Beyond Brand Promises Fulfillment: The Next Frontiers of Retailer as Brand and Supply Chain

By Steve Tracey📧 and Kusumal Ruamsook📧 

In Supply Chain Management Review, November, 2023.

A major shift in the focus of branding has occurred in the last two decades. Traditionally, brands were associated with products, and consumers purchasing the products were often unaware of the company behind them. Today, a growing number of companies place greater emphasis on corporate brands and corporate-dominant brand architecture as a means to navigate the competitive and hyperconnected market environment. Boosted by the e-commerce boom, supply chain management has risen to the forefront of retail branding strategies. This article discusses how distribution and logistics are revolutionizing corporate branding strategies in the retail sector, going beyond the enabler of brand promises delivery to be an extension of the retailer brand.

View the full article from the publisher web site here.

Related CSCR White Paper:

Read “The Evolutionary Nexus of Supply Chain and Corporate Branding in Retail” here.

The Evolutionary Nexus of Supply Chain and Corporate Branding in Retail

By Steve Tracey📧 and Kusumal Ruamsook📧 

White paper, January 2023

A major shift in the focus of branding has occurred in the last two decades. Traditionally, brands were associated with products, and consumers purchasing the products were often unaware of the company behind them. Today, a growing number of companies place greater emphasis on corporate brands and corporate-dominant brand architecture as a means to navigate the competitive and hyperconnected market environment. Indeed, built and nurtured effectively, a corporate brand can provide a foundation for differentiation that is not as easy to imitate, and can bestow cohesiveness across global markets and broadening sales channels in the digital commerce era. In line with the momentum towards corporate branding, the applicability and importance of corporate brands as valuable assets has been increasingly espoused in the retail sector. We observe that supply chain management, especially the distribution and logistics elements, has risen to become the forefront apparatus in retail branding strategies. Indeed, the roles of fulfillment and last-mile logistics are expanding beyond the crucial enabler of brand promises delivery to be an extension of the retailer brand itself. The paper provides a conceptual lens of strategic corporate branding that lays the foundational understanding of corporate brand–supply chain nexus in cultivating an authentic corporate brand.  Additionally, the paper brings to light how distribution and logistics are revolutionizing corporate branding strategies in the retail sector.  Examining Amazon as a best-in-class example, we discuss how this powerhouse retailer brand leverages the power of effectively crafted supply chain processes in enhancing the authenticity and value of its brand.

View full paper here.


Suggested citation

Tracey, Steve, and Kusumal Ruamsook. 2023. “The Evolutionary Nexus of Supply Chain and Corporate Branding in Retail.” White paper, Center for Supply Chain Research® (CSCR®), The Pennsylvania State University.

Forecasting Venue Popularity on Location-Based Services Using Interpretable Machine Learning

By Lei Wang📧, R. Gopal, R. Shankar, and J. Pancras

In Production and Operations Management, 2022. 31(7), 2773-2788. https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13727

Customers are increasingly utilizing location-based services via mobile devices to engage with retail establishments. The focus of this paper is to identify factors that help to drive venue popularity revealed by location-based services, which then better facilitate companies’ operational decisions, such as procurement and staff scheduling. Using data collected from Foursquare and Yelp, we build, evaluate, and compare a wide variety of machine learning methods including deep learning models with varying characteristics and degrees of sophistication. First, we find that support vector regression is the best performing model compared to other complex predictive algorithms. Second, we apply SHAP (Shapley Additive exPlanations) to quantify the contribution from each business feature at both the global and local levels. The global interpretability results show that customer loyalty, the agglomeration effect, and the word-of-mouth effect are the top three drivers of venue popularity. Furthermore, the local interpretability analysis reveals that the contributions of business features vary, both quantitatively and directionally. Our findings are robust with respect to different popularity measures, training and testing periods, and prediction horizons. These findings extend our knowledge of location-based services by demonstrating their potential to play a prominent role in attracting consumer engagement and boosting venue popularity. Managers can make better operational decisions such as procurement and staff scheduling based on these more accurate venue popularity prediction methods. Furthermore, this study also highlights the importance of model interpretability which enhances the ability of managers to more effectively utilize machine learning models for effective decision-making.

