The theory seems to make sense. Stereotypically, the girl always seems to fall for the macho “man’s man” over the shy, passive nice guy. At least, this is what Hollywood and social media tends to depict in popular culture. However, naysayers of this common adage may be surprised by recent study results coming out of the US.
A very sad man once said, “Why do girls always complain that all guys are jerks, then date jerks when there are intelligent, sweet men like me dying for a girlfriend?” Well, a new study shows that this guy may be outta luck.
The study in question was conducted in a Tanzanian chimp reserve by Arizona State University Anthropologist Ian Gilby. The scientists hypothesized that female chimps would be more attracted to the aggressive male chimps, and therefore, reproduce with them more often than non-aggressive chimps. This study was observational, and scientists ended up observing that the “males who directed aggression towards females at higher rates were more likely to sire those females’ offspring.”
Nice men, don’t lose hope yet. There are a number of things that may show this study to be unreliable. Firstly, the study is not the most reliable sort. Being observational brings forth the issue of being less thorough than any sort of experiment or double-blind placebo trial, which wouldn’t quite be possible with this sort of hypotheses.
Additionally, the details of the study are muddy. Specifically, what did the researchers use to determine aggression in males? What was judged to be the difference between passive and violent? It’s also worth pointing out that the article did not disclose whether the aggressive males and the passive males were given the same access to females, which would obviously affect which group the females would end up mating with. The study was not conducted multiple times, and this being an observational study, this data was only drawn once over a seventeen-year period.
Overall, despite the fact that this single study found that the females were more likely to mate with males who repeatedly abused them over several years, the conclusions we draw from this study don’t quite match up to what we’d expect from humans, and more importantly, the correlation between aggression and attractiveness is not established based on this single observational study alone. Nice guys, just stay nice.