Conducting a Risk Assessment for your New Business

By: Jaiden Moore

Running a business involves a variety of risks. Some of these risks have the power to completely dismantle a business, while others have the power to seriously damage it, making repairs expensive and time-consuming. Business owners, no matter how big or small the business is, may foresee and plan for risks that are inherent in doing business. Risks are being taken by small business owners every day. However, putting too much at stake could affect your net income. To ensure that you are making the right decisions, conduct a risk assessment for your small business.

While many people are involved in the process and several factors are considered, executing a thorough risk assessment boils down to three main components: risk identification, risk analysis, and risk review.

 risk identification 

To properly address hazards and risks in the workplace, they must first be correctly identified. The goal of risk identification is to identify what, where, when, why, and how a situation can hinder a company’s ability to function. For example, a business located near the Gulf of Mexico would list “the potential for hurricanes” as an occurrence that could interfere with normal business operations. This will enable you to minimize harmful risks before they arise.

here are some ways that a small business owner can identify risks:

Brainstorming: 

To brainstorm is to take a holistic view of the business you are developing. In doing this, you want to think about any challenges you anticipate as well as anything that you are unsure about.

Thinking Pessimistically:

Generally, pessimists have a gloomy or skeptical outlook. While pessimism is typically not encouraged in the workplace, asking yourself “what is the worst thing that could possibly happen to the business” is a good way to identify risks.

Imagining Yourself in the Employee’s Shoes: 

Even if you are a new business owner and currently operate as the sole employee, employee perceptions of a business’s dangers can be very different from those of the business owner. In their regular work activities, employees can come across new threats that were not previously noticed or anticipated. As a result, putting yourself in the employee’s shoes can give you a good sense of what could go wrong.

risk analysis

After you have identified potential risks, you must prioritize them in accordance with an assessment of their likelihood of occurrence. With this in mind, establish a probability scale for the purposes of risk assessment.

For example, risks may:

  1. Be very likely to occur;
  2. Be somewhat likely to occur;
  3. Have a small chance of occurring; or
  4. Have little to no chance of occurring.

Failure to appropriately assess risk likelihood can have serious implications. If you underestimate the likelihood of an incident, you might not take the appropriate preventative measures, which can result in expensive mishaps or even fatalities. The opposite is also true: if you overestimate the likelihood of an event, you could take unnecessary precautions that cost you time and money.

risk review

Once you have established a list of potential business risks and determined each risk’s likelihood of occurrence, detail them in a document. Develop a method to evaluate the impact of each risk, then consider the extent of the potential harm and the difficulty of recovery. Determine the controls you may apply to limit potential risks. To predict your revenue cycle, look at patterns over time. Additionally, evaluate the effect risks have on your business, and consider a risk’s importance as well as the possibility that it will affect your business.

Periodically review your risks. Your risk assessment is not a one-time commitment; it is instead an ongoing an ongoing responsibility. At the end of each year, you should evaluate your risk management procedures to assess how you manage risks. Additionally, keep an eye out for emerging risks that may not have been significant during the prior evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Risk assessments are an essential component of managing a business. Your business risk assessment can be used to inform decisions about funding. A quick risk assessment will assist you in avoiding problems that could impact your finances. You learn from the assessment what actions you should take to safeguard your company. This will enable you to recognize the situations you need to deal with, and steer clear of. In addition to helping you internally, a financial risk assessment can aid in your readiness for financer interactions. Before lending you money, these people want to know how risky your business is. They consider the potential of your business expanding as well as your likelihood of repaying the loan. By putting the aforementioned risk assessment methods into practice, you may control any potential risk to your business. Prepare your risk assessment plan so that you can take the time to identify and manage the risks that your company faces.

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on January 31, 2023 and can be found here.


Jaiden Moore, at the time of this post, is a second-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. He has a B.A. in Liberal Studies from North Carolina A&T State University, and is interested in civil litigation. Jaiden is Treasurer of the International law society and is a member of the Black Law Students Association as well as the Business Law Society at Dickinson Law.

 

 

Sources: 

https://safetymanagement.eku.edu/blog/risk-identification/

https://www.assp.org/news-and-articles/conducting-a-risk-assessmenthttps://www.patriotsoftware.com/blog/accounting/small-business-risk-analysis-assessment-purpose/

https://www.projectmanagement.com/contentPages/article.cfm?ID=274371&thisPageURL=/articles/274371/Brainstorming-Risk#_=_

https://www.berkeleywellbeing.com/pessimism.html#:~:text=Pessimists%20typically%20have%20a%20gloomy,t%20willing%20to%20take%20risks.

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/financial-theory/09/risk-management-business.asp

https://www.lucidchart.com/blog/risk-assessment-process

No One Wants to Commute: 4 Considerations if Your Organization is Moving to Full-Time Remote Work

By: Eric Le

 In January 2023, Meta abandoned its San Francisco office, an office space with 400,000 square feet in downtown San Francisco.1 Meta had rented out the space five years earlier to make space for the employees behind Instagram. The lease termination was eight years early, as Meta’s lease was set to expire in March 2031.

Meta’s lease termination adds to the already colossal—21 million square foot—inventory of vacant office space in SF. That number amounts to an office vacancy rate of 27.6%. For comparison, that vacancy rate was 3.7% before the global pandemic.2

Over on the East Coast, Meta is also dismantling its office in Manhattan. Salesforce is doing the same. Last year, about 20% of Manhattan’s offices were completely vacant.

As the pandemic ebbs and flows, and COVID restrictions phase in and out, it’s hard to predict the necessity of an office space. The late 2022 massive tech layoffs only exacerbated the problem. Many businesses and organizations are transitioning to full-time remote work. When they do, they must decide whether to terminate their commercial leases early. So, here are a few things to be aware of if you are faced with the decision to terminate early.

Surrender obligations

Your commercial lease is likely to have a clause that addresses your surrender obligations. In general, the tenant must return the commercial property, such as an office space, to a broom-clean state. A broom-clean state means all of the tenant’s personal property is removed from the premises. Alternatively,  some commercial leases will allow the tenant to return the space as-is. An as-is return is favorable for the departing tenant because it allows the tenant to leave the property in its current condition and with any existing faults. If your commercial lease already demands a broom-clean return, it might be worthwhile to negotiate with the landlord for an as-is return.

Considerations for tenants

Tenants wanting to relieve their obligations under a commercial lease must be careful. In Pennsylvania, a landlord must accept the tenant’s early termination in order for the tenant to be free of her obligations, such as the obligation to pay rent.3 Therefore, the best practice for a tenant is to document the landlord’s acceptance of the surrender in a written lease termination agreement. The landlord must explicitly accept the surrender of the property and do so in writing. If a landlord does not accept your surrender, you are legally liable for the ongoing rent.

