The Most Valuable Secrets Must Be Kept Secret – Why Successful Startups Should Utilize Non-Disclosure Agreements

By: Madeleine Kuhns-Baione

Startups that do not utilize Non-Disclosure Agreements (“NDA”) are at higher risk for financial instability or failure. Even if an entrepreneur feels that they can trust others, utilizing NDAs is one of the easiest yet most effective ways to protect a business.

What aRE ndaS?

Non-Disclosure Agreements, commonly called confidentiality agreements, are binding agreements where parties are legally required to keep specific information confidential. Parties to the NDA cannot share the information with third parties or use it for their benefit. NDAs are useful for all aspects of business, including sales meetings, negotiations, discussions with financiers, product suppliers, etc. Most commonly though, NDAs are used with employees and business partners.

What are THE BENEFITS OF ndAS?

1. Protect Intellectual Property

NDAs protect confidential information including, but not limited to – trade secrets, client information, marketing strategies, proprietary processes, coding techniques, and other sensitive information. NDAs give business owners the power to decide what information is confidential and protected. With this power, business owners can establish employee expectations regarding what information is protected and the consequences of violations.

2. May Minimize Competition

If a startup utilizes an NDA, the parties to the NDA are legally bound to keep confidential information from competitors. In addition, they may not legally use this confidential information to start their own competing business while utilizing the same processes, trade secrets, clients, etc. However, NDAs are not the “end all, be all” to minimize competition. NDAs only assure that a business’s confidential information is legally protected.

3. Provide the Ability to Pursue Legal Recourse

The utilization and enforcement of NDAs are particularly helpful for setting employee expectations and legally binding employees and third parties to abide by the agreement. However, an NDA’s effectiveness within a business is never guaranteed, as employees and third parties may choose to violate the NDA. Luckily, NDAs provide fairly easy legal recourse when a breach occurs.

If confidential information is shared in violation of an NDA, a business may file one of the following claims: breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, misappropriation of trade secrets, copyright infringement, or other intellectual property law violations. It is important to note that NDAs offer broad protection. Within an NDA, a business may include proprietary and non-public information that does not meet the standard of a “trade secret,” that other claims require. For example, a misappropriation claim would require that the confidential information meets elemental requirements for a trade secret, while an NDA may not.

If a business does not use an NDA and confidential information is shared, proving that the information is a trade secret may be more difficult. With an NDA violation, a business may file a breach of contract claim, seek an injunction to prevent the employee or third party from further violating the NDA, or the business may file a lawsuit for financial damages for the losses they suffered resulting from the breach.

HOW Can You Ensure That the NDA Is Enforceable?

An NDA is an enforceable contract. For contracts to be enforceable, there must be consideration. In plain language, contracts require a bargain between the employer and the employee or third party. In the case of an NDA for employment, the employer is receiving the protection of confidential information. To enforce the NDA, the employee must receive something in exchange. Some courts have held that at-will employment is sufficient for the NDA to be enforceable. Regardless of the circumstances, NDAs should always be thoroughly reviewed with an attorney, if necessary, to ensure that the NDA will be enforceable.

Even if an NDA appears enforceable, a court may find it is not. This finding may occur when the NDA includes broad language, information that is not confidential, or something illegal. To mitigate these issues, language and word choice should be extremely precise and specify what information is considered confidential under the agreement. Further, if the information stated within the agreement has been widely disclosed or is public knowledge, it is extremely unlikely that a court will uphold the NDA. Lastly, NDAs cannot force employees to engage in illegal conduct, such as legally forcing them to withhold reports of something they are required to report by law.

Although NDAs are easy to draft and utilize, businesses should give them significant time and effort to ensure they will be enforceable. If an entrepreneur utilizes an enforceable NDA, they are taking a big step toward protecting their business and preventing the disclosure of sensitive and confidential information.

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 1, 2023 and can be found here.


Madeleine is a 3L at Penn State Dickinson Law pursuing a joint JD/MBA degree. Madeleine studied International Business and Management at Dickinson College for her undergraduate education. Before attending law school, Madeleine worked as a Claim Manager at a 9/11 Victim Compensation law firm in NYC. Madeleine is interested in pursuing a career in business and/or healthcare law.

How to (Legally) Pay Fewer Taxes: Converting Property to Benefit from Depreciation Deductions

By: Nikolajs Gaikis

I want to pay more taxes . . . said no entrepreneur ever! Paying taxes is an unavoidable part of entrepreneurship. After all, the Internal Revenue Service (”IRS”) is essentially a partner in your business. Unlike your actual partners, you would like to pay the IRS as little as possible. Fortunately, an easy legal solution exists!   

Most entrepreneurs start their businesses using their personal property, like their cars, homes, or office furniture. These entrepreneurs may be eligible for depreciation deductions that lower their businesses’ taxable income over many years. This blog post will explain what property conversion is and depreciation deductions are, how to convert your property, how to determine the fair market value of your converted property, and how to determine depreciation deduction eligibility.  

what is conversion and depreciation?

