “loaded” terms
- Define key terms
- Make sure key terms are used consistently
Premises
- All relevant premises are identified
- Any factual information in support of the premise is delineated so that reader is convinced of reliability of premises
Inferences
- All inferences from premises to conclusions (both intermediary and final) are clearly framed
- Inferences are valid (the evidence warrants the conclusion)
- Standard fallacies are avoided
Values and Principles Identified
- All relevant moral values and/or aspects of the Code of Ethics are identified
- All moral frameworks that frame the argument are clearly identified
Evaluation
- Strongest arguments for position are offered
- Most significant counter objections are considered and successfully addressed
Taken: Andy Lau Ethics of Star Trek Course