Considerations for landlords

On the other hand, landlords should also be cognizant of their rights if a tenant terminates early. In Pennsylvania, a landlord may repossess a property even if she did not accept the tenant’s early termination. The mere fact that he resumes possession is not of itself a sufficient foundation upon which to predicate either an acceptance of a surrender or an eviction.4 For example, the landlord has the right to reenter the premises to clean and renovate the space without accepting the tenant’s surrender. However, landlords must be careful in repossessing the property to make sure that she does not create a hostile environment for the tenant to reoccupy the property, resume the landlord-tenant relationship, or renew the commercial lease.

Most importantly, the landlord also has the right to start subletting the premises without accepting the tenant’s surrender (thereby not relieving the tenant of his obligations under the lease).5

Security Deposits

Most commercial leases will require the tenant to commit to a security deposit. In Pennsylvania, the applicable law for security deposits is the Pennsylvania Landlord & Tenant Act of 1951. The good news is that the act provides robust protection for tenants, such as the right to receive your security deposit and any interests accrued.6 The bad news is that only residential tenants are entitled to these rights.7 Therefore, commercial tenants in Pennsylvania do not have a statutory right to recover their security deposits.

Instead, the amount and the return of the security deposit are up for negotiations in Pennsylvania. Thus, landlords and tenants in Pennsylvania must be intentional when reserving their rights to the security deposit when they enter a commercial lease. Lack of a security deposit provision in the commercial lease may limit a tenant’s rights if she decides to terminate early.

Key Takeaway 

These are just a few among the many considerations a tenant and landlord have when facing an early termination of a commercial lease. It’s also important to note that terminating early is not just beneficial to tenants—some landlords may want to terminate early, too. Tenants may want to terminate early because there is no longer a use for an office. Landlords may want to terminate early because they need the space for another lucrative opportunity. Thus, if you are the party that receives the early termination request, you must recognize that you have the upper hand and negotiate your departure accordingly.

 

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 1, 2023 and can be found here.


Minh “Eric” Le, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. He has interned for the Federal Public Defenders, and the Pennsylvania Office of the Attorney General, in the Financial Enforcement Section. Eric also worked as a Summer Associate with Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney. Eric is a first-generation college and law student. He was born in Vietnam and raised in Ho Chi Minh City, before moving to Brooklyn, New York, in 2002.

Sources:

1. Sydney Boyo, How San Francisco Can Tackle Two of its Biggest Issues: office vacancies and housing, CNBC (Dec. 30, 2022, 8:05 AM), https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/30/two-of-san-franciscos-biggest-issues-office-vacancies-and-housing.html.

2. Natalie Wong, Tech Layoffs Mean Even More Empty Offices in NYC, San Francisco, Bloomberg (Jan. 10, 2023, 1:45 PM), https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-10/tech-layoffs-remote-work-mean-more-pain-for-empty-office-buildings?leadSource=uverify%20wall.

3. Hochman v. Kuebler, 53 Pa. Super. 481, 484–85 (1913) (noting that tenants’ obligations under a commercial lease are not discharged unless the landlord accepts the surrender).

4. Kahn v. Bancamerica-Blair Corp., 327 Pa. 209, 213 (1937)

5. Id. at 214

6. 68 Pa. Stat. Ann. § 250.511a

7. 68 Pa. Stat. Ann. § 250.512 (“This section shall apply only to residential leaseholds and not to commercial leaseholds.”)

Small Businesses Incentivized to Go Green

By: Lisa Dang

Small business and start-up companies incur a variety of costs to operate their businesses. However, no matter the size of a business, energy consumption ranks among the top five business expenses. The primary use of energy includes operating vehicles, heating and cooling, and operating equipment. The ability to cut down on fixed costs such as utilities may significantly improve cash flow. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), the average monthly utility bill for commercial buildings is $650 per month with the northeast region averaging a higher cost of $727 per month. The cost of electricity and natural gas is only expected to rise in the coming years and remain volatile. Whether your company has been in operation for years or is beginning to get off the ground, managing and saving on energy costs is not only beneficial for the business but also for the environment. With the recent enactment of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), small businesses are incentivized to deploy clean energy technology to reap significant cost-saving benefits.

I. The inflation reduction act 

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) is a landmark piece of legislation, representing the largest climate and energy spending package in U.S History.[3] The IRA mandates a nationwide reduction of carbon emissions of roughly 40% by 2030 and includes an investment of $369 billion in energy and security climate change programs. Here is how the IRA can help your business reduce energy costs and foster a cleaner environment.

1. The Deploying Solar

Small businesses and start-up companies can reap significant tax breaks from purchasing and deploying solar energy systems. The IRA expanded the Federal Tax Credit for Solar Photovoltaics (PV) systems. There are two available solar tax credit options available for businesses:

        • Investment tax credit (ITC): provides a tax credit that allows businesses to deduct a percentage of the cost of installing a solar energy system from their federal income tax liability
        • Production Tax Credit (PTC): provides a per kilowatt-hour (kWh) tax credit based on the amount of electricity generated and sold by qualified energy projects

 

Under the IRA, the ITC enables business owners to receive a one-time 30% tax credit for PV system installation. In contrast, the solar PTC can be claimed every year over the 10-year credit period at the current rate of 2.6 cents/kWh for commercial projects (adjusted for inflation). The size of the system must be under 1 megawatt (MW) to claim an ITC or PTC, and project owners cannot claim both credits for the same property. Projects may qualify for additional bonus credits of 10% if located in a low-income area.

It is important to note that these tax credits are only available for solar systems placed in service from 2022 or later and begin construction before 2033. These credits are designed to phase out after 2032, thus it is critical that small businesses begin strategizing how to support the deployment of solar technology sooner rather than later.

A. Which is Better for My Business: ITC or PTC? 

The decision to choose an ITC or PTC depends on multiple variables. Start-up companies or small businesses that may be cash-strapped may benefit from opting for the ITC, providing upfront credit against the capital expense used to install the solar systems. In most cases, the ITC is a great option for small businesses that require only a small PV system to help save money on energy bills. In contrast, larger-scale PV projects should opt for the PTC because they provide an attractive cash flow since credits are earned over time. Ultimately, PTCs and ITCs provide competitive incentives and cash flow opportunities for many small businesses and start-up companies.

B. What if My Business Does Not Have the Capital to Invest in Solar Technology?

In cases where your business does not have the capital to invest and own a solar system, it is still possible to reap significant cost-saving benefits on utilities through power purchasing agreements (PPA). For many businesses, entering into a third-party PPA is the best option to help reduce energy costs with little to no startup investment associated with the solar installation. A solar PPA is a financing agreement in which a third-party developer purchases the solar system, installs it on your workplace building, and charges a reduced fee for the electricity generated. While your business may not claim the tax credit under a PPA, the developer may claim the tax credit and may use that tax credit to help lower your monthly payment.

2. Electric Vehicles

 

For the first time in the U.S., the IRA provides a tax credit for businesses purchasing qualified electric vehicles (EVs). The credit is up to $7,500 for new EVs and the vehicle must be used for business purposes, not for resale, and primarily used in the U.S.

For a vehicle to qualify for the tax credit, the vehicle must:

        • Have an external charging source
        • Have a gross vehicle weight rating of less than 14,000 lbs
        • Be made by a qualified manufacturer

If you are unsure whether your vehicle will qualify for a tax credit, the Department of Energy has made it easy by simply entering your vehicle identification number (VIN). Check it out here.