Conversion is the process in which a taxpayer changes the tax classification of their property from personal use to business use or vice versa. After converting your property to business use, a taxpayer may claim various deductions, if they meet certain requirements. Deductions reduce a taxpayer’s taxable income.  

Depreciation deductions are a type of deduction that spreads the cost of your property purchase over time by lowering your taxable income. With depreciation, a taxpayer deducts a set amount of the property’s total cost each year until their deductions equal their cost. 

converting your personal property to business use

Converting property from personal use to business use requires two steps. First, your property must be a capital asset. Capital assets are property for which the normal utility is longer than one year. Second, your use of the property must be motivated by profit. That’s it, your property is converted! Taxpayers may also partially convert their property to business use. A common example is a taxpayer’s partial use of their home for business. 

Let’s focus on homes for a bit. Generally, a taxpayer must use part of their home (which includes separate structures) exclusively and regularly as their principal place of their trade or business. Alternatively, a taxpayer must use part of their home exclusively and regularly as a place to meet and deal with clients in the normal course of their trade or business. Meeting either of these requirements can convert a part of your home to business use. 

determining the fair market value of your property at conversion

Once an entrepreneur converts their property to business use, they must determine the property’s value at the time of conversion. The IRS requires the entrepreneur to estimate in good faith the fair market value (“FMV”) of their property at the time of conversion. You could easily estimate the FMV of a car by searching on appraisal websites, like Kelly Blue Book. However, if you’re converting your fancy office chair or something unique, a good-faith FMV estimate will suffice. 

For your home, you could use Zillow to estimate its FMV. Next, determine the square footage (“SQFT”) for both your home and the room(s) you are using for business. Divide the room(s)’s SQFT by the SQFT of the home. Next, multiply that number by your home’s FMV. 

$100,000 Zillow FMV of your home. 

100 SQFT business room ÷ 1000 SQFT home =  0.1 

0.1 x $100,000 = $10,000  

$10,000 is the FMV of the business room. You may be eligible to depreciate this. 

determining whether your business property is eligible for depreciation

Great, now you’ve converted your property to business use. Determining whether your property is depreciable is the fun part where you pay less tax! 

First, you must identify whether the property is a capital asset. Remember, capital assets are property for which the useful life is longer than one year. Second, you must use your capital property in your trade or business. This step should be easy because if you are following this blog, you have already begun exclusively using your property for your business. Finally, your property must wear and tear. Broadly speaking, anything you physically use as an entrepreneur wears and tears, including buildings. 

Determining the exact depreciation deduction for your taxes is complicated. It merits its own blog post. Luckily, the IRS had already created a helpful step-by-step guide. When determining your exact depreciation deduction, a tax professional can be very helpful. 

other important things to note 

Entrepreneurs that take advantage of property conversion and depreciation deductions should keep careful records. First, you should document the FMV of the property at the time you converted it. Furthermore, you should always record the time when you abandoned the personal use of your property. Along this same vein, entrepreneurs should never use their converted property for personal use. If you are audited, your failure to comply with depreciation requirements or maintain records could result in the IRS demanding back tax payments, interest, and penalties on the income you deducted. 

If your business is organized as anything other than a sole proprietorship, you may need to officially transfer the title of the converted property over to your business. This is because you own the property and your LLC, partnership, or corporation doesn’t unless it holds the title. This is the case even if you are the sole member of an LLC or the sole owner of a corporation. 

Finally, perhaps you previously converted your property to business use and you failed to claim depreciation deductions. The IRS allows taxpayers to amend their returns for refunds for up to three prior taxable years. You better get on it! 

take away for entrepreneurs 

Converting personal property to business use and claiming depreciation deductions is an awesome way to lower your taxable income without expense purchases for your new business. Remember, you must follow all the rules. Hiring a tax professional is always a good idea. Good luck, and happy depreciating! 

 This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on January 22, 2023 and can be found here.


Nikolajs Gaikis, at the time of this post, is a second-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. He has interned with the United States Attorney’s Office and the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General Bureau of Consumer Protection. This summer, he will be a Summer Associate at Dentons Cohen & Grigsby in Pittsburgh. He is also an Associate Editor of the Dickinson Law Review. Nikolajs earned his Bachelor of Musical Arts from Roosevelt University, where he studied French Horn with Jon Boen, Principal Horn of the Chicago Lyric Opera Orchestra.

 

Sources 

See IRC § 168. 

See 26 C.F.R. § 1.168(i)-4 (2021). 

https://www.inc.com/jana-kasperkevic/us-entrepreneurs-keep-businesses-close-to-home.html https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc509 

https://www.irs.gov/publications/p946 

https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc704 

https://www.irs.gov/filing/amended-return-frequently-asked-questions 

Intellectual Property Basics for Entrepreneurs

By: Pranita Dhungana

How many Intellectual Property (“IP”) markers can you spot around yourself? 