Keywords: Interpretable machine learning; Location-based services; SHAP (Shapley Additive exPlanations) value; User engagement; Venue popularity prediction

Is Adopting Mass Customization a Path to Environmentally Sustainable Fashion?

By A. Alptekinoglu📧 and A. Orsdemir

In Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2022, forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.1088

Problem definition: In high-product-variety businesses like fashion, mass production (MP) systems create environmental waste in the form of overproduction on a colossal scale. Mass customization (MC) has been proposed—without solid evidence—as a solution. In this paper, we analyze whether MC can indeed offer a win-win solution that helps both the bottom line and the environment. We also study the impact of three real policy options: promoting MC, charging a disposal fee for overproduction, and recycling. Academic/practical relevance: There is increasing interest in mass-customizing fashion goods, not only because consumers value customization, but also because MC is perceived to be environmentally friendly. Our paper puts this advocacy for MC to the test. We contribute to the literature, which has been largely silent on the issue, by uncovering when MC offers a win-win and relating such market outcomes to policy ideas. Methodology: We develop an analytical model of an MP firm adopting MC (going hybrid). The firm’s profit-maximizing variety, price, and inventory decisions then form the basis of our understanding the environmental impact of adopting MC and assessing various policy options. Results: Adopting MC can be a win-win, but it can also increase overproduction and hurt the environment. Our policy analyses reveal two kinds of insights. The first kind is about whether a policy expands win-win outcomes—encouraging sustainable adoption of MC. Among the policy ideas we explore, only promoting MC so as to increase consumers’ tolerance for waiting for mass-customized products can do that unambiguously. The second kind of insight is about whether a policy reduces the hybrid firm’s environmental impact. Only a disposal fee and costly recycling programs can do that unambiguously. Managerial implications: For MC adoption to be a win-win, policy makers must (1) work on convincing consumers to wait for bespoke fashion; (2) target MP firms with low cost of variety (high product-mix flexibility) with disposal fees or costly recycling programs; and (3) encourage those with relatively higher cost of variety to develop/acquire technology that would make recycling profitable.

Keywords: Corporate, social, and environmental responsibility; Fashion industry; Mass customization; Mass production; Make-to-order; Make-to-stock; Overproduction; Waste; Postponement; Product variety; Additive manufacturing; 3-D printing

Heteroscedastic Exponomial Choice

By A. Alptekinoglu📧, and J. Semple

In Operations Research, 2021, 69 (3): 841–858. https://doi.org/10.1287/opre.2020.2074

We investigate analytical and empirical properties of the Heteroscedastic Exponomial Choice (HEC) model to lay the groundwork for its use in theoretical and empirical studies that build demand models on a discrete choice foundation. The HEC model generalizes the Exponomial Choice (EC) model by including choice-specific variances for the random components of utility (the error terms). We show that the HEC model inherits some of the properties found in the EC model: closed-form choice probabilities, demand elasticities, and consumer surplus; optimal monopoly prices that are increasing with ideal utilities in a hockey-stick pattern; and unique equilibrium oligopoly prices that are easily computed using a series of single-variable equations. However, the HEC model has several key differences with the EC model, which show that variances matter: the choice probabilities (market shares) as well as equilibrium oligopoly prices are not necessarily increasing with ideal utilities; and the new model can include choices with deterministic utility or choices with zero probability. However, because the HEC model uses more parameters, it is harder to estimate. To justify its use, we apply HEC to grocery purchase data for 30 product categories and find that it significantly improves model fit and generally improves out-of-sample prediction compared with EC. We go on to investigate the more nuanced impact of the variance parameters on oligopoly pricing. We find that the individual and collective incentives differ in equilibrium: firms individually want lower error variability for their own product but collectively prefer higher error variability for all products—including their own—because higher error variability softens the price competition.