II. Conclusion 

All businesses must factor in the cost of utilities and energy consumption. With energy prices rising and fluctuating at unpredictable rates, the switch to solar energy can save small businesses and start-up companies significant money. Now, more than ever, businesses are incentivized to go green with the recent enactment of the Inflation Reduction Act. Businesses that take advantage of the solar opportunities and EV tax credits are situated to not only save money but help save the environment.

 

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on January 31, 2023 and can be found here.


Lisa Dang, at the time of this post, is a 3L at Penn State–Dickinson Law. Dang hails from Richmond, Virginia, and graduated from the College of William and Mary with a BS in Neuroscience and Philosophy. Before coming to law school, Dang worked as a Research Assistant in the division of Hematology, Oncology & Palliative Care at Virginia Commonwealth University. Dang has a wide-range of interests and has been exploring many different classes and areas of law. In between work and school, Dang plays competitive Ultimate Frisbee.

Sources:

The Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. § 1531 et seq.

Id. § 1532.

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/03/11/2022-05134/civil-penalties-2022-inflation-adjustments-for-civil-monetary-penalties

Incorporating in Delaware—the Good, the Bad & the Equity

By: Dennis Scoggin

    When people think of Delaware … let’s face it, people don’t think of Delaware. But it is the business world’s best-kept secret. About 65% of Fortune 500 companies are incorporated in Delaware (e.g., Amazon, Google, Tesla, etc.). This is no mere fluke. The state boasts a business-friendly climate and extensive body of corporate law. And here’s the kicker: no corporate income tax. Setting up a company in Delaware is so streamlined, that it is home to more than 1.8 million companies—more than the number of Delaware residents! Which is surprising, considering the state has no sales tax, investment income taxes, inheritance taxes, or personal property taxes. A nondescript office building that spans less than a city block in Wilmington, Delaware, is the official incorporation address of more than 285,000 global companies! Notably, you do not have to live in Delaware to incorporate a company in Delaware. Also, a Delaware physical address is not required as long as you retain a Delaware registered agent for your Delaware corporation or LLC.

Predictable legal landscape

The predictability of the Delaware court system is a boon for companies—business issues are predictable because of the Delaware Court of Chancery. This forum is the nation’s preeminent corporate court. It is responsible for developing the case law on corporate matters because its judges are experts in corporate law (no juries in this court!). The Court of Chancery handles matters in equity, and focuses on corporate issues, trusts, estates, other fiduciary matters, disputes involving the purchase of land and questions of title to real estate, as well as commercial and contractual matters. The average civil lawsuit can span several years, but with judges who specialize in corporate law and the lack of juries, along with primacy of corporate-related cases, means that similar cases can be decided swiftly.

Taxes schmaxes

Delaware is considered a tax haven because of its unparalleled tax savings. If your company is incorporated in Delaware, but you conduct business out of state, there is no state income tax. There is also no inheritance tax on stock held by non-Delaware residents. Additionally, there is no state sales tax on intangible personal property (like royalty payments). Also, non-residents who own shares of stock in Delaware corporations are not subject to Delaware taxes. Some companies, however, avoid their in-state income tax by establishing subsidiary or shell companies that hold various intangible assets but do not directly run business operations.

Anonymity & expediency

Did you know that you can conduct same-day business filings in Delaware? The incorporation process can take less than an hour! You can find filing forms and fees here. If you plan on creating an LLC, there is no requirement to make the names and addresses of your LLC’s members and/or managers a matter of public record. As a Delaware registered agent, you would only need to reveal this information: (1) in the event of a legal proceeding; or (2) at the request of law enforcement. Officers, directors, and shareholders do not need to be Delaware residents.  Further, small businesses are allowed to have just one person hold the role of officer, director, and shareholder. When it comes to raising capital, whether via angel investors or venture capital, they often prefer you incorporate in Delaware because they are familiar with its business laws.

Considerations 

Size matters. Small businesses do not get significant tax savings—you do not get to avoid taxes outright. Delaware does not tax companies incorporated in the state that do not do business there, but you are still responsible for taxes imposed by your home state. Your company will also have to pay the Delaware franchise tax on its shares’ value, but this could be minimal compared to the income taxes your home state may charge. Albeit minimal for small businesses, franchise taxes are subject to increases based on the number of shares and improved value. You may also need to pay a franchise tax in your home state. If you plan on conducting business in another state, you still need to satisfy your state’s filing and licensing requirements for conducting business there (Delaware registered agent fees may vary). If your company is involved in a lawsuit, you will need to travel to Delaware to handle any legal disputes. You will also have to account for legal fees to retain a Delaware attorney to maneuver the legal landscape.

Key Takeaway 

In sum, the key advantages to incorporating in Delaware are tax benefits, privacy, expediency, simplified structure, and predictability in corporate law. Delaware offers convenience to companies who incorporate within the state, but said benefits are primarily geared towards large corporations. If you have a small business, you should carefully weigh the additional costs involved against the benefits of incorporating in Delaware. But if you structure your company properly, you will reap the privileges of being a Delaware corporation.

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 1, 2023 and can be found here.


 Dennis Scoggin, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. Upon graduation, Dennis will work as a judicial clerk for the Delaware Court of Chancery.

 

 

 

Sources:

https://corp.delaware.gov/

https://courts.delaware.gov/forms/download.aspx?id=135828

https://www.forbes.com/advisor/business/incorporating-in-delaware/

https://www.delawareinc.com/before-forming-your-company/benefits-of-incorporating-in-delaware/?campaign

https://www.legalnature.com/guides/top-3-best-states-to-start-and-incorporate-a-business

https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/incorporating-in-delaware-advantages-and-disadvantages

https://sunlightfoundation.com/2016/04/06/why-are-there-so-many-anonymous-corporations-in-delaware/

How to Start Up: Picking the Perfect Name for Your Business

By: Julia Martinez

Let’s talk about naming your business. As you would expect, branding can make or break a project. 82% of investors say name recognition is an important factor guiding them in their investment decisions, and brands with poor company branding pay 10% higher salaries. A name is a long-term commitment, and can be a daunting task – it took Warby Parker six months and over 2,000 options to find their brand’s perfect name.

You’ve probably seen ads online for business-name generators or “brand identity toolkits.” There are both free and paid tools all over the internet that can suggest names, domains, and URLs. In addition to the branding criteria, try the free tools available at the end of the article for inspiration in choosing the perfect name.

three important criteria for a brand name 

1. Memorable

A 2010 study found that consumers have a more positive reaction to brands with repetitively structured names, like Kit-Kat and Coca-Cola. You want something that reflects who you are, what you’re trying to achieve, and what sets you apart.

2. Accessible 

One of the reasons why picking a name can be so difficult! There really is a sweet spot between unique and bizarre. If your brand name is too hard to interpret or pronounce (or more importantly, Google) you’re going to run into problems with brand recognition.