I see the DELL icon on my laptop, my employer’s logo on my water bottle, the Nike checkmark on my socks, Dove chocolates, the Apple logo on my iPad, and 21 more on my desk alone. 

IP is a critical business asset. The examples above alone illustrate that one of the functions of IP is to identify and distinguish the brand. For example, I didn’t buy just any tablet – I specifically chose an iPad because of the qualities and features associated with Apple. 

IP protection should be a consideration right from the beginning of your business to protect your intangible assets from competitors, as well as to create a distinct brand identity. Here are the four main types of IP, and how they interface with business:

1. trademark

A trademark is a word, logo, or package design that identifies the source of the goods or services, such as the examples above. Companies invest significantly on advertising to create a unique and recognizable brand identity, and trademark is a tool to reinforce and protect that. 

In addition to identifying your brand, trademarks also provide legal protection against counterfeiting. For example, another tablet manufacturer cannot use the Apple logo because Apple has the exclusive rights to its trademarks, which allows Apple to pursue legal remedies against counterfeiters. Such protection bars competitors from benefiting off of your brand image, and ensures that your consumers are not misled. 

The only requirement for trademark protection is actual use, for example, in advertising or packaging. However, national registration is still desirable because it provides nationwide protection, while a non-registered trademark provides protection only within its geographic area of use. Additionally, state registration can also be useful as it provides notice of your trademark to local businesses. 

Among other requirements, a registrable trademark must be unique and non-misleading. In addition, a trademark must not simply describe the goods or services. For example, “The Bookstore” would not be a registrable trademark for a bookstore. 

💡New business owners should consider trademark registration requirements when picking a company name and logo to create a unique and legally protected brand identifier. 

2. copyright

Copyright protects artistic and literary works like books, movies, and music. In the business context, it also protects original and creative works like software, video games, documents, and marketing materials. A copyright owner has the exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, display, and derive from their copyrighted work. Such exclusive rights allow you to issue a license to others to use your work. Depending on your business, a licensing fee can be a lucrative source of income. A common example is software license. 

Copyright protection does not require national registration. Copyright exists from the moment an eligible work is created. For example, a book enjoys copyright protection from the moment it is written. However, registration is desirable because it allows you to sue infringers, and makes certain monetary damages available in case of infringement. In addition, registration makes licensing the work easier. 

A copyrightable work must be minimally creative and not be copied from an existing work. Additionally, copyright protects the particular expression, and not the underlying idea. For example, if you write a book on bee-keeping, you have exclusive rights to that book, but not to the idea of bee-keeping. 

💡New business owners should register copyrights for original, creative works to preserve exclusivity in such works, and to make licensing easier. 

3. patent

Patent protects inventions, designs, and asexually reproduced plants. Some famous patented inventions include the electric lightbulb, Apple’s first personal computer, GPS technology, CRISPR gene editing, and the shaving razor. 

Unlike with trademarks and copyrights, patent protection is harder to obtain, is more expensive, and can take a few years. A patent is granted by the U.S. government only after a rigorous, technical examination of a patent application to ensure that the invention meets all the patentability requirements. A patentable invention must be man-made as opposed to natural, new, useful, and not an obvious combination of existing inventions. 

A patent gives you a limited monopoly right over your invention, meaning that others cannot make, use, or sell the patented invention during that time. Patenting your product will ensure an exclusive market for a limited time, during which your product enjoys zero competition. In addition, if you have ever seen Shark Tank, you must already know that patents also enhance your business’s credibility. This is likely because the rigorous patent examination process gives the impression of government approval. Speaking of Shark Tank, the limited exclusive right to sell the invention can also attract potential investors. 

💡New business owners should patent their inventions as soon as possible to obtain a limited monopoly over the market, enhance credibility, and attract potential investors. 

4. trade secret

Trade Secret, as the name suggests, protects secret business information. It protects almost any information that is valuable because it is not known and is sufficiently secret, such as formula, process, software, recipe, customer list, budget plan, marketing data. The two most famous trade secrets are Google’s search algorithm and Coca-Cola’s recipe. 

Trade secret protection requires only that the information actually be secret. The obvious benefit of a trade secret is that your competitor cannot access that information to gain a competitive advantage over you. Ask yourself, do you use a search engine other than Google’s? 

💡 New business owners should take affirmative steps to keep secret business information confidential because such information can obtain trade secret protection, thereby providing a competitive advantage. 

I hope this blog has helped you think about your business’s IP needs. Because IP is a crucial business asset, please work with a lawyer to better understand the specific registration requirements and processes.  

💡Miscellaneous IP considerations: It is important to periodically assess whether your business is infringing on others’ IP. Additionally, if you hire employees, their employment contracts would ideally transfer IP rights in any company-related work that they create back to the company. 

 

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 7, 2023 and can be found here.


Pranita Dhungana, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law, and has a B.S. in Chemistry. She will be pursuing Intellectual Property law upon graduation.