Keywords: Economics: econometrics; Games/group decisions: noncooperative; Marketing: choice models, pricing; Utility/preference: choice functions; Revenue Management and Market Analytics; Discrete choice theory; Random utility models; Exponomial choice model; Demand modeling; Demand elasticity; Consumer surplus; Maximum likelihood estimation; Pricing; Price equilibrium

Is Adopting Mass Customization a Path to Environmentally Sustainable Fashion?

By A. Alptekinoglu📧, and Adem Orsdemir

Working Paper, 2020.

Problem definition: In high-product-variety businesses like fashion, mass production systems create environmental waste in the form of overproduction on a colossal scale. Mass customization has been proposed – without solid evidence – as a solution. In this paper, we analyze whether mass customization can indeed offer a win-win solution that helps both the bottom line and the environment. We also study the impact of three real policy options: promoting mass customization, charging a disposal fee for overproduction, and recycling. Academic / practical relevance: There is increasing interest in mass customization of fashion goods, not only because consumers value customization, but also because mass customization is perceived to be environmentally friendly. Our paper puts this advocacy for mass customization to test. We contribute to the literature, which has been largely silent on the issue, by uncovering when mass customization offers a win-win and relating such market outcomes to policy ideas. Methodology: We develop an analytical model of a mass producer firm adopting mass customization (going hybrid). The firm’s profit-maximizing variety, price and inventory decisions then form the basis of our understanding the environmental impact of adopting mass customization and assessing various policy options. Results: Adopting mass customization is a win-win in many scenarios, e.g., high (moderate-to-low) product value and moderate-to-high (moderate) product variety cost. Surprisingly, going hybrid can also increase overproduction and hurt the environment. Our policy analyses of the hybrid firm reveal that: promoting mass customization may not always help (in moderate- and low-value-product cases); charging a disposal fee for overproduction does always help; and recycling helps only if it is costly on a per unit basis (and not necessarily if profitable). Managerial implications: Mass customization can be a win-win, but it can also backfire on the environment. Policy interventions must be carefully thought through because some may have unintended consequences.

Keywords: Corporate social and environmental responsibility; Mass customization; Make-to-order; Mass production; Make-to-stock; Overproduction; Pricing; Product variety; Fashion industry

Access: Full paper here.

Heteroscedastic Exponomial Choice

By A. Alptekinoglu📧, and John H. Semple

Working Paper, 2020.

We investigate analytical and empirical properties of the Heteroscedastic Exponomial Choice (HEC) model to lay the groundwork for its use in theoretical and empirical research that build demand models on a discrete choice foundation. The HEC model generalizes the Exponomial Choice (EC) model by including choice-specific variances for the random components of utility (the error terms). We show that the HEC model inherits some of the properties found in the EC model: closed-form choice probabilities, demand elasticities and consumer surplus; optimal monopoly prices that are increasing with ideal utilities in a hockey-stick pattern; and unique equilibrium oligopoly prices that are easily computed using a series of single-variable equations. However, the HEC model has several key differences with the EC model that show variances matter: the choice probabilities (market shares) as well as equilibrium oligopoly prices are not necessarily increasing with ideal utilities; and the new model can include choices with deterministic utility or choices with zero probability. However, because the HEC model uses more parameters, it is harder to estimate. To justify its use, we apply HEC to grocery purchase data for thirty product categories and find that it significantly improves model fit and generally improves out-of-sample prediction compared to EC. We go on to investigate the more nuanced impact of the variance parameters on oligopoly pricing. We find that the individual and collective incentives differ in equilibrium: Firms individually want lower error variability for their own product, but collectively prefer higher error variability for all products – including their own – because higher error variability softens the price competition.

Keywords: Discrete choice theory; Random utility models; Exponomial Choice model; Demand modeling; Demand elasticity; Consumer surplus; Maximum likelihood estimation; Pricing; Price equilibrium

Access: Full paper here.

