Adichie’s Thoughts on the College Classroom

In pages 164-166 of Adichie’s novel Americanah, Ifemelu discusses her feelings about American college classrooms. Some of her thoughts I completely agree with, and others I’m not so sure. She mentions how students say “I’m not sure” instead of “I don’t know,” something I have seen more in high school classes than now. My experience in high school has shown me that students, myself included, don’t want to tell the teacher they don’t know something, especially if it’s what the teacher has been teaching recently. Students say things that do exactly what Adichie says, they “give no information but suggest the possibility of knowledge.” Also, Adichie says that students don’t know how to speak, and I have seen a similar pattern with writing. I know I am not a perfect writer, but I’ve noticed, again mostly in high school as I haven’t had a chance to read nearly as much student writing here yet, that students write poorly. Once again, I’m by no means a perfect writer, but there are some students whose writing ability isn’t as good as it could be in high school. The last topic I really agree with his her section on textbooks. I bought a book for math class and so far my professor hasn’t taught us anything similar to what’s in the book, and has even gone as far as to say that we won’t find what we’re learning in any book or any website. Additionally, my chemistry lecture and lab required me to buy six different things. So far we have needed to use all of these, but it still seems a little over the top to me. Another topic she talks about is education ideologies in America and Nigeria, which appear to have stark differences based on how Adichie describes them. To me, her description makes it sound like education in Nigeria has a real, solid point, but I do not mean that American education is pointless. She talks about participation like it is useless, that students just say random things to get their participation points that take away from the real learning of the class. Also, she says how Americans give suggestions rather than instructions. This leads me to believe that education in Nigeria is straight forward. If I were in Adichie’s shoes, I would notice that some of my classes involve a lot more talking and discussion than others. They really make the student pay attention and contribute to the class. Another thing I’d notice is that Penn State values group work, so far I have a group or partner for all of my classes except one, math. Based on these two observations, I would generalize it by saying that Penn State values student interaction in the classroom. In these three pages by Adichie, she writes some things that I feel a lot of college students probably agree with and have noticed in their own college experience.

2 thoughts on “Adichie’s Thoughts on the College Classroom

  1. I have only had a month’s experience in college classrooms, but I agree with your point on textbooks; my biochemistry professor told us that a much more effective way to study than to read our book is to go through the study guides that he posts online.

    In both high school and college, I have heard my classmates talk about BS-ing the answers on open-ended exams, and I think that somehow, we have this mindset that we should always say something, just to look good, even if it is off base. My AP teachers actually encouraged us to do this because AP graders give points for correct information, and they will not take off points if the correct facts are mixed in with a few incorrect facts. Thus, we, including me at times, don’t like to say, “I don’t know.”

    Fortunately, I think that my experience on the quiz bowl team made me more comfortable with admitting ignorance because, as team captain when I was a senior, the responsibility to know the answer seemed to fall most heavily on me, and, as I frequently did not, and could not make up the answer like I could on an open-ended test question, I had to say, “I don’t know the answer.”

  2. Hi TJ! I like the points you brought up! You were very thorough in discussing all of them, and I like that. I agree that education in Nigeria (from Ifemelu’s descriptions) seems to be more direct and focused as opposed to the U.S.’s comparatively abstract way of teaching, involving group work, activities, and discussion. I went to a French high school in Morocco, and it too was very straight-forward with no room for fluff or fun (although I thoroughly enjoyed it). The classes were completely lecture classes, and we were to write down the lectures (in French!!) word for word and then regurgitate them later on exams. Now that happens to be my learning style, a very direct take, but I know that it is NOT for everyone, and that many would be happier in an American educational environment. So good job bringing up these points! Thanks for the post!

Leave a Reply