 

 

Sources:

https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=88d72fd7-c1ca-4da3-bf0b-55a63c567872

https://www.uspto.gov/ip-policy/trade-secret-policy

https://www.wipo.int/tradesecrets/en/

https://info.vethanlaw.com/blog/trade-secrets-10-of-the-most-famous-examples

Conducting a Risk Assessment for your New Business

By: Jaiden Moore

Running a business involves a variety of risks. Some of these risks have the power to completely dismantle a business, while others have the power to seriously damage it, making repairs expensive and time-consuming. Business owners, no matter how big or small the business is, may foresee and plan for risks that are inherent in doing business. Risks are being taken by small business owners every day. However, putting too much at stake could affect your net income. To ensure that you are making the right decisions, conduct a risk assessment for your small business.

While many people are involved in the process and several factors are considered, executing a thorough risk assessment boils down to three main components: risk identification, risk analysis, and risk review.

 risk identification 

To properly address hazards and risks in the workplace, they must first be correctly identified. The goal of risk identification is to identify what, where, when, why, and how a situation can hinder a company’s ability to function. For example, a business located near the Gulf of Mexico would list “the potential for hurricanes” as an occurrence that could interfere with normal business operations. This will enable you to minimize harmful risks before they arise.

here are some ways that a small business owner can identify risks:

Brainstorming: 

To brainstorm is to take a holistic view of the business you are developing. In doing this, you want to think about any challenges you anticipate as well as anything that you are unsure about.

Thinking Pessimistically:

Generally, pessimists have a gloomy or skeptical outlook. While pessimism is typically not encouraged in the workplace, asking yourself “what is the worst thing that could possibly happen to the business” is a good way to identify risks.

Imagining Yourself in the Employee’s Shoes: 

Even if you are a new business owner and currently operate as the sole employee, employee perceptions of a business’s dangers can be very different from those of the business owner. In their regular work activities, employees can come across new threats that were not previously noticed or anticipated. As a result, putting yourself in the employee’s shoes can give you a good sense of what could go wrong.

risk analysis

After you have identified potential risks, you must prioritize them in accordance with an assessment of their likelihood of occurrence. With this in mind, establish a probability scale for the purposes of risk assessment.

For example, risks may:

  1. Be very likely to occur;
  2. Be somewhat likely to occur;
  3. Have a small chance of occurring; or
  4. Have little to no chance of occurring.

Failure to appropriately assess risk likelihood can have serious implications. If you underestimate the likelihood of an incident, you might not take the appropriate preventative measures, which can result in expensive mishaps or even fatalities. The opposite is also true: if you overestimate the likelihood of an event, you could take unnecessary precautions that cost you time and money.

risk review

Once you have established a list of potential business risks and determined each risk’s likelihood of occurrence, detail them in a document. Develop a method to evaluate the impact of each risk, then consider the extent of the potential harm and the difficulty of recovery. Determine the controls you may apply to limit potential risks. To predict your revenue cycle, look at patterns over time. Additionally, evaluate the effect risks have on your business, and consider a risk’s importance as well as the possibility that it will affect your business.

Periodically review your risks. Your risk assessment is not a one-time commitment; it is instead an ongoing an ongoing responsibility. At the end of each year, you should evaluate your risk management procedures to assess how you manage risks. Additionally, keep an eye out for emerging risks that may not have been significant during the prior evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Risk assessments are an essential component of managing a business. Your business risk assessment can be used to inform decisions about funding. A quick risk assessment will assist you in avoiding problems that could impact your finances. You learn from the assessment what actions you should take to safeguard your company. This will enable you to recognize the situations you need to deal with, and steer clear of. In addition to helping you internally, a financial risk assessment can aid in your readiness for financer interactions. Before lending you money, these people want to know how risky your business is. They consider the potential of your business expanding as well as your likelihood of repaying the loan. By putting the aforementioned risk assessment methods into practice, you may control any potential risk to your business. Prepare your risk assessment plan so that you can take the time to identify and manage the risks that your company faces.

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on January 31, 2023 and can be found here.


Jaiden Moore, at the time of this post, is a second-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. He has a B.A. in Liberal Studies from North Carolina A&T State University, and is interested in civil litigation. Jaiden is Treasurer of the International law society and is a member of the Black Law Students Association as well as the Business Law Society at Dickinson Law.

 

 

Sources: 

https://safetymanagement.eku.edu/blog/risk-identification/

https://www.assp.org/news-and-articles/conducting-a-risk-assessmenthttps://www.patriotsoftware.com/blog/accounting/small-business-risk-analysis-assessment-purpose/

https://www.projectmanagement.com/contentPages/article.cfm?ID=274371&thisPageURL=/articles/274371/Brainstorming-Risk#_=_

https://www.berkeleywellbeing.com/pessimism.html#:~:text=Pessimists%20typically%20have%20a%20gloomy,t%20willing%20to%20take%20risks.

