Having a pet dog might be one of the best things on the planet. Even being in the presences of a dog (especially at college) is amazing. Dogs have an unexplainable quality about them that makes the irresistibly comforting. Their comforting quality allows them to be used to help adults with mental and physical health because they “encourage people to exercise and increase social interaction” (UPI). Because of this researchers at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention think that dogs can also help reduce childhood anxiety.
In past studies, dogs have been shown to reduce the risk of allergies and asthma in children which improves children’s immune systems by exposing them to allergens earlier in life. Now, researchers think that the constant playing, caretaking, social interaction and companionship has the ability to prevent anxiety and obesity that are usually rooted in childhood.
To conduct this study, 643 children between the ages of 4 and 10 from a clinic in upstate New York between July 2012 and December 2013 were surveyed before and after their annual check-up. The researchers collected age, sex, height, and weight information measured by the nurses. Only one child from each family could participate and the researchers excluded anyone who was ill or developmentally disabled. The survey included a number of questions about “somatic and mental health, nutrition, physical activity, parental depression, and whether or not the child has difficulties with emotions, attention, behavior or social interaction” (UPI). They were also asked whether the family had a pet. If the answer was yes, and they had a dog as a pet, more questions were asked about “how long the child had been exposed to the dog, physical activity with it, and how much time the child spent with the animal” (UPI). One potential flaw in this study is the fact that it is the parents had to answer the questions. It is possible that the parents were not truthful in areas such as “parental depression” or whether the child had difficulties with emotions, attention, behavior or social interaction. Another thing is that they might not be able to recall as much as they would life. It is possible that their memories are skewed. With this in mind, it could have effected the end result of the experiment.
Based on the survey, the researchers found that 57.5% of children had a pet dog and 42.5% did not. There was no significant difference in “BMI, screen time or physical activity between children with and without pet dogs” (UPI). To measure levels of anxiety researchers used the Screen for Child Anxiety and Related Disorders. They found that 21% of children without pet dogs scored above a 3, meaning that further assessment would indicate an anxiety diagnoses. Only 12% of children with dogs had a score of 3 or higher on the survey. There are defiantly many third confounding variables that could have effected the outcome, one of them, like I mentioned above, the parents were not 100% truthful when it came to the survey. Another thing could be whether or not anxiety ran in the family. An anxiety gene could run in the family and that family could still have a pet dog.
Researchers concluded that dogs could reduce childhood anxiety by encouraging conversation with other people, easing separation anxiety. They also found that dogs could increase oxytocin levels that reduce cortisol, which is the physiological responses to stress. Researchers would have to expand this study over a long period of time in order to really see if there is a real connection between dogs and childhood anxiety and compare those to a group that does not have dogs. Researchers wrote, “‘Because this was a cross-sectional study of associations, a correlational study, no cause or effect can be inferred.’ ‘It may be that less anxious children have pet dogs or pet dogs make children less anxious'”(UPI).
I found this study interesting because I did not grow up with a pet dog and have bad anxiety that developed when I was a child. However, anxiety runs in my family and I know many people who have dogs and also have anxiety. There are alot of factors that could have played a role in the outcome of this cross-sectional study. However, I think people can agree that dogs are very comforting especially in times of a distress so it is likely that dogs can reduce anxiety in children.