In a world that is becoming ever more interconnected, leaders of all types must, of necessity, learn to interact and adjust to a variety of cultures. The leader who views the world through the tunnel vision of his or her own particular culture, and is unwilling to adapt to and integrate new ideas and paradigms will not be a leader for long. The list of cultural diversities, and therefore adaptations that may be required, is long. Moran, Harris, and Moran1 have attempted organize those diversities by grouping them into ten specific categories.
The shortcoming in any such categorization is that it fails to assign weight to the varying categories of cultural diversity. For example, in the same list we find “Communication and Language”, “Food and Feeding Habits”, “Values and Norms”, and “Beliefs and Attitudes”.2 (Moran, Harris, and Moran, pp.11-13) While it is certainly true that each of these categories plays a role in defining a culture, it is not true that each of these categories is equally adaptable or can be integrated into a company or organization with equal success. Learning to adapt to, and integrate, various communication and food types and styles is straight-forward enough. It may require patience and persistence, but it is certainly doable when the common vision and mission of the organization are kept in view by everyone involved. However, adapting to and integrating widely divergent values and beliefs is not such a straight-forward process and may, in fact, not always be possible. For example, in a past generation, to accept and integrate the language and culture of the German people would have been desirable. To attempt to accept and integrate the values and beliefs of Nazism would have been suicidal. In today’s world, to accept and integrate the language and culture of Middle Eastern nations is desirable and necessary. To accept and implement the values and beliefs of Sharia Law would be suicidal.
Making such distinctions between varying aspects of cultures is not easy. As Moran, Harris, and Moran point out, “Culture is a complex system of interrelated parts that must be understood holistically.”3 (Moran, Harris, and Moran, p.14) We must take care not to stereotype individuals based on a value or belief held by other members of their group. This country was guilty of doing this during the years of World War II when German and Japanese Americans were unfairly and unjustly counted as our enemies. It happens today when people of Middle Eastern descent are assumed to be “terrorists” simply because of their appearance. We should get to know and understand the values and beliefs of individuals and groups, especially those with whom we intend to forge working relationships. The GLOBE (Global Leadership and Organizational Behavior Effectiveness) studies found that one of three leadership qualities perceived in all cultures as contributing to leadership ability was Charismatic/Value-Based leadership. “This CLT [Culturally Endorsed Leadership Theory Dimension] captures a leader’s ability to inspire, to motivate, and to expect high performance outcomes on the basis of his/her firmly held core values.”4 (Emphasis added.) Leading based on a firmly held set of core values is important in all cultures. Therefore, if individuals or groups are not in “sync” in their deeply held beliefs and values, it becomes very difficult, if not impossible, to adapt to and integrate one another’s cultures and to effectively lead such a group based on your core values.
The clashes of culture that have been seen throughout history, and that continue to be seen today, are most often not the result of diversities like food, clothing, and language, or even work habits or relationship patterns. They are the result of differing values and beliefs about very basic issues. Until we can find common ground at this level, the clashes will continue. It is only in the context of a common culture of shared values and beliefs (dignity of life, freedom of expression, etc.) that we can be free to learn about and enjoy the many cultural diversities (languages, foods, dress, etc.) of the world.
References
- Moran, Robert T., Harris, Philip R., Moran, Sarah V. Managing Cultural Differences: Leadership Skills and Strategies for Working in a Global World. Burlington, MA: Elsevier, Inc. 2011 – Eighth Edition
- Ibid.
- Ibid.
- Professional Knowledge Center. The Globe Project: A 1000-Word Précis. Retrieved August 29, 2014, from http://www.grovewell.com/pub-GLOBE-precis.html