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/financial-theory/09/risk-management-business.asp

https://www.lucidchart.com/blog/risk-assessment-process

Small Businesses Incentivized to Go Green

By: Lisa Dang

Small business and start-up companies incur a variety of costs to operate their businesses. However, no matter the size of a business, energy consumption ranks among the top five business expenses. The primary use of energy includes operating vehicles, heating and cooling, and operating equipment. The ability to cut down on fixed costs such as utilities may significantly improve cash flow. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), the average monthly utility bill for commercial buildings is $650 per month with the northeast region averaging a higher cost of $727 per month. The cost of electricity and natural gas is only expected to rise in the coming years and remain volatile. Whether your company has been in operation for years or is beginning to get off the ground, managing and saving on energy costs is not only beneficial for the business but also for the environment. With the recent enactment of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), small businesses are incentivized to deploy clean energy technology to reap significant cost-saving benefits.

I. The inflation reduction act 

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) is a landmark piece of legislation, representing the largest climate and energy spending package in U.S History.[3] The IRA mandates a nationwide reduction of carbon emissions of roughly 40% by 2030 and includes an investment of $369 billion in energy and security climate change programs. Here is how the IRA can help your business reduce energy costs and foster a cleaner environment.

1. The Deploying Solar

Small businesses and start-up companies can reap significant tax breaks from purchasing and deploying solar energy systems. The IRA expanded the Federal Tax Credit for Solar Photovoltaics (PV) systems. There are two available solar tax credit options available for businesses:

        • Investment tax credit (ITC): provides a tax credit that allows businesses to deduct a percentage of the cost of installing a solar energy system from their federal income tax liability
        • Production Tax Credit (PTC): provides a per kilowatt-hour (kWh) tax credit based on the amount of electricity generated and sold by qualified energy projects

 

Under the IRA, the ITC enables business owners to receive a one-time 30% tax credit for PV system installation. In contrast, the solar PTC can be claimed every year over the 10-year credit period at the current rate of 2.6 cents/kWh for commercial projects (adjusted for inflation). The size of the system must be under 1 megawatt (MW) to claim an ITC or PTC, and project owners cannot claim both credits for the same property. Projects may qualify for additional bonus credits of 10% if located in a low-income area.

It is important to note that these tax credits are only available for solar systems placed in service from 2022 or later and begin construction before 2033. These credits are designed to phase out after 2032, thus it is critical that small businesses begin strategizing how to support the deployment of solar technology sooner rather than later.

A. Which is Better for My Business: ITC or PTC? 

The decision to choose an ITC or PTC depends on multiple variables. Start-up companies or small businesses that may be cash-strapped may benefit from opting for the ITC, providing upfront credit against the capital expense used to install the solar systems. In most cases, the ITC is a great option for small businesses that require only a small PV system to help save money on energy bills. In contrast, larger-scale PV projects should opt for the PTC because they provide an attractive cash flow since credits are earned over time. Ultimately, PTCs and ITCs provide competitive incentives and cash flow opportunities for many small businesses and start-up companies.

B. What if My Business Does Not Have the Capital to Invest in Solar Technology?

In cases where your business does not have the capital to invest and own a solar system, it is still possible to reap significant cost-saving benefits on utilities through power purchasing agreements (PPA). For many businesses, entering into a third-party PPA is the best option to help reduce energy costs with little to no startup investment associated with the solar installation. A solar PPA is a financing agreement in which a third-party developer purchases the solar system, installs it on your workplace building, and charges a reduced fee for the electricity generated. While your business may not claim the tax credit under a PPA, the developer may claim the tax credit and may use that tax credit to help lower your monthly payment.

2. Electric Vehicles

 

For the first time in the U.S., the IRA provides a tax credit for businesses purchasing qualified electric vehicles (EVs). The credit is up to $7,500 for new EVs and the vehicle must be used for business purposes, not for resale, and primarily used in the U.S.

For a vehicle to qualify for the tax credit, the vehicle must:

        • Have an external charging source
        • Have a gross vehicle weight rating of less than 14,000 lbs
        • Be made by a qualified manufacturer

If you are unsure whether your vehicle will qualify for a tax credit, the Department of Energy has made it easy by simply entering your vehicle identification number (VIN). Check it out here.

II. Conclusion 

All businesses must factor in the cost of utilities and energy consumption. With energy prices rising and fluctuating at unpredictable rates, the switch to solar energy can save small businesses and start-up companies significant money. Now, more than ever, businesses are incentivized to go green with the recent enactment of the Inflation Reduction Act. Businesses that take advantage of the solar opportunities and EV tax credits are situated to not only save money but help save the environment.

 

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on January 31, 2023 and can be found here.


Lisa Dang, at the time of this post, is a 3L at Penn State–Dickinson Law. Dang hails from Richmond, Virginia, and graduated from the College of William and Mary with a BS in Neuroscience and Philosophy. Before coming to law school, Dang worked as a Research Assistant in the division of Hematology, Oncology & Palliative Care at Virginia Commonwealth University. Dang has a wide-range of interests and has been exploring many different classes and areas of law. In between work and school, Dang plays competitive Ultimate Frisbee.