Product Return Episodes in Retailing

By M. Samorani, A. Alptekinoglu📧, and P. Messinger

In Service Science, 2019, 11 (4): 263–278. https://doi.org/10.1287/serv.2019.0250

The return of a product is often one of a series of transactions that a consumer undertakes in search of a good. Recognizing this, we analyze returns as part of a product search process: on returning a product, consumers may immediately purchase an alternative one, which they may later replace with another product, and so on, until they either ultimately keep their last purchase (Keep outcome) or not (No-keep outcome). We call such a sequence of transactions a product return episode. In this work, we study consumer Keep and return abuse behavior using episodic metrics. Using data from a consumer electronics retailer, we show that analysis of product returns with episodic metrics provides insights that differ from, and go beyond, analyses with commonly used transactional metrics. We find that although higher average price and larger store assortment at a subcategory level both tend to increase the return probability, they also increase the probability of keeping a product at the end of an episode, which points to profit-improving opportunities for retailers by allowing returns and tracking episodes. We also find that episodic metrics are useful for identifying return abuse.

Keywords: Product returns; Product search; Price; Store assortment; Retailing; Reverse supply chain

Mobile Targeting Using Customer Trajectory Patterns

By A. Ghose, B. Li, and S. Liu📧

In Management Science, 2019, 65 (11): 4951–5448. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2018.3188

Rapid improvements in the precision of mobile technologies now make it possible for advertisers to go beyond real-time static location and contextual information on consumers. In this paper we propose a novel “trajectory-based” targeting strategy for mobile recommendation that leverages detailed information on consumers’ physical-movement trajectories using fine-grained behavioral information from different mobility dimensions. To analyze the effectiveness of this new strategy, we designed a large-scale randomized field experiment in a large shopping mall that involved 83,370 unique user responses for a 14-day period in June 2014. We found that trajectory-based mobile targeting can, as compared with other baselines, lead to higher redemption probability, faster redemption behavior, and higher transaction amounts. It can also facilitate higher revenues for the focal store as well as the overall shopping mall. Moreover, the effect of trajectory-based targeting comes not only from improvements in the efficiency of customers’ current shopping processes but also from its ability to nudge customers toward changing their future shopping patterns and, thereby, generate additional revenues. Finally, we found significant heterogeneity in the impact of trajectory-based targeting. It is especially effective in influencing high-income consumers. Interestingly, however, it becomes less effective in boosting the revenues of the shopping mall during the weekends and for those shoppers who like to explore across products categories. Our overall findings suggest that highly targeted mobile promotions can have the inadvertent impact of reducing impulse-purchasing behavior by customers who are in an exploratory shopping stage. On a broader note, our work can be viewed as a first step toward the study of large-scale, fine-grained digital traces of individual physical behavior and how they can be used to predict—and market according to—individuals’ anticipated future behavior.

Keywords: Mobile targeting; Trajectory mining; Field experiment; GPS; Location-based advertising

The Fulfillment-Optimization Problem

By M. Acimovic📧 and V. F. Farias

In INFORMS TutORials in Operations Research. Operations Research and Management Science in the Age of Analytics, 2019, 218–237 (Invited. Peer-reviewed/refereed). https://doi.org/10.1287/educ.2019.0199

This tutorial studies the fulfillment-optimization problem, a key optimization problem facing retailers that fulfill online customer orders using inventory that might be distributed across multiple supply nodes, which for omnichannel retailers may include the entire store network in addition to distribution centers. This tutorial formulates and studies the fulfillment optimization problem as an online optimization problem. The first approach we study to solving this problem is similar in spirit to linear programming–based bid price approaches to network revenue management. The second approach relies on an algorithm based on the primal-dual schema. The approaches are complementary; the former is suitable in a regime where the demand for products is relatively predictable, whereas the latter is applicable to settings where such predictability is not available. In both cases we describe the practical impact of these solutions at real-world retailers. Finally, we discuss outstanding unsolved problems in the area that we believe can have significant impact on practice.

Keywords: Online retailing; Omnichannel retailing; Fulfillment optimization; Inventory control; Heuristics