3. Evolvable

Ask yourself these two questions: Is the name something you can eventually trademark and own? And is it a name that can grow with your company and stay relevant to your offered products or services?

vetting your name 

Once you get a short list of names together, you will want to determine whether or not any of the names are taken. You don’t have to trademark your business name to run business activity under it, but you do need to register a business if you start any sort of commercial activity, like promoting goods or services. If that’s the case, your business needs to be registered and you’ll need to receive a Tax ID before you can legally operate business activity.

It should be noted that the registered business name chosen doesn’t have to be the same as your business it just needs to be an available name. In other words, you can have your registered name be completely different from your public name – just make sure that your public name isn’t trademarked by someone else! Technically, you can use the same business name as someone else if the name isn’t protected by a trademark. However, if both businesses are in the same geographical location or sell similar goods and services, it is not recommended.

checking trademarks

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)’s Trademark Electronic Search System is the best way to search for all applied-for and registered trademarks. If the name is available, filing a trademark for a business name with the USPTO costs between $50 and $600, depending on if you’re registering the trademark in one state, multiple states, and the type of trademark being registered. Note that if you’re a foreign-domiciled applicant, you are required to hire a U.S.-licensed attorney to represent you at the USPTO.

do i need a trademark?

As mentioned earlier, you can legally run a business without any registered trademarks. But going without a trademark is operating without legal protection – you risk potential lawsuits from other companies of similar names in the future, and you risk your name being copied by others. Trademarks won’t only protect the brand name, but they can protect your logo, slogan, or other related intellectual property.

what can’t i trademark?

You can’t trademark descriptive terms, so any generic words, slogans, colors, smells, and sounds cannot be registered with the USPTO. If it’s a non-generic word, you could register it, but you would need to demonstrate how it represents the business.

Inventions and works of authorship (like writings, reports, drawings, sculptures, illustrations, video recordings, audio recordings, computer programs, and charts) cannot be trademarked and need to be protected with either copyrights or patents instead.

online naming tools

Now that you know some of the basic rules around naming your brand, it’s time to get brainstorming! The links below are some great examples of online tools that can help you to come up with the perfect brand name, domain name, and URL. Just remember – your brand name should be memorable, accessible, and evolvable.

For Names: Shopify, Wordoid

For URLS: Brand Bucket

For Domains: Bust a Name, Panabee

 

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 9, 2022.


Julia Martinez, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. She has a B.A. in Criminal Justice and Political Science from Temple University, and has interests in criminal, civil, and administrative law. Julia is President of the Latinx Law Student Association, a 3L Class Representative, and Treasurer of Phi Alpha Delta.

 

Sources:

https://www.smallbizgenius.net/by-the-numbers/branding-statistics/#gref

https://www.quora.com/How-was-the-name-Warby-Parker-chosen

https://businessnamegenerator.com/how-to-find-out-if-a-business-name-is-taken-available/

https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/why-hire-private-trademark-attorney

How Non-Profits Rely on “Legal Intern Volunteers”

By: Cristian Mejia

Should nonprofit organizations expect to attract law student interns by offering only unpaid positions? During law school, students are strongly encouraged to take a series of internships during summers and their second and third years of law school. There are many paid internships, especially for upper-grade level positions. In the non-profit sector, however, paid internships are hard to obtain and when obtained they still pay well below comparable work at firms. 

what is the difference between interns and intern volunteers?

As a general business model, nonprofit organizations typically offer unpaid internships for law students and categorize them as intern volunteers. The U.S. Department of Labor explains that internship and volunteering roles are not interchangeable categorizations, though often used interchangeably. They further explain that an internship is guided towards transitioning classroom work in a major field of study to work experience, while volunteering is guided towards donating time for humanitarian purposes. Both designations may be unpaid, but unpaid internships have certain requirements. Please follow this link for a breakdown of those definitions provided by William & Mary University: intern or volunteer.

how are non-profits usually funded?

Non-profits are philanthropic organizations that usually work on a small budget. They generally receive their funding from grants, individual donations, or other fundraising sources. The funding they receive is primarily to be used for benefiting the purposes of their mission. This means that while nonprofits may want to pay interns, they risk not having enough funds for their permanent employees or to allocate to the services they provide.  According to the IRS, tax-exempt nonprofits are required to pay “reasonable” salaries to their employees. So nonprofits that can pay interns, run into the problem of trying to offer competitive rates. Under the constraints of the reasonable pay standard of the IRS, how reasonable is it for nonprofits to try to compete with for-profit firms that can offer much higher pay than the general stipend usually offered? These stipends are typically calculated by living expenses for the duration of the internship, and are often only offered after the student has sought out and been unable to obtain funding from other sources.

what do interns generally offer?

Considering the difficulty of paying interns for their service we may ask, what do interns offer? Generally, interns bring in little to no experience, limited knowledge in the field, and are joining for a short term. If internships are generally for the benefit of the intern, why should interns be paid? Some may disagree that internships are purely for the sake of the intern. What legal interns lack in experience, they much up for in the ability to work and handle tasks usually required to be completed by staff at the organization. While time is spent training and giving feedback to a temporary worker, that intern is nonetheless providing services. They are doing intake calls, data entry, legal research and writing assignments, and in some cases much more essential work. It is hard to consider that work is non-compensable.

The bargaining power between the nonprofit and the intern is split, though the organization retains a better position. The nonprofit is aware that law students are not required but strongly encouraged to take internships during the summers and in many curriculums required to have external internships during their second and third years. Further, nonprofits are bound by the limitations of the fields for which they offer services. As a philanthropic organization, the nonprofit expects students who wish to work for them to be civic-minded and understand the needs of the organization.

should all interns be paid?

Leaders of nonprofit organizations have budgeting complications unique to their field. They face pressure from their donors to meet expectations of how much service they should be providing with the money they donate and as years progress donors expect the same quality of advocacy while funding is stretched thin. To respond to these pressures, studies have found that organizations resort to cutting overhead expenditures, including facilities improvements, and competitive salaries for qualified professionals. This includes staff at all levels, leaving organizations to frequently resort to hiring less qualified staff, or expecting more qualified staff to accept fractions of what they may obtain elsewhere.

Accepting an unpaid internship extends beyond just obtaining work experience. Interns get to be a part of something dedicated to serving the community and extending services for those who do not generally have access to those services. An intern is not a volunteer, but it may be fair to consider an internship experience as dual purpose by both obtaining legal experience and providing public service. The relationship between the legal intern and the nonprofit is one where each requires the other. Nonprofits understand that they are grooming the nonprofit legal professionals of the future. While today they may only be training a temporary worker, this worker may very well be a part of their organization in the future. Finding those who accept less pay, or no pay, at this early stage, may prepare them for a career of compromising salary for providing free legal services.

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 11, 2022 and can be found here.


Cristian Mejia, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. Originally from New Jersey, Cristian graduated from Montclair University and prior to law school, worked as a paralegal at a civil litigation law firm. Cristian has interned with non-profit Immigration organizations, the Adams County Public Defender’s Office and the Department of Justice. Upon graduation Cristian is interested in practicing within the fields of Civil Rights and Equal Protection of the law, Immigration, Criminal Law and Civil Litigation.