Sources:

The Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. § 1531 et seq.

Id. § 1532.

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/03/11/2022-05134/civil-penalties-2022-inflation-adjustments-for-civil-monetary-penalties

Choosing a Business Entity for Your HUD Insured Real Estate Investment

By: Emily Ameel

Investing in affordable housing is a necessary step in community development and advancement. The Federal Housing Administration’s (“FHA”) Multifamily Mortgage Insurance program is one of many programs facilitated by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) to secure the advancement of affordable rental housing in the United States. Under the FHA loan program, HUD provides mortgage insurance for loans issued by FHA-approved lenders for the construction, rehabilitation, acquisition, and refinancing of affordable and market-rate multifamily housing. A property must contain five or more rental units to be eligible for the FHA Multifamily Mortgage Insurance Program. FHA Insured properties are not subject to income limits unless the property is operating under an additional state or federal affordable housing program, such as receiving Section 8 subsidies or Low -Income Housing Tax Credits (“LIHTC”).

Under the FHA Multifamily guidelines, the mortgagor (also referred to as the borrower) of any FHA-insured project must be a single asset entity (also referred to as a single purpose entity or “SPE”), meaning that the subject property must be the sole asset of the mortgagor entity. HUD has established entity types that are acceptable forms of SPEs for participation in the FHA Multifamily Mortgage Insurance program, some of which are more popular than others. An investor must weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each entity type to determine which will be best for their real estate investment.

Popular Entity Types for the fha multifamily mortgage insurance program:

The General Partnership (“GP”) 

A real estate investor may form a general partnership as the mortgagor for their FHA Insured Multifamily project. A general partnership is composed of two or more general partners who share in the management of the company. General partnerships are known as the “default” business entity, as they can be formed with subjective intent by the partners and do not require formal state filing for formation. General partnerships enjoy the benefits (and sometimes drawbacks) of pass-through taxation, meaning that the income of the entity is “passed through” to the general partners, who must report the income on their individual tax returns.

Drawbacks of the general partnership include the lack of liability protection. All general partners of a general partnership can be held personally liable for the debts of the business. As stated above, general partners share in the management of the business but can also bind each other, making it so that each general partner shares in liability.

The Limited Partnership (“LP”)

The limited partnership is similar to the general partnership. Limited partnerships consist of one or more general partners and one or more limited partners. General partners in a limited partnership control the management and operation of the business and are personally liable for the debts of the business. Limited partners act as investors in the business, have no control over management, and are only liable for business debts up to the amount of their investment. Limited Partnerships are also pass-through taxation entities. The limited partnership is a popular entity for affordable housing developments that receive LIHTC funding, as 99.99% of the interest is typically held for a limited partner tax credit investor.

The Limited Liability Company (“LLC”)

Another popular option for investors is the Limited Liability Company. The LLC is composed of managers and members. Managers have management rights in the LLC, and members are like investors. In a typical HUD transaction, an LLC will have either a manager who is not a member and owns 0% interest in the entity or a “managing member” who is both an interest-holding member and a manager of the LLC. Additionally, LLCs provide liability protections for managers and members. LLCs are popular options for new real estate investors because they can be owned and managed by a single “managing member” individual and provide that individual with liability protection. LLCs are easy to form, with most states requiring only a few documents for formation and registration. Like general partnerships and limited partnerships, the LLC is subject to pass-through taxation. Some states do require annual reporting and fees to maintain active status.

The Corporation (“S-Corp” or “C-Corp”)

HUD also allows corporations to act as the SPE mortgagor. Corporations are composed of corporate officers and owners called shareholders. Corporate officers may also be shareholders of the corporation. Like LLCs and LPs, corporations enjoy liability protections for their officers and shareholders. For taxation purposes, C-Corps and S-Corps are treated differently. S-Corps enjoy pass-through taxation like LLCs and partnerships. C-Corps are faced with “double taxation,” where both the corporation and shareholders are taxed on the business income. Corporations must follow corporate formalities, such as holding regular meetings, recording meeting minutes, and maintaining corporate governance documents.

Other Approved Entities:

Although less popular, HUD also allows the following entity types to act as SPE mortgagors:

        • Trust with beneficiaries and one or more trustees (where the duration of the trust is greater than or equal to the FHA Note);
        • Nonprofit corporations;
        • Joint ventures

Choosing (and forming) a mortgagor entity for your multifamily investment property is one of the many steps required to participate in the FHA Multifamily program. Consulting with an attorney to make an informed decision as to which entity type is suitable for your investment is imperative, as the mortgagor’s entity structure and organizational documents will be subject to lengthy due diligence review in the approval process.

 

This post has been reproduced and updated with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 2, 2023 and can be found here.


