We all feel guilty when we take a piece of chocolate cake from the dining commons, go to the creamery and order a cone of Peachy Paterno, or eat Chic-Fil-A from the Hub. And I know I feel exceptionally guilty if I don’t go to the gym or do some form of exercise on these days. This made me wonder about exercise, diet, and obesity. Obesity in America is on the rise. It’s a wonder to me as to whether or not anything is being done about this.
Referring to my question as to whether something is being done about the rise of obesity in America, we can look at this study on “Are Health Care Professionals Advising Obese Patients to Lose Weight?” done by Deborah A. Galuska, PhD; Julie C. Will, PhD; Mary K. Serdula, MD; and Earl S. Ford, MD. 12,835 adults that were 18 years or older, classified as obese, and visited their physician for a frequent, routine checkup during the 12 months prior to experiment were in question. Obesity in this experiment was considered to be anyone with a body mass index ≥30 kg/m2. It was concluded that 42% of participants said that their health care professional told them that they should lose weight. Female, middle aged, people with higher levels of education, that lived in the northeast, reported poorer perceived health, were more obese, and had diabetes mellitus were the ones who were more likely to receive advice from medical professionals. Those who were told to try to lose were trying sufficiently harder to lose it than those who were not. Less than 50% of the obese people tested were being advised to lose weight. If this is a threat to their bodies, why aren’t they all being told to lose weight?
What kind of strategies are people utilizing when attempting to lose weight? According to Kruger, Galuska, Serdula, and Jones, the most common ways to try to lose weight include: eating fewer calories, eating less fat, and exercising more. The less common strategies consist of: skipping meals, eating food supplements, joining a weight-loss program, taking diet pills, taking water pills or diuretics, or fasting for less than 24 hours.
With all these different weight-loss mechanisms, which is the best? And is it only one mechanism that will get a good result? Wing’s study asked these same questions. Wing found that 60% of studies found significantly greater weight loss in exercise alone in comparison to no treatment controls. 15.4% of studies found major differences in initial weight loss for diet and exercise versus diet only. In conclusion, Wing found that exercise for weight loss tends to be most effective, but there is not solid enough information to say that this is the most effective always. My guess is that this could be due third variables. Wing even offers that same idea.
So what does this mean?
- Obesity is on the rise in America.
- A medical professional advising someone to lose weight will prompt them to attempt to lose weight.
- The most common weight loss strategies are: eating fewer calories, eating less fat, and exercising more.
- Exercise alone has proven to be the most effective mechanism for weight-loss, but there is not enough data to prove that this is full proof.
We all have that friend…