Sources:

https://www.score.org/resource/balancing-nonprofits-and-paid-employeeshttps://www.thebalancesmb.com/can-nonprofits-pay-staff-2501893

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/i990sj.pdfhttps://www.volunteering.com.au/internships-versus-volunteering-use-top-5-tips-tell-difference/

https://www.wm.edu/offices/revescenter/issp/visasandimmigration/f1student/employment/volunteerunpaidinternships/index.php

https://ssir.org/articles/entry/the_nonprofit_starvation_cycle

Small Business Owners Beware: Proactive Measures to Avoid Costly Litigation

By: Lauren Stahl

As a small business owner, you are more likely concerned with sales, managing employees, and cash flow than potential lawsuits. However, many small business owners will face the threat of a lawsuit at some point. And the financial impact can be devastating. A recent study from the U.S. Chamber Institute of Legal Reform revealed that tort liability costs are a “significant drain on…small businesses in particular.”

For many small businesses, which survive on small profit margins, litigation costs are crippling, if not fatal. The effects of litigation can reach far beyond financial loss. An impending lawsuit can—and will—add additional stress to you and your employees. Sitting in a courtroom will not help you to maintain and grow your business. A lawsuit can also harm your business’s reputation, especially if the case is publicized by a local or national media outlet.

To avoid costly litigation, you should consider the following proactive steps to keep your business out of the courtroom and the headlines.

hire experienced lawyers

Many businesses, including small businesses, will have contracts with third parties and employees. Many legal disputes arise surrounding the interpretation of a contract. Often, litigation can be avoided if an experienced lawyer drafts or reviews those contracts.

Hiring a lawyer can be expensive. But spending $500 or $1,000, for example, to have a lawyer draft or review a contract could help the business avoid a $200,000 lawsuit. Cost is relative. A modest sum of money upfront could save a small business an extraordinary sum of money in the future. Consider, too, that something in your business will go wrong—maybe not today but someday. And at that time, a relationship with a lawyer who is willing to help on short notice will likely be necessary.

PUT EVERYTHING IN WRITING

Small business owners might have the temptation to verbally agree or shake hands on an agreement. But think again! All contracts should be in writing. As mentioned above, many legal issues arise from interpreting contracts. Putting contracts in writing will help to avoid miscommunications and misunderstandings about goods, services, expectations, and payments.

Additionally, keeping a strong written record is important. Business owners should keep a record of all email correspondence, invoices or other statements, company policies and procedures, among other documents.

Why is keeping a written record so important? Written email correspondence can help decipher exactly what you agreed to. Invoices and other statements reveal when balances are due. Company policies and procedures should also be in writing as they can be used to demonstrate nondiscriminatory employment practices. Putting contracts in writing and keeping a written record are essential to avoid costly litigation.

DEVELOP CLEAR WORKPLACE POLICIES FOR FAIR AND CONSISTENT PRACTICES

Businesses create workplace policies to provide guidance on how to consistently handle workplace situations and manage expectations. Most policies provide direction for employees. Workplace policies help to distinguish appropriate from inappropriate behavior. They also help to maintain order within the business and ensure that its employees are treated fairly and equally.

Businesses do not need to create policies for every possible unanticipated event. Doing so would limit the ability to address individual situations and employee needs as they arise. But businesses do need policies that provide clear guidelines to ensure legal compliance and fair, equal, and consistent practices within the business. For example, business owners should develop policies to create consistency and fair treatment among employees (e.g., paid time off and benefits eligibility). Business owners may also want to create a policy that addresses appropriate employee behavior or conduct (e.g., attendance policy, code of conduct, and social media policy).

As small business owners, you should not only create clear policies but also communicate those policies with employees. You will also likely need to update and revise those policies over time to address the changing workplace and ensure compliance with the law.

Business owners should consult an experienced lawyer in developing these policies. Creating, communicating, and implementing company policies in a fair and consistent manner will help small businesses avoid litigation.

conduct research on people & companies before doing business

While not all legal disputes can be prevented, some can. Consider what hiring people who lack integrity, honesty, competence, and professionalism could do to your business. Or what doing business with less than reputable companies could do.

These types of people and companies could harm not only you or your business but also third parties, such as your customers. This exposes you to even more liability.

Prior to entering an employee or business contract, take your time. Request multiple references from potential candidates and take the time to call those references. Have conversations in a variety of settings with prospective employees, vendors, distributors, etc. Conduct social media searches.

When you are hiring, you will want to make decisions based on what will be best for your business now and in the future. While you may need to hire someone quickly, do your best to hire the right person or business. Such practices will save you time and energy in the long run. Especially if hiring the wrong person or company results in an impending lawsuit.

consider another cost-effective choice: mediation

Complaints against other employees or management in the company will arise. Having a plan for early resolution can prevent these issues from escalating.

Utilizing mediation—versus litigation—is a way for businesses to avoid the costly litigation process and move right to resolving the dispute. Through this process, a mediator works with both parties to manage communication and identify the parties’ real interests. Mediation is a great alternative to consider. Its beauty is found in its low cost, speed, and confidentiality (discussions cannot later be used in court).

main takeaway

Costly litigation can be avoided. Consider these proactive steps to keep your focus on what is important: your business.

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 7th, 2022, and can be found here.


Lauren Stahl, at the time of this post, is a rising 3L at Penn State Dickinson Law. She has a B.S. in Biology from Georgetown University. Formerly a medical researcher at the National Institutes of Health and Penn State College of Medicine, Lauren has interests in the intersection of health law and business law. Lauren currently serves as a Comments Editor of the Dickinson Law Review and is a member of the Health Law Society and Women’s Law Caucus. She is also Professor Prince’s Team Lead and the Lead TA for the Legal Writing program.

 

Sources:

https://instituteforlegalreform.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/FINAL-Small-Business-Tort-Costs-10.20.20.pdf

https://www.forbes.com/sites/allbusiness/2019/04/21/cash-flow-challenges-facing-small-business-owners/?sh=661c14136561

https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/rs265tot.pdf

https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/en/insights/articles/small-business-attorneys-handling-more-litigation-in-house

https://www.wolterskluwer.com/en/expert-insights/workplace-rules-for-business-owners-and-employees

https://www.cohenandmalad.com/tips-for-small-businesses-to-avoid-litigation/

https://cuetolawgroup.com/how-to-protect-your-business-from-lawsuit/

https://www.hsolaw.com/blog/how-to-avoid-litigation

Anti-Trust Law: It’s Not Just For The Big Guys!

By: Fredner Prevalus

If one were to ask which areas of law are relevant to an entrepreneur or small business owner, typical responses would likely begin with contract law, agency law, or torts. Then responses would likely move on to employment law, tax law, or property law-including IP/Patents. There’s a strong likelihood that anti-trust law would be near the bottom of that list if it’s even mentioned at all. Unfortunately, outside of large corporate mergers, this area of law is often neglected and overlooked, especially in small business legal discussions. It’s the Cinderella of legal academia. In our brief discussion, we’ll help dispel some common misconceptions and discuss why anti-trust law matters and how anti-trust law can potentially have an impact on small business owners and entrepreneurs.                

playing monopoly

One of the principal inter-related aims of antitrust law is the prevention of the collectivization and concentration of market power and the protection of consumer welfare. A brief and highly simplified review of basic economic theory may be helpful here. Market structures exist along a continuum. A monopoly structure-single seller-occupies one extreme pole while perfectly competitive market-many sellers- occupies the other. Ideally, with limited exceptions, the perfectly competitive market structure is preferred because prices are at equilibrium; the price that buyers and sellers are willing and able to trade absent any market impediments. The equilibrium price implies that if a seller attempted to set a price above this level, they would lose sales and revenue, thus becoming unprofitable. A seller in this market is a price taker. In contrast, the monopolist has market power or the ability to influence prices and set a price significantly above the competitive equilibrium thus increasing their profits. This has the deleterious effect of reducing output and creating a deadweight loss. A deadweight loss is a loss in potential economic activity as a segment of buyers can no longer participate in the market.

per-se problems


Naturally, with the prospect of capturing significant profits, there’s a strong incentive for a business to emulate some of the features of a monopoly through contract, collusion, or cooperation with competitors, suppliers, and/or others. Some of these practices, by their very nature, have predominantly anticompetitive effects and are condemned outright regardless of their actual effects or the size of the participants. These are called “per se” violations and include but are not necessarily limited to price fixing, bid rigging, customer segmentation, and market allocation. In addition, the first sections of the 1890 Sherman Act, the principal statutory authority on anti-trust law, suggests that even the act of making an agreement to engage in these practices is a criminal violation.

let’s be reasonable 

Even for practices where the circumstances and effects are taken into consideration-known as a rule of reason analysis-the disruptive and damaging toll defending a suit can have on a business may be disastrous. To facilitate the transmission of information for the betterment of their business, many owners and decision-makers actively engage with other market participants formally or informally through meetings, correspondence, and membership in trade associations. These practices are often a natural part of doing business, however, a small business owner needs to be mindful that the substance of some of these communications may be a potential violation. There have been several seminal cases where a simple email correspondence discussing prices to set between competitors was sufficient to establish an antitrust violation.

big fish in a little pond   

A prevailing misconception is that anti-trust law applies only to “big” businesses. However, what constitutes big business can be relative and is highly contingent on how the market is defined. In anti-trust law, a relevant market is distinguishable in two principal ways, a product market and a geographic market. A product market is determined by applying the hypothetical monopolist test. This test analyzes the consumer substitution effects of a Small but Significant Non-Transitory Increase in Price (” SSNIP”). If a hypothetical monopolist is unable to apply an SSNIP, then the relevant market definition must be expanded to include substitute goods/services. Moreover, the geographic market refers to a market’s physical or virtual boundaries. A similar hypothetical monopolist test is used to determine the geographic market which is typically limited by transaction costs. This means that the relevant market is not necessarily national in scope but can be defined regionally or locally and the relevant product/service market can be defined so narrowly as to include a few providers. Therefore, a small business may have more market power and influence than they realize. As an illustration, suppose only three restaurants in a town provide Caribbean/African cuisine. Suppose the restaurants were part of the same entity and decided to noticeably increase their menu prices. If a significant number of their customer base did not switch to alternate cuisines, then other cuisines would not be part of the same product/service market as the Caribbean/African cuisine. Also, suppose that the next nearest restaurant offering Caribbean/African cuisine was an hour’s drive away. If most customers would not be willing to travel to that restaurant, then that restaurant is not part of the town’s relevant geographic market for Caribbean/African cuisine.

some useful tips

Although market power alone does not constitute a violation, it’s a significant factor in conjunction with other actions. Other potentially illegal actions include but are not limited to predatory pricing/bidding, boycotts/refusals to deal, vertical integration-price squeezing, vertical restraints-price ceiling/floor, tying-exclusive dealing-bundled discounts. The scope of anti-trust law in regulating business conduct is broad. Anti-trust law is not exclusively limited to the mergers & acquisitions of fortune 500 companies trading shares on wall street. It can have important implications for a small business operating on main street. In fact, several significant landmark cases involved businesses operating at a regional or local level (Aspen Skiing Co. v. Aspen Highlands Skiing Corp (1985)). It’s important to remember that operating one’s establishment in a way that’s unfair to competitors or consumers is a potentially losing strategy. It’s recommended that business owners have some familiarity with anti-trust legal principles especially as their business continues to grow. A good first step is to review the FTC’s Guide to Anti-trust Laws which can be accessed through the link below.

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 11th, 2022, and can be found here.


Fredner Prevalus, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. He is a Haitian-Canadian from Toronto, Canada. He earned his MA in Economics at McMaster University and worked in the financial services industry prior to law school. He is the current President of the American Constitution Society, a former Student Bar Association Budget Committee Member, Law Lion Ambassador, and Leading Law Student with the Carlisle Borough Council. He recently interned at the Office Of Chief Council-Pennsylvania Department Of State. His general interests lay at the intersection of law, economics, business, and finance. Outside of his academic and professional pursuits he is a health and fitness enthusiast who enjoys traveling with his fiancee Deborah.”

Subchapter V – A Bankruptcy Solution for Small Businesses

By: Zach Javorsky

Small businesses hit hard by the pandemic relied on government stimulus to stay alive. Many small businesses are considering their next move now that crucial stimulus is running out. For a small business with overdue debt, its creditors are likely calling, asking when they will be paid or, worse, making threats about collections and repossessions. As a result, small business owners may ask themselves what they can do to move forward.

One option that might not come to mind is bankruptcy. Historically, bankruptcy was inaccessible for small businesses due to complex regulations, costs, and time. That all changed in February 2020, when the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019 became law, adding Subchapter V to the Bankruptcy Code. Today, Subchapter V may provide a struggling small business with a lifeline and a path forward.

This blog aims to educate small business owners about Subchapter V, how it differs from other types of bankruptcy, and what to expect during the bankruptcy process.

Bankruptcy Jargon
Term Definition
Debtor A business filing bankruptcy
Creditor A person/business to whom the debtor owes money
Plan A document the debtor files that shows how it plans to repay its debts
Confirmation When the judge approves the plan and determines it is feasible and meets all legal requirements

the historical options – chapter 7 and chapter 11

Traditionally, a small business considering bankruptcy had two options: liquidate under Chapter 7 or reorganize under Chapter 11. In a Chapter 7 liquidation, the business closes, its assets are sold, and creditors split the sale proceeds. In Chapter 11, a business reorganizes, staying open, but its debt is restructured. In Chapter 11, the business’s creditors must approve any reorganization plan.

Historically, Chapter 11 was too costly and time-consuming for small businesses, forcing them to close and liquidate under Chapter 7. To learn more about Chapters 7 and 11, Click Here.

a new path forward – subchapter v

Subchapter V is a bankruptcy designed for a small business. Essentially, in Subchapter V, creditors are forced to accept three- or five-year repayment plans. These repayment plans can take debts that are due immediately and spread them throughout the plan. In practice, this means a bankruptcy court will protect the small business as it repays its debts, and creditors will have to stop any attempts to collect debts from the small business.

A small business must owe its creditors less than 2.7 million dollars to qualify for Subchapter V. During the pandemic, Congress raised this limit to 7.5 million dollars through March 2022; it is unknown if this raised limit will continue. Additionally, to be eligible for Subchapter V, a small business must make enough revenue to pay its debts through the repayment plan.

If a small business owes less than 2.7 million dollars, it qualifies for Subchapter V and benefits from the subchapter’s streamlined approach. Subchapter V differs from Chapter 11 in several key ways:

      1. It is cheaper. Fees are typically less because a small business does not pay U.S. Trustee fees, creditor committees fees, and administrative fees can be spread over the plan’s length.
      2. A small business owner can retain its equity.
      3. It allows the business to stay open while repaying its creditors with its disposable income.
      4. Creditors do not have to approve the plan if it’s shown the creditors will receive more than they would in a Chapter 7 liquidation.

Finally, reorganizing is quicker under Subchapter V than Chapter 11. In Subchapter V, a business must file a plan within 90 days, and court approval will come after that. On average, from petition to confirmation of a Subchapter V plan takes 224 days.

the process

A small business considering filing a Subchapter V bankruptcy will need to consult with a bankruptcy attorney. This attorney will answer specific questions regarding the circumstances the business is facing. This blog post will provide an overview of what a small business owner can expect during the process, which has three phases – pre-filing, post-filing, and post-confirmation.

In the pre-filing phase, a business owner will work with their attorney to gather information about the business’s finances. This work includes gathering documents, including federal and state tax returns, invoices, payrolls, a list of creditors, contracts, leases, certificates of incorporation, bylaws, partnership agreements, and a list of the business’s owners. Once the debtor gathers this information, the business’s attorney will file the necessary forms, known as a petition, with a bankruptcy court. Once the debtor’s lawyer files the petition, the automatic stay goes into effect, stopping all creditors’ communications and threats.

The next phase is post-filing and is the most critical. Soon after the business files its petition, the court will appoint a Subchapter V Trustee. This Trustee, often an attorney, will work with the business and its creditors to create a repayment plan. The Subchapter V Trustee will also make statements to the court regarding things such as the value of property, amounts of debt, and whether the plan is ready for confirmation. The Subchapter V Trustee’s recommendations are impactful, and the judge may rely upon them. Once the debtor drafts a feasible repayment plan, meaning that the court believes the business can make the required payments and the creditors get more than they would in Chapter 7, the court will confirm the plan.

Once the plan is confirmed, the business enters the post-confirmation phase. This is when the business has to start making its required payments. If it stops making the payments, the creditors can ask the court for relief. If the business’s circumstances change, leaving it unable to make the required payments, it can ask the court to modify the plan. If the business makes all the required payments, the court will discharge its debts, and the business will leave bankruptcy.

conclusion

Historically, bankruptcy was not an option for a struggling small business. Now, Subchapter V is a powerful tool that gives a small business a path forward. Readers can find additional information below.

 

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 10, 2022, and can be found here.


Zach Javorsky is a recent graduate of Penn State Dickinson Law. He is from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and is a graduate of Allegheny College. Zach plans to become a corporate attorney after graduation. He is a member of the Dickinson Law Review Editorial Board.

 

Sources

11 U.S.C §1181, et seq. [Subchapter V]

11 U.S.C §701, et seq. [Chapter 7]

11 U.S.C. §1101, et seq. [Chapter 11]

United States Courts, Chapter 11 – Bankruptcy Basicshttps://www.uscourts.gov/services-forms/bankruptcy/bankruptcy-basics/chapter-11-bankruptcy-basics (last visited Feb. 10, 2022)

Mark Bossi et al., Subchapter V in the Eighth Circuit: The data from the first 18 months, Thompson Coburn LLP (Sept. 8, 2021), https://www.thompsoncoburn.com/insights/blogs/credit-report/post/2021-09-08/subchapter-v-in-the-eighth-circuit-the-data-from-the-first-18-months

Brett S. Theisen & Natasha Songonuga, Subchapter V Bankruptcy for Middle Market Debtors, Gibbons (Sept. 17, 2021), https://www.gibbonslaw.com/resources/publications/subchapter-v-bankruptcy-for-middle-market-debtors

Amy E. Vulpio, New Subchapter V May be the Bankruptcy Lifeline Small Businesses Need to Survive Covid-19, White and Williams (MAR. 23, 2020), HTTPS://WWW.WHITEANDWILLIAMS.COM/RESOURCES-ALERTS-NEW-SUBCHAPTER-V-MAY-BE-THE-BANKRUPTCY-LIFELINE-SMALL-BUSINESSES-NEED-TO-SURVIVE-COVID-19

William L. Norton III & James Blake Bailey, The Pros and Cons of the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019, Bradley (Aug. 2020), https://www.bradley.com/insights/publications/2020/08/the-pros-and-cons-of-the-small-business-reorganization-act-of-2019

Jennifer McLain, Subchapter V of Chapter 11: New Rules and New Players to Help with Small Business Reorganization, JDSUPRA (Oct. 29, 2021), https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/subchapter-v-of-chapter-11-new-rules-4470399/

J.P. Finet, Subchapter 5 in Chapter 11 Bankruptcy, FindLaw.com (June 30, 2021), https://www.findlaw.com/bankruptcy/business-bankruptcy/subchapter-5-in-chapter-11-bankruptcy.html

Michael R. Herz, Subchapter V, Not a Moment Too Soon, Fox Rothschild (Dec 21, 2020), https://insolvency.foxrothschild.com/2020/12/subchapter-v-not-a-moment-too-soon/

Kenneth T. Lauthenschlager & Charles Middlebrooks, Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019: Subchapter V Explained, Johnsonston Allison Hord (Jan. 21, 2021), https://www.jahlaw.com/small-business-reorganization-act-of-2019-subchapter-v-explained-news-and-events/

Maureen Weidman, Difficult Decisions: Whether to file Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 Bankruptcy and What It Will Mean for You and Your Business, Penn State Dickinson Law (Sept. 24, 2018), https://sites.psu.edu/entrepreneurshiplaw/2018/09/24/difficult-decisions-whether-to-file-chapter-7-or-chapter-11-bankruptcy-and-what-it-will-mean-for-you-and-your-business/

Photo Sources

New York Daily News, https://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/bankruptcy-cases-show-nation-selective-justice-article-1.3244880

Mediatbankry, https://mediatbankry.com/2021/01/14/subchapter-v-trustee-should-not-be-a-debtors-disbursing-agent/

NH Business Review, https://www.nhbr.com/lots-of-questions-few-answers-at-first-gt-advanced-technologies-bankruptcy-hearing/

Transaction Fees: Credit Card Surcharging and Minimum Transaction Amounts

By: Lance Sacknoff
Graphic depicting a credit and debit card side-by-side with bullet points of common characteristics underneath each one

Various practices adopted by many small business owners meant to alleviate the hardships imposed by transaction fees, such as creating a “minimum credit card payment” policy, have become commonplace in small business storefronts across the country.

While a number of these practices may seem innocent enough, federal and several states’ laws regulate or prohibit outright some of these practices, such as assessing convenience fees for credit card use. To avoid the possibility of future private litigation, fines, or even criminal punishment, savvy business owners should make learning about the permissibility of these practices.

transaction fees and practices offsetting costs

magnifying glass on top of a paper magnifying the word CONTRACT

To start accepting credit and debit cards as a form of payment, merchants have to enter into a contract between the merchant and the various credit card issuers: the four biggest issuers of credit and debit cards being Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express. The card issuers often refer to these contracts between card issuers and merchants as a “Merchant Agreement.” The Merchant Agreement will contain, among many other provisions, a number of rules and regulations that a merchant must observe when accepting a credit card as a consumer’s payment for goods sold or services rendered. If the merchant does not follow these regulations, the card issuer can punish the merchant in a number of ways, such as by no longer allowing the merchant to accept Visa credit or debit cards as a form of payment.

Although credit card issuers have developed a number of rules that explicitly address (and sometimes outright prohibit) practices for reducing merchant costs for processing credit card transactions, small business owners’ attempts to reduce these costs are understandable. The average card issuer processing fees vary from 1.3% to 3.5% per transaction, depending upon the brand (or “card network”), the type of merchant, and the type of credit card used.

PAYMENT NETWORK AVG. PROCESSING FEES
Visa Between 1.29% + $.05 to 2.54% + $.10
Mastercard Between 1.29% + $.05 to 2.64% + $.10
Discover Between 1.48% + $.05 to 2.53% + $.10
American Express Between 1.58% + $.10 to 3.45% + $.10
Table data via The Ascent

defining common practices

The Minimum Transaction Amount and Card Surcharging are the two most common practices that could lead a merchant to run afoul of credit card issuer rules. Understanding what these practices entail constitutes the first step in avoiding them or only using them when the law permits:

      1. A minimum transaction amount is the lowest transaction value that a merchant allows for a customer to pay with a card. If a merchant posts a sign that says, “$10 minimum for credit cards,” then a customer trying to purchase a $5 sandwich would have to pay with cash.
      2. Card surcharging occurs when a merchant adds a fee to a customer’s bill when the customer elects to pay with a card. These fees have several names, such as “convenience fee,” “transaction fee,” or “processing charge.” If a customer elects to use a card when buying a $1.50 stick of gum, a merchant surcharges the customer by adding a convenience fee of 20 cents to the bill.

a sign at a business indicating a surcharge for a customer who uses a credit card

permissibility of minimum transaction amounts and surcharging

After the passage of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act in 2010 and subsequent legislation, credit card issuers are no longer allowed to explicitly prohibit any sort of minimum transaction amount. A subsequent 2016 legal settlement to a class action lawsuit brought against the issuers led to uniformity among the issuers in their policies on surcharging and minimum transaction amounts.

minimum transaction amounts permissible but limited

Although no state or federal law prohibits the use of minimum transaction amounts for credit card transactions, issuers have developed uniform rules for the industry to make policies more fair to consumers and merchants alike:

      1. Merchants may set a Minimum Transaction Amount of no more than $10 for any given transaction.
      2. When a merchant sets a minimum transaction amount, they must, typically, provide written notification to the issuer thirty days in advance of instituting the minimum transaction amount.

credit card surcharging permissible but severely

According to the federal Truth in Lending Act (also called “Regulation Z” by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau), surcharging credit card customers is, strictly speaking, allowed, depending on the state in which the merchant is located.

Sixteen states have statutes that either (1) prohibit credit and debit card use surcharges or (2) encourage merchants to offer discounts for cash transactions to offset processing fees: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Nevada, New York, Oklahoma, Texas, Washington, Wisconsin, and Wyoming.

Even if you do not live in a state with a credit card surcharge law, other state laws could address the surcharging practice. For example, Pennsylvania state law does not include a specific prohibition against credit card surcharges. However, a lack of a clear prohibition against levying such surcharges does not mean a Commonwealth court could never deem credit card transaction surcharges as illegal under other consumer protection laws, such as the Commonwealth’s Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL).

The UTPCPL prohibits a number of “unfair or deceptive acts or practices,” including any practices that may create confusion or a misunderstanding. A business that assesses a surcharge to credit cards but not debit cards–despite the two cards looking nearly identical–could constitute an “unfair practice” under the UTPCPL.

Because these statutes vary in their complexity for prohibitions against credit card surcharging, the best course of action would be to avoid the practice entirely and embrace another practice made explicitly legal by the Truth in Lending Act: Cash Discounting.

cash discounting: a viable alternative

Federal agencies, such as the FTC and CFPB have regularly recognized “cash discounting” as permissible under federal law. Although it may seem a matter of semantics, the situation can best be defined as offering a reward, or discount, for cash paying customers rather than a punishment, or fee, for customers paying with credit cards.

Image of a gas station sign with cheaper prices for cash customers

The solution might seem overly simple, but sometimes solutions to sticky legal situations can be. Gas stations offering discounts to cash paying customers have been interpreted as a legal practice for several decades:

“Due to unique open air nature of gasoline service stations, dealer wishing to offer discounts for purchase of gasoline by cash may indicate availability of such discount by sign anywhere on premises which is clearly visible to any customer entering service station area; credit card price clearly disclosed on pump is ‘regular price.’” – Board of Governors of Federal Reserve System Official Staff Interpretation FC-0140

A savvy entrepreneur would integrate this solution for their future business practices. Instead of worry about state and federal statutes, simply ring up the items at a price that would be feasible for business profitability if every customer was using a credit card. In the event the customer uses a debit card or cash, apply a discount. If the customer uses a credit card, don’t. It’s that easy.

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 11, 2022, and can be found here.


Lance Sacknoff, at the time of this post, is a graduating 3L at Pennsylvania State University – Dickinson Law, earning a J.D. and certificate in Entrepreneurship Law: Intellectual Property and Technology, as well as CALI awards in Blockchain & Cryptocurrency Law and Internet Law. As a law clerk for a Carlisle firm, Allied Attorneys of Central Pennsylvania, Mr. Sacknoff currently pursues his passion in helping small business owners navigate a variety of legal issues. He also recently served as a Launchbox panelist on “Demystifying Trademarks: What Small Business Owners Need to Know.”

SOURCES & FURTHER READING

“Colorado Eliminates Ban on Surcharges” – Bass, Barry, and Sims PLC

“Average Credit Card Processing Fees and Costs in 2021” – The Ascent

“FDIC Laws, Regulations, Related Acts” – Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)

“Credit or Debit Card Surcharges Statutes” – National Conference of State Legislatures

§ 1026.4 Finance charge. – Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

“What is a Merchant Agreement?” – Payment Cloud

“Minimum Transaction Amount on a VISA Credit Card” – VISA