Emily Ameel, at the time of this post, is a second-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. She has a B.S. in Psychology and a B.A. in Women’s Studies from the University of Georgia. Prior to attending law school, Emily worked on Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) transactions as a third party consultant. She intends to pursue a career in affordable housing upon graduation. In her free time, she enjoys distance running.

 

Sources:

https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/mfh/progdesc/rentcoophsg221d3n4

https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/mfh/progdesc/purchrefi223f

HUD Handbook 4350.1 – FHA Multifamily Housing Policy

 

How to Start Up: Picking the Perfect Name for Your Business

By: Julia Martinez

Let’s talk about naming your business. As you would expect, branding can make or break a project. 82% of investors say name recognition is an important factor guiding them in their investment decisions, and brands with poor company branding pay 10% higher salaries. A name is a long-term commitment, and can be a daunting task – it took Warby Parker six months and over 2,000 options to find their brand’s perfect name.

You’ve probably seen ads online for business-name generators or “brand identity toolkits.” There are both free and paid tools all over the internet that can suggest names, domains, and URLs. In addition to the branding criteria, try the free tools available at the end of the article for inspiration in choosing the perfect name.

three important criteria for a brand name 

1. Memorable

A 2010 study found that consumers have a more positive reaction to brands with repetitively structured names, like Kit-Kat and Coca-Cola. You want something that reflects who you are, what you’re trying to achieve, and what sets you apart.

2. Accessible 

One of the reasons why picking a name can be so difficult! There really is a sweet spot between unique and bizarre. If your brand name is too hard to interpret or pronounce (or more importantly, Google) you’re going to run into problems with brand recognition.

3. Evolvable

Ask yourself these two questions: Is the name something you can eventually trademark and own? And is it a name that can grow with your company and stay relevant to your offered products or services?

vetting your name 

Once you get a short list of names together, you will want to determine whether or not any of the names are taken. You don’t have to trademark your business name to run business activity under it, but you do need to register a business if you start any sort of commercial activity, like promoting goods or services. If that’s the case, your business needs to be registered and you’ll need to receive a Tax ID before you can legally operate business activity.

It should be noted that the registered business name chosen doesn’t have to be the same as your business it just needs to be an available name. In other words, you can have your registered name be completely different from your public name – just make sure that your public name isn’t trademarked by someone else! Technically, you can use the same business name as someone else if the name isn’t protected by a trademark. However, if both businesses are in the same geographical location or sell similar goods and services, it is not recommended.

checking trademarks

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)’s Trademark Electronic Search System is the best way to search for all applied-for and registered trademarks. If the name is available, filing a trademark for a business name with the USPTO costs between $50 and $600, depending on if you’re registering the trademark in one state, multiple states, and the type of trademark being registered. Note that if you’re a foreign-domiciled applicant, you are required to hire a U.S.-licensed attorney to represent you at the USPTO.

do i need a trademark?

As mentioned earlier, you can legally run a business without any registered trademarks. But going without a trademark is operating without legal protection – you risk potential lawsuits from other companies of similar names in the future, and you risk your name being copied by others. Trademarks won’t only protect the brand name, but they can protect your logo, slogan, or other related intellectual property.

what can’t i trademark?

You can’t trademark descriptive terms, so any generic words, slogans, colors, smells, and sounds cannot be registered with the USPTO. If it’s a non-generic word, you could register it, but you would need to demonstrate how it represents the business.

Inventions and works of authorship (like writings, reports, drawings, sculptures, illustrations, video recordings, audio recordings, computer programs, and charts) cannot be trademarked and need to be protected with either copyrights or patents instead.

online naming tools

Now that you know some of the basic rules around naming your brand, it’s time to get brainstorming! The links below are some great examples of online tools that can help you to come up with the perfect brand name, domain name, and URL. Just remember – your brand name should be memorable, accessible, and evolvable.

For Names: Shopify, Wordoid

For URLS: Brand Bucket

For Domains: Bust a Name, Panabee

 

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on February 9, 2022.


Julia Martinez, at the time of this post, is a third-year law student at Penn State Dickinson Law. She has a B.A. in Criminal Justice and Political Science from Temple University, and has interests in criminal, civil, and administrative law. Julia is President of the Latinx Law Student Association, a 3L Class Representative, and Treasurer of Phi Alpha Delta.

 

Sources:

https://www.smallbizgenius.net/by-the-numbers/branding-statistics/#gref

https://www.quora.com/How-was-the-name-Warby-Parker-chosen

https://businessnamegenerator.com/how-to-find-out-if-a-business-name-is-taken-available/

https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/why-hire-private-trademark-attorney

Finding the Right Lawyer for Your Business: Part II

By: Lauren Stahl

Fancy awards, badges, and seals are not indicative of a great lawyer. And awards are not all created equal. Business owners should heed caution when looking at lists of awards on a lawyer’s website. A deeper discussion of these so-called “vanity” or “ego” awards can be found in Part I.

Finding a lawyer for your business does not have to be a daunting task. But where should you look to find a lawyer? What questions should you ask? Consider the following advice when searching for the right lawyer for your business.

Where should you start looking?

A great place to start looking for a lawyer is the American Bar Association (“ABA”). The ABA’s website has a great deal of information not only for professionals but also consumers who have legal questions. The ABA specifically has a “Hire a Lawyer” section. On this page, you can find public-service oriented referral services and other tools, such as bar directories, that can help you find a qualified lawyer.

Beyond the ABA’s website, you can search for a lawyer by city and state via a commercial lawyer referral service, such as FindLaw. Similar services are also listed on the ABA’s website.

what are the minimal skills your lawyer should have?

Depending on the type of business you have, you may need a lawyer with the following set of foundational skills:

Contracts. You will need a lawyer who is familiar with your business practices and can prepare contracts between your business and clients, suppliers, and customers. You will also need a lawyer to help you respond to contracts that other parties will want you to agree to.

Taxes and licenses. If your business is in the startup phase, you will need a lawyer who knows how to register your business for state and federal identification numbers. Beyond that, you will a lawyer who understands the tax implications of various business transactions that your business will engage in.

Business organizations. Depending on the stage of your business, you may need a lawyer to advise you on what type of business entity to form (e.g., corporation vs. limited liability company (LLC)). This lawyer should be able to discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each entity and to prepare any paperwork associated with formation.

Real estate. If you are leasing a commercial space for your business, the lease is likely complex and drafted to benefit the landlord. A lawyer with some real estate experience should have a standard “tenant’s addendum” that contains provisions to benefit your business. These provisions can be added to the standard “print form” lease document.

Intellectual property. If you have a media, design, or other creative business, a lawyer who has experience with registering products and services for federal trademark and copyright protection will certainly be helpful. Typically, these tasks are performed by lawyers who specialize in intellectual property. If your lawyer specializes in small businesses, then she likely has a working relationship with a lawyer who specializes in intellectual property.

whaT questions do you need to ask potential lawyers?

When interviewing potential lawyers for your business, don’t be afraid to ask direct questions. Here are a few examples of questions to ask:

Are you well-connected in the area? No lawyer can know everything about every area of the law. But a lawyer should be able to find solutions to your legal problems and refer you to lawyers who specialize in certain areas if needed. If your business has specialized legal needs, the right lawyer for your business should either be familiar with that area or have a working relationship with someone who is. This will prevent you from having to find a new lawyer every time you encounter a different legal problem.

Do you have other clients in my industry? The right lawyer will be somewhat familiar with the legal environment of your industry. If not, a lawyer should be willing to learn. One thing to consider is whether the lawyer represents one or more of your competitors. While lawyers must abide by principles such as client confidentiality, you do not want to risk an accidental slip of sensitive information to a competitor.

Are you experienced? It is important to ask direct questions about a lawyer’s experience. For example, if you know that you want to form an LLC, you might want to ask questions about her experience forming and handling other LLCs. 

How do you educate your clients? A lawyer should be willing to tell you what the law says and explain how it affects your business. A lawyer should be a teacher and take the time to educate you and your staff about legal matters directly impacting business operations. The right lawyer might also distribute newsletters or legal reports that describe recent. developments in the law that impact your business.

what questions do you need to ask yourself?

After interviewing potential lawyers for your business, you will also need to reflect on the interview and should ask yourself questions when determining if this lawyer is the right one for your business. For example:

Do I like this person? You should be able to communicate openly and freely with your lawyer. Trust your instincts and feelings. If you feel that you cannot trust a certain lawyer, keep looking.

Does this person communicate with me? The right lawyer will not simply tell you what you cannot do but will tell you how to do what it is that you want to do. She will discuss all available options. The right lawyer will tell you what other businesses in your situation normally do.

Is her office conveniently located? While it might be easier to meet with your lawyer remotely, consider whether you would like to meet with your lawyer in person. If so, you likely will need to visit your lawyer often in the first few years of business. Choosing a lawyer relatively close to you or your business might be beneficial to avoid wasting travel time every time you need legal advice.

main takeaway

While there is no “right” way to find an attorney or “right” question to ask, it is possible to find the right lawyer for your business. Many small businesses wait until a problem has already occurred to hire a lawyer. Don’t be one of them.

This post has been reproduced with the author’s permission. It was originally authored on April 2022, and can be found here.


Lauren Stahl, at the time of this post, is a rising 3L at Penn State Dickinson Law. She has a B.S. in Biology from Georgetown University. Formerly a medical researcher at the National Institutes of Health and Penn State College of Medicine, Lauren has interests in the intersection of health law and business law. Lauren currently serves as a Comments Editor of the Dickinson Law Review and is a member of the Health Law Society and Women’s Law Caucus. She is also Professor Prince’s Team Lead and the Lead TA for the Legal Writing program.

Sources:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/basharubin/2014/11/14/small-business-expert-how-do-you-find-and-pick-a-lawyer/?sh=31190c8b138a

https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_education/resources/public-information/how-do-i-find-a-lawyer-/